Today:
You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.
As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.
My piece on what Truman knew (and didn't) about Hiroshima as a target it published! It is chapter 3 in Michael D. Gordin and G. John Ikenberry, eds., The Age of Hiroshima (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2020). 5 years in the making, easily! And my first publication of the new decade. I think this my most historically contentious and interesting article I've ever published, and I'm quite proud of it.
If anyone wants a PDF of my article, send me a PM and we'll make it happen.
I'm now the new mod of r/writinghistory. Join us. I hope to make this a solid place to discuss researching and writing history.
How hard is acceptance into MA programs? I’m trying to do near eastern language and culture and I don’t really know how much published research I need to be a competitive candidate for admittance
I have a question.
The Serbs in 1995 wanted three enclaves or "islands" of ARBiH control in the middle of Republika Srpska control: Srebrenica, Žepa, and Goražde.
They then imprisoned 20000-25000 muslim women and children along with like 10000 muslim men.
Why did they choose to genocide them and not use these prisoners as leverage or bargaining chips to get the three enclaves they wanted?
It seems like every other genocide I explore there's a clear provocation or underlying reason behind it but this just seems incredibly stupid from a military standpoint and I can't find a reason why they would deviate from their goals just to genocide a group of people.
What sources do you historians think are under-used or under appriciated in your field of study? What can they bring 'extra'?
Your Weekly /r/askhistorians Recap
Friday, January 17 - Thursday, January 23
###Top 10 Posts
| score | comments | post |
|---|---|---|
| 3,972 | 485 comments | [Meta] Sub question - Why can't we have 'Answered' flairs!? |
| 3,738 | 53 comments | In 1604 there was a supernova that caused a star to be bright enough to be seen during day time. How was this interpreted at the time? Did any figures or groups try to capitalise on it for political or spiritual influence? |
| 3,669 | 121 comments | Did the Nazis look for mythological artifacts? |
| 3,529 | 34 comments | Karl Marx worked as a journalist for the New York Tribune for a decade (from 1852 to 1862). Would his American readers have been aware of his reputation as the author of The Communist Manifesto (1848) or his philosophical/political ideas? |
| 2,987 | 69 comments | In "A Knight's Tale", Edward the Black Prince disguises himself so that he may joust equally against other riders. When he is discovered, many of the riders dare not strike him given his lineage. Are there real life examples of this or were royalty treated just like any other competitor? |
| 2,951 | 46 comments | Nixon claimed that he would have destroyed the tapes had he thought they proved he did anything illegal. While President, he refused to hand them over until the Supreme Court made him. If Nixon didn’t think he did anything illegal, why did he so ardently refuse to hand them over? |
| 2,747 | 34 comments | The first short story of the Witcher series was published in 1986 during the last years of Communist Poland. What was the status of the fantasy genre during that time? Was it popular? Were certain topics censored? |
| 2,455 | 57 comments | Brown vs Board lead to firing of thousands of black teachers as schools were desegregated. Were many of these teachers also integrated into the newly mixed schools? |
| 2,067 | 84 comments | Why did the Roman military seemingly change from a high status institution in 2nd century, to become a low status institution by the 4th century. |
| 572 | 15 comments | Why did the KKK have such weird titles? |
###Top 10 Comments
If you would like this roundup sent to your reddit inbox every week send me a message with the subject 'askhistorians'. Or if you want a daily roundup, use the subject 'askhistorians daily'
However, I can do more.. you can have me search for any keywords you want on any subreddit you want. To customize the roundup, send a message with the subject 'custom askhistorians' and in the message: specify a number of upvotes that must be reached, and then an optional list of keywords you want to search for, separated by commas. You can have as many lines as you'd like, as long as they follow this format:
50, africa, germany, europe
You can also do 'custom askhistorians daily' And you can replace askhistorians with any subreddit.
See my wiki to learn more: click here
####Please let me know if you have suggestions to make this roundup better for /r/askhistorians or if there are other subreddits that you think I should post in. I can search for posts based off keywords in the title, URL and flair. And I can also search for comments.
Are there any other William Gibson fans out there? His latest book, Agency, just came out this past week. I'm currently about halfway through re-reading The Peripheral, but I'm hoping to start Agency early next week. Anyone else excited for the new book? Anyone already finished it?
I’ve made a few disparate references to this before, but over the last few months I’ve been doing dramaturgical research for my school’s production of The Birds. For those who don’t know, being a dramaturg (as I like to describe) essentially means being a history/research consultant for a play: we research the context the play was written in, the context that it takes place in, production history, and other related themes and topics about the play and related to the specific interpretation you’re going with, and create materials for both the cast and crew, so that they better understand the role they are inhabiting, as well as the audience, so they can better grasp the theme of the play, and understand content that might not be clear from the text (like if you’re doing a translation of a play written for an entirely different culture, explaining things that would be obvious to original audiences but unclear to yours).
This is my first time really serving as a dramaturg, and it’s honestly been some of the most fun I’ve had working on a show in years. I got to do a deep dive into Greek history, both theatre and not-theatre, which has been fascinating. (I have over a dozen books about Ancient Greece in my apartment, and it’s great.) And this sub has been a big help, scrolling through a lot of old threads trying to dig up information and book recommendations. On Sunday we have our first rehearsal, and I’m doing a presentation for the cast to essentially lecture them about Ancient Greece, and will soon be sending out a 30ish page packet with a ton of information for them, so that’ll be exciting!
I think this is the biggest research project I’ve embarked on in college, which is interesting since this isn’t even for a class (though I do get academic credit for it, so there’s that). I suppose this also partially says something about my other projects, that perhaps I could’ve done better on. But this was something I was really passionate about, and some of the stuff that I want to do career-wise, so naturally I would put a lot more effort into it. (Plus I had winter break, and therefore time to do work.) Honestly makes me wish I had thrown in a second major or minor in history… alas, it’s my last semester, so a bit late.
In American dollars, how much would a Norse raider profit from a fairly average raid in England or Francia in the early Viking age?
Also in dollars, how much would a typical kit(weapon, armor, etc) cost a Viking? Would going raiding reliably pay off the investment?
What amount of profit from a raid would be considered a good haul? How was loot divided amongst the participating marauders?
HS teacher here.
Hoping someone one can point me in the direction of some easily accessible (i.e. short and easy to read) sources/historical fiction on non-Europeans in WWI and/or the Spanish Revolution.
TIA
does anyone know how to cite census data? I specifically need to cite (and find) data for the US population (and of the slave population) between 1790 and 1860. Thanks!
So about a month ago, I wrote a thing about the history and philosophy of science and Dr. STONE. I wrote it all in one day because I was trying to time it with respect to the final episode of Dr. STONE so I could submit it while it was hot.
Since then, someone else tried to x-post it to /r/philosophy, but the mods there told them they should just get me to post it, so they contacted me.
Since it's not really hot anymore, I can take my time with the research and stuff now. I feel like it's too long to be a cohesive question for the subreddit. I considered breaking it down into several questions and asking the subreddit over the course of days or something, but that seemed obnoxious. So I decided to just wait for another Friday FFA.
If anyone would be willing to help me make any part of this more accurate (with due credit, etc.), please let me know. I looked through the flaired users to see if anyone had an appropriate expertise but I don't think I was ever able to properly identify anyone.
I'd also appreciate just pointers at how to figure out how accurate this is, I really don't have much of an idea. I just sort of summarized what Larry Laudan said is historically the case.
Thanks for any help anyone's willing to provide me at all.