Hey everyone, I have a few questions about World War 2.
1.) Does anyone know the average age of Wehrmacht soldiers year-by-year during the war? I would guess that between 1942 and 1945 the average age decreased as Germany was starting to taste more and more defeat and requiring more manpower. I've read a few accounts that describe quite a few young (16-18 years old) German soldiers in Normandy in 1944 because manpower was becoming a significant issue. However, I have also learned that there were some much older men defending Berlin in 1945, but not sure how prevalent that was. There's also a pretty well-known picture of either a 15- or 16-year-old German soldier crying after being captured by the American soldiers. Was that age common late in the war?
2.) I'd love to hear any thoughts on the 'clean Wehrmacht myth'. I'm aware that there were some German soldiers who may not have had much knowledge about the atrocities being committed, but I have no idea how prevalent it was for the average Wehrmacht soldier to have genuinely been unaware of how widespread and horrible their war crimes were. But I would venture a guess that there would be a decent probability of Germans on the front-lines (especially the western front) not being exposed or informed about it. Then again, the magnitude was so great that I'm not sure how small or big the portion of the ignorant may have been. I do feel some empathy for the Germans who didn't know about the atrocities, especially the young conscripts, just because war (and WW2 in particular) was absolute hell. And just to be absolutely clear, I know that a very large portion of German soldiers were either complicit or active participants in war crimes, and I have no sympathy for those ones at all. Was there a difference in awareness of Nazi war crimes between Wehrmacht soldiers on the eastern front vs. the western front?
TLDR; bold parts are my questions; talking about the Wehrmacht, not the SS because it's universally known how blatantly evil they were. But any info is appreciated
Edit: grammar & wording
I'll take a shot at answering #2. For #2, the short version is that virtually every soldier, especially on the Eastern Front, was aware of the crimes being committed. The war aims for the Eastern Front were intrinsically linked to Nazi ideology. It cannot be understood outside of the lens of Nazi racial hierarchy, with Aryan 'clean' races subjugating 'inferior' races. As such, the way the entire war was conducted from top to bottom in the east was not as a traditional war of army versus army, combatants fighting over territory - but as army versus people groups.
Let's look at what the German Army believed prior to the invasion of Poland. Hitler said of Poland to his staff, "Our strength lies in our speed and our brutality. Genghis Khan hunted millions of women and children to their deaths, consciously and with a joyous heart. History sees in him only the great founder of a state" and that "hard ethnic struggle that will not permit any legal restrictions. The methods will not be compatible with our normal principles." Franz Halder, the chief of staff, is quoted as saying prior to the invasion of Poland 'it's the aim of the Leader and of Goring to annihilate and exterminate the Polish people'. Brauchitsch, the commander in chief of the German Army in 1939, "confirmed that the policy was to 'prevent the Polish intelligentsia from building itself up to become a new leadership stratum. The low standard of living will be maintained. Cheap slaves. All the rabble must be cleared out of German territory.' As noted by John Wheeler-Bennett, after a pogrom against German Jews in 1938, "...among the Generals there was scarcely a voice raised in protestation.' The German High Command were clearly aware of the war being fought against people and not against an army. Indeed, as John Wheeler-Bennett says: "No man who participated in the Fuhrer Conferences of August 22, 1939, and there were present the highest ranking officers of the three services, could thereafter plead ignorance of the fact that Hitler had laid bare his every depth of infamy before them, and they had raised no voice in protest either then or later."
During the invasion of Poland, activities against civilians were not limited to only SS rearguard actions. From 'The Nemesis of Power':
With the Polish war not two weeks old, yet clearly won, Ribbentrop conveyed to Keitel in the Headquarters train on September 12 the Fuhrer's instructions for the solution of the Polish problem. These included the mass execution of the intelligentsia, the nobility and the clergy of all elements, in fact, who might be regarded as leaders of a potential subsequent resistance movement — and a wholesale massacre of the Jews, the raison d'etre for which was to be a faked uprising in the Galician Ukraine. Keitel passed these instructions on to Canaris, and the ‘little Admiral was aghast. He protested that the military honour of Germany would be indelibly sullied if it condoned such crimes. But Keitel replied imperturbably that the Fuhrer had commanded these things to be done and had added, moreover, that if the Army should express disagreement with them, they would have to accept the presence as equals of units from the SS and the SIPO (Security Police), who would not scruple to do the Fuhrer's commands and who would operate independently of military government.
Of the invasion of the Soviet Union, Colonel-General Hoepner wrote: "This struggle must have as its aim the demolition of present Russia and must therefore be conducted with unprecedented severity. Both the planning and the execution of every battle must be dictated by an iron will to bring about a merciless, total annihilation of the enemy. Particularly no mercy should be shown toward the carriers of the present Russian-Bolshevik system." Von Reichenau, commander of the 6th Army, wrote: "Thereby the troops too have tasks, which go beyond the conventional unilateral soldierly tradition [Soldatentum]. In the East the soldier is not only a fighter according to the rules of warfare, but also a carrier of an inexorable racial conception [volkischen Idee] and the avenger of all the bestialities which have been committed against the Germans and related races."
It cannot be interpreted any other way than that the commanders of the Wehrmacht, in addition to the SS, conceived of the war not as a war against an army, but as a war against peoples.