The Sun is a masculine entity according to Greek mythology (Helios/Apollo) but did other ancient cultures see the Sun as a feminine celestial body instead?

by Asinus_Docet

Upon stambling on this gorgeous artwork from u/captainbertbert, I read the following comment from u/crimsonultra:

In his book The Hero With a Thousand Faces, Joseph Campbell notes that the feminine sun is a relic of a much older heritage, echoing the cultures before the rise of more patriarchal patterns that came with agriculture. Besides Germanic culture, feminine Sun stories have survived in Japanese culture as well.

The reasons for this switch may be due to a shift in focus from the divine feminine to the divine masculine.

If anyone can, I would like to receive more context:

  1. Which ancient heritage is J. Campbell referring to? Materially speaking, do we have any archeological evidence to support it?
  2. Could more be said about the Sun's switch from a feminine to a masculine entity? What are the main milestones of that cultural history?

I'm mostly used to Greek mythology where the twin gods Apollo and Artemis respectively represent a masculine Sun and a feminine Moon. I would love to know if that ancient gender allotment of celestial bodies wasn't universal. How? Why?

itsallfolklore

One should be wary of going to Campbell for anything historical. He was trained in psychology and drew what he knew about cultural comparisons from Jung, also a psychologist with only speculative understanding of the past. Both are noted for broad generalizations based on cherry-picked examples. For that matter, many folklorists find Campbell wanting when it comes to comparative research and analysis.

I know of no good evidence that cultural assumptions about the genders of the sun and moon represent a historical process. Some cultures assume the sun is male and some assume it is female; often the moon appears as just the opposite. It appears that the idea of a female sun was widespread in Northern Europe - in English one still speaks of the Man in the Moon. I suspect that the female sun was displaced by more recent acknowledgement of the Classical Greek understanding of a male sun - but I am not prepared to say that this was, in fact, a recent historical process or when this occurred.

The crucial thing to understand is that there is no evidence of some sort of widespread prehistoric supplanting of a female sun by a male one. It is simple a matter of cultural assumption not generally tied to history. Dismissing the Japanese female sun as some sort of relic from prehistory is typical of the Jungian/Campbell molding of the facts to suit the theory. As is typical, Campbell speculates on something no one can know, and then passes it off as part of his professed remarkable understanding of humanity, history, and cultures in general.