Is Hisarlik definitely the Homeric Troy?
Seems to be pretty much accepted as the site!
So...
What’s the evidence that it is? what’s the evidence that it’s not?
Thanks
The consensus is that the Homeric Troy and Trojan War is a literary invention, but that the Hisarlik Mound contains the remains of the city it was inspired by.
Here's a previous answer by /u/kookingpot that goes over some evidence: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3v6wzr/was_the_trojan_wars_epic_inspired_by_an_actual/cxkteyl/