What to do with a US vet's personal WW2 photo collection, which includes photos of WW2 German soldiers (while they were alive) that he got when he captured their camera (after his own tank knocked their Panther out and they were killed) and he then developed their pictures when he got home?

by mr_myke

A friend's father was a in a Tank Destroyer in Europe in WW2. His operational areas were incredible. D-day, Operation Goodwood, Huertgen Forest, crossing Bridge at Remagen while it stood, Liberating Nordhausen, right up to the Oder River at war's end. Because he was in the vehicle, he took his own photos throughout, throwing exposed rolls in a bag. All were developed when he got home. All beautifully sharp and pristine snapshots now rest in an old album.

TLDR: The short question is, the family has asked me, a WW2 enthusiast friend, to make recommendations on what they should do with it? They have made their copies, and want the originals to "go to some museum and be preserved." I applauded their instincts, and now seek input on choices to recommend. So that's the broad question, and thx in advance for input.

Now for other detail mentioned in my hopefully attention-getting headline...and a more narrow question, but one I think is more fascinating to consider. About 10 years ago, while this amazing vet was alive, I asked to meet him and talk. I knew he was "in a tank in WW2" but apparently that is most all he really ever said. No details to his family even, as well as my dad, who was his close friend.

After some careful prep, he opened up to me and brought out his album. I recorded hours of interviews. The album was incredible. But he didn't understand its significance. It IS significant. All the battles I mentioned are covered, except DDay is light (he was 6th wave, Utah Beach). All pics incredible, but some are jaw-dropping. The scenes at Nordhausen -- his unit was there w/in 24 hours after liberation -- are proof positive of the horrors, and the death, of the slave laborers in that system. The standing bridge at Remagen pics are among the best I have ever seen.

But my jaw fell most when, turning a page, I saw four clearly German soldiers posing with smiles in front of an operational Panther tank. They were in their all black wool unis; the Panther's unit insignia is clearly identifiable. Then more photos followed of these same soldiers, in casual and battlefield photos. The men are clearly facially identifiable. I asked the man what are these? In his standard gruff, but totally matter-of-fact way, he said, "Oh just some Krauts."

I asked, but why do you have them?? He shrugged, and explained. The next page showed a knocked out Panther. It was the same one. He said he took the camera off a dead crewman. He said he "liked it" and it had film left, so he shot the rest of the roll, then put it in his bag with all his others to be developed when he got home. And that's how these smiling German tankers are in a US Army vet's photo album from 1944.

Sadly, literally within weeks of these sessions, after I left to start editing the tapes and thinking of what to recommend happen to this album, the man passed. (A responder I know attended the EMT call to the local senior home. The vet dropped with a heart attack. As he lay on the floor, his last words were: "The f***ing Nazis didn't kill me, and this won't either." This, from a man who never spoke openly about his service -- after 60+ years, the thing at the top of his mind as he lay dying was the war. Just incredibly telling.)

After that, the family -- living distantly -- did not want to take the issue up, and I didn't force it. Now, flash ahead years later. They have reached out and asked the question I posed above. But I have another one. Does anyone have input on whether it would be worth it to try and ID those German soldiers? To try, perhaps, to return them to the families? If so, how would I start that (without going to Germany)? I have the battle diary of the US unit (Tank Destroyer 899). I am fairly certain where the tank kill occurred. The Panther photos are clear. I think the idea has a chance. But I am intimidated on where and how to start. The family does not appear to be interested in this angle. I believe I could get their agreement, but wouldn't want to try to convince them unless I have a realistic plan.

So that's it. Another TLDR. Two questions. What org is best to preserve and value an incredible collection of WW2 soldier personal photos of the European theatre from 1944-45? And, is there a legit interest, and path for success, in returning to their families the photos taken by German soldiers, who later died in the war, that were ultimately developed by the soldier who created this album? Thanks for considering!!

Mick_86

U.S. Army Heritage and Education Center at Carlisle PA might like to take them

E mail them at carl_ahec-acq@conus.army.mil

LongoSpeaksTruth

I would also pose this question here: https://www.reddit.com/r/GermanWW2photos/

oddist1

Might try The National WWII Museum in New Orleans. they have a phone number you can call to ask about artifact donations 504-528-1944 x 515

Its nice museum I spent a good part of day wandering around in it last time I was in NOLA