Why were Spanish Conquistadors so brutal towards indigenous?

by enlightendark

I'm reading Bartolomé de las Casas chronicle on the conquest of the Nueva España and it makes me sick. I was especially impressed by his witnessing of a Spanish soldier who, not finding anything for his hound to eat, took a toddler away from his mother, cut his arms off and fed the dog with them.

I understand that atrocities happened in every war, but the Spanish conquest of Mexico seems especially brutal to me. Also, I found that the Spaniards were not like that when they conquered the Kingdom of Granada, for example, nor during the Reconquista. I read about that a lot and, although horrors and death happened, I haven't found anything like feeding hounds with living children. I don't understand the reasons behind this different treatment of fallen enemies.

Have historians wondered about and studied the possible causes of this brutality? Were they influenced by the food? Was it the weather, illnesses? Weren't they on their minds? Were they extremely scared? What drove this inhuman behavior?

Nordic_ned

First I would point out that the story you described was supposed to take place in Cuba rather than Mexico, but really I just have some additional related questions.

  1. How much more brutal were the Spanish towards the natives compared to other non Christian enemies such as the the people of Granada?

  2. How did Spanish treatment of the natives vary? For example, did they treat the native Taino differently than they treated the Mexica or the Inca, for example?