My family has many stories about sexual trysts and dalliances that go back generations, yet I often hear people say Americans were far less sexually active in the past. Is this a fact, or is it simply people assuming stricter historical social taboos correspond to the historical reality?
I don't want to discourage any further answers, but you'll probably enjoy these older threads while you wait:
How common was casual sex throughout history? by /u/Tiako et al
Did Flappers use birth control? by /u/mimicofmodes
Was pre-marital pregnancy common in the 1800s? once again by the inimitable mimicofmodes
Did teen pregnancy rates actually increase after the 1950s? by /u/HueJass84
Did teenager pregnancy rates rise with the new availability of cars in the 1920s?
Is there actually any evidence that young adults in the 40's and 50's were less promiscuous than young adults today? by /u/SilverRoyce
I don't know how far in the past you want, but you might be interested in the Kinsey Reports. This was a huge 2 part study on human sexual activity in America led by Alfred Kinsey; one volume about men was published in 1948 and another volume about women was published in 1953 [Sexual Behavior in the Human Male and Sexual Behavior in the Human Female respectively.] Both involved a few 1000 participants, Kinsey and co. had long in depth interviews with each participant about sex
If you can access the reports themselves, you're in for an interesting read. There are about a zillion statistics on all kinds of sex. Ask a librarian. To make a long story short, people absolutely were sexually active, including in ways they weren't supposed to be. Some highlights as taken from my senior thesis, which included some stuff on Kinsey:
Both reports were easily accessible to the public and became best-sellers despite being essentially dry scientific literature. For my thesis I looked at a bunch of reviews and editorials about the report in newspapers from that time [via newspapers dot com].
The female report especially made waves; many people weren't happy to hear that women weren't living up to the sexual rules that existed for them. To sum up a great number of opinions I read:
One book that can give you a sense of the reception without reading a million papers like i did is An Analysis of the Kinsey Reports of Sexual Behavior in the Human Male and Female, ed. Donald Porter Geddes (New York: E.P. Dutton & Co., 1954).
My conclusion is that Kinsey's facts reflect the actual activities people were occupying themselves with, and the response reflects both a national interest in sex and a national interest in moral guardianship and repression.