Thomas Aquinas is quoted "Take away prostitutes from the world, and you will fill it with sodomy"; was there such benign indifference towards prostitution among church leaders of the 13th century, or are his views exceptional? What about among civil authorities?

by td4999
RunDNA

It should be pointed out that the quote is not actually by Aquinas.

Here's a translation of the relevant text in De Regimine Principum (On the Government of Rulers):

Thus, Augustine says that a whore acts in the world as the bilge in a ship or the sewer in a palace: "Remove the sewer, and you will fill the palace with a stench." Similarly, concerning the bilge, he says: "Take away whores from the world, and you will fill it with sodomy." [Book 4, Chapter 14]

As you can see, the passage is quoting (or more accurately, paraphrasing) Augustine.

And though the book was often included in Aquinas's collected works, only perhaps Book 1 and the first four chapters of Book 2 are by Aquinas. The rest of the work was probably written by Ptolemy of Lucca. The latter parts even mention the crowning of Albert I of Habsburg, an event which did not occur until 1298, twenty-four years after Aquinas's death.

And the quote we are talking about comes from Book 4, which is part of the work definitely not written by Aquinas.

Source:

Blythe, James M., trans. On the Government of Rulers: De Regimine Principum, by Ptolemy of Lucca, with portions attributed to Thomas Aquinas. The Middle Ages Series. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1997.