I'm looking to learn more about The Guilded Age, what should I know going in and anything you'd recommend looking at?

by GabrielAntihero

All I know about it currently is there was an extreme wealth gap and the standard of living for the poor was horrendous.

ProfessionalKvetcher

If we want to keep things concise and simple, Richard White’s The Republic For Which It Stands, is unquestionably the best one-volume analysis of the American Gilded Age on the market, at least as far as I’m aware. White is an excellent writer, as detailed as he is concise, and skilled at weaving together all of the pieces of American culture and history that made the Gilded Age a reality. If you’re crunched for time or don’t feel like embarking on the following odyssey that introduces all of the pieces and trusts you to put them together yourself, stop reading here and check out Richard White; I promise you won’t be disappointed. If not, read on and buckle up.

To really understand the Gilded Age, you first have to start with at least a basic understanding of Manifest Destiny and the idea that the growing United States had an obligation to continue growing geographically, economically, and as a national power. Considering America’s rocky start as an offshoot of the British Empire and their role largely being that of a pawn in the tussle between European superpowers, it’s easy to see how generations of young American men felt that their own nation needed substantial growth and it was their responsibility to lead the charge.

The absolute latest you can start in your understanding of the Gilded Age is with the Louisiana Purchase and the Lewis and Clark Expedition, which first introduced Americans to the concepts of A) buying and selling territory on a global scale and B) expanding the borders of their nation to exploit the resources within. An excellent and accessible book on this is Stephen Ambrose’s Undaunted Courage, which explores both of these concepts, starting as a study of the Lewis and Clark Expedition and analyzing it in terms of its immediate and future impact.

If you want to follow the theme instead of the chronology, skip to the next paragraph and then double back to this one, as you’ll see in a moment. The second substantial event in the 1840s was the Mexican-American War, which I’ve written about at length on this sub before, and this is relevant to our discussion because it established the United States as a military power in its own right, capable of scuffling with other sovereign nations that it neighbored. While the War of 1812 saw some rather humiliating losses, the Mexican-American War, while not without its downsides, was a decisive victory for the United States that both expanded territory and demonstrated military superiority. It would also be the dress rehearsal for the Civil War, where men like Grant, Lee, Sherman, and Jackson learned to be generals, but that’s more of an ancillary study than particularly relevant to our discussion of the Gilded Age. For an analysis of the Mexican-American War, I recommend Robert Merry’s A Country of Vast Designs, which looks at both the war and the President who waged it, James Polk. If you want a more thorough study of President Polk, who more or less embodied the spirit of Manifest Destiny with his clear political goals and his “my way or the highway” attitude, Walter Borneman’s Polk is one of the best resources on the man. Additionally, if you want to fill in the gaps between the Louisiana Purchase and the Mexican-American War, there’s no better book that I’ve ever read than Daniel Walker Howe’s What God Hath Wrought.

Next, let’s examine the westward expansion that followed the Mexican-American War in the California Gold Rush, when countless miners and fortune-seekers moved to the West Coast in order to strike it rich. Again, this is where we see the personal excellence and prosperity beliefs that embodied the Gilded Age come to life, as men left their father’s trades and set out to earn vast riches in a hostile, unknown land. The best book I’ve read on the subject - admittedly, the only one since I was 10 - is Richard Lingenfelter’s Gold Lust and Silver Sharks. While occasionally bogged down with details about the mining towns and the politics therein, this is still an excellent resource that examines the California Gold Rush in the years between 1848 and 1884. There’s also a companion/sequel entitled Copper Kings and Stock Frenzies, but it more discusses the specifics of the mining industry and I wouldn’t call it necessary for your study. Fascinating and worth a read, yes, but not quite necessary. While you’re in this time period, Paul Andrew Hutton’s The Apache Wars is an excellent, if rather depressing, overview of the United States’ complicated and violent relationship with the natives.

Strangely enough, we’re actually going to skip over the most significant event of the 1860s, the American Civil War, and focus on the second most significant event - the building of the Transcontinental Railroad, which linked the two halves of the United States and opened the West up to unprecedented growth and prosperity. For this event, I’ve read two different books and recommend them both, the first being Stephen Ambrose’s Nothing Like It In The World and the second being David Howard Bain’s Empire Express. Ambrose is more concise, Bain is more detailed, and both are excellent. I would probably recommend starting with Ambrose and if you want more detail and you’ve got the time, check out Bain’s.

Okay, we’ve finally made it to the 1870s and the proper beginning of the Gilded Age, but it’s important to remember that no one of the time looked up from their newspaper at breakfast and told their wife “honey, we’re living in the Gilded Age!” Instead, it was simply a continuation of the ongoing growth and prosperity of the United States. I digress.

New York City was the center of power and wealth in the late 1800s, and while there have been countless books written on this time period, the best summaries that come to mind - at least for me, I’m sure there are much better recommendations that will get posted - are a pair of books. The first is Charles R. Morris’ book The Tycoons: How John D. Rockefeller, Jay Gould, and J.P. Morgan Invented the American Supereconomy; the second is Kenneth D. Ackerman’s biography of Boss Tweed, much more succinctly titled Boss Tweed. Between these two books, I don’t think you can find a more concise but detailed picture of how the times developed into what we now call the Gilded Age. I would also add T.J. Stiles’ bio of Cornelius Vanderbilt, The First Tycoon, into the mix, but that’s only if you want to go extra deep. Morris does an excellent job of explaining how the American economy began to grow so rapidly during this time period under the leadership of the tycoons; Ackerman studies the complex system of political skullduggery mastered by Boss Tweed and Tammany Hall, which can help explain how the rich got richer, the poor got poorer, and the government was shifted into a nigh-oligarchy by Tweed and his men. Anyway, that’s just what comes to mind for me, but I certainly haven’t read every book on the subject and I’m sure I’ve got some serious gaps in here.