I have 35 questions about the Nordic Bronze age after hitting a wall with research for a book, Looking for answers or even academic speculation about things that cant be answered. The more that can be answered, the better.

by DumbThoth

I'm working on a book, for this book there's a lot I need to know about the Nordic Bronze Age as I want to incorporate as much historically/archeologically correct and plausible details as possible. I've spent 6 months getting background info from the bronze age to the medieval age. I keep hitting walls with the bronze age as most of the research is hyper focused, niche and difficult to access, There's also a lack of comprehensive overviews comparable to other historical cultures which I suspect is due to the nature of the culture taking place before written history. I started with a list of 100 questions I may need answers for after doing my initial research, I've whittled it down to 35 questions, help me whittle it down more please.

Questions:

A) Bronze Age Trade routes/Denmark's ties to the Amber Road.

  1. Did Denmark Have a Bronze Trade or was the amber road more of an intermediary for them since more amber was found to the west?

  1. Could/did the Bronze age Nordic peoples sail through rivers to the Mediterranean themselves or was the trade more of a relay system?

  1. Did they have to portage and large distances and if so where?

  1. Is it realistically possible for individual Nordic Bronze age people to have been embroiled in minor rolls in the raids of the Sea People since the Black Sea Civillizations Minoans and Myceneans were all groups that the Nordic Bronze age had ties too?

  1. Did the Nordic Bronze Age inhabitants sail around the Iberian Peninsula?

B) Bronze age Climate/Geography and population dynamics.

From what I understand around 8300BCE Drastic Temperature rise beginning Brings Aspen, Birch, Pine, Aurochs and Elk to Denmark, then in 7000BCE, continued temperature rise brings Oak, Elm, Hazel, Deer and Boar to the area. By 4500BCE Denmark coastline starts to look like islands we see today and the populations shifted to a more seafood based diet increasing the population. I also understand that the settlements were usually only 2 or 3 families at the largest and towns weren’t sustainable yet…

1. How Dense and vast would these forrests be?

2. How far would settlement have been from each other on average (would they see the lights and smoke of each-others fires)?

3. Were groups more cooperative or weary with each other?

4. What would be the main dips and bumps in the regional climate between the modern era and the 8.2 kiloyear BP climate event?

5. Was there any climate change after 4500BCE that was more local?

6. Was there any seasonal sea ice around Denmark?

C) Bronze age belief systems/Indo-European,Celtic and Iron Age Comparative Mythology and language

  1. Could Bronze age and Nordic people understand the other Germanic groups or even celts or would translators have been required and at what point would there languages have split too much?

  1. How far back would oral history have reached during the bronze age, e.g. would they have stories and myths about the arrival of agriculture, horses and proto-indo-european culture, their own migrations or even the sinking of Doggerland or the end of the Ice age and extinct MegaFauna?

  1. Did the Bronze age Scandinavians Germans and Celts recognize the shared indo-european roots of many of their beleifs?

  1. When did Odin and other distinctly Scandinavian myths show up in the mythology of the region?

  1. Did they see dragons as Tolkienesque depictions portray them or would they have been more serpent-like as they were familiar with snakes, do we know if they saw them as scaled/reptillian?

  1. Any early Scandinavian myths that could reference Giant Squids as they occasionally washed ashore?

  1. Do we know how the (much later) belief of the 9 realms evolved?

  1. Does the (much later) belief of Yggdrasil the world tree have any earlier parallels or roots?

  1. Are there Euhemeristic Historical interpretations of any Germanic or early Norse myths?

  1. How were most people sacrificed when it happened? Where they bled like livestock, hung like Tollund man or something else do we know what classes of society would have been chosen for sacrifice and whether it would have ever been voluntary due to religious beliefs?

  1. Was the Runic alphabet originally used for simple symbols, narratives, preserving statements or for more practical bookkeeping purposes (perhaps like the cuneiform script)? How quickly did it change when it first appeared? Was it related to other written languages?

D) The evolution of Bronze age to Iron Age boats.

  1. Why did boats like the Hjortspring Boats and the boats in the petroglyphs have 2 beaks/horns on each side one extending from the gunwale on either end of the boat as well as one underneath extending from the keel. The upper one makes sense for perhaps a figurehead or attaching things to like in the boats of later ages that have the dragon head and tails but the second seems redundant both functionally and aesthetically. What are the main theories on this? Was the bottom one used for Fishing nets, taking the hits of ice packs? Coming ashore? Portaging? This double-beaked style seems very unique.

  1. When did the boats likely become klinker built? When did they become capable of open ocean travel?

  1. Why were the early petroglyph boats larger than the later petroglyphs and were there actually boats that big during the bronze age?

  1. Did the Scandinavians take or give influence on boat designs from the Greeks or Egyptians during their trade?

E) Other

  1. When did Scandinavian cultures shift from round huts to longhouses?

  1. When and where were the first buildings with sod walls and or roofs built?

  1. What was the range of settlement sizes for the Bronze Age?

  1. How much livestock would make a family considered wealthy?

  1. What Percentage of Livestock were harvested each year for food and where they mostly processed at a certain time of year?

  1. Was meat preserved with salt and or drying? Was Snow or streams used as natural refrigerators?

  1. What was bathing like and did they have a similar sauna culture to the Finns?

  1. How was Childbirth handled and were was the baby usually delivered?

  1. When did longhouses shift from straight A-frames to ballooned boat-hull-shaped longhouses?

Excuse my spelling and grammar if there are any issues i did not review this as I typed it between other things.

Georgy_K_Zhukov

Hi there - we're happy to approve your question related to your creative project, and we are happy for people to answer. However, we should warn you that many flairs have become reluctant to answer questions for aspiring novelists and the like, based on past experience: some people working on creative projects have a tendency to try to pump historians for trivia while ignoring the bigger points they were making, while others have a tendency to argue with historians when the historical reality does not line up with what's needed for a particular scene or characterization. Please respect the answers of people who have generously given you their time, even if it's not always what you want to hear.

Additionally, as amazing as our flair panel is, we should also point out that /r/AskHistorians is not a professional historical consultation service. If you're asking a question here because you need vital research for a future commercial product such as a historical novel, you may be better off engaging a historical consultant at a fair hourly rate to answer these questions for you. We don't know what the going rate for consultancy work would be in your locality, but it may be worth looking into that if you have in-depth or highly plot-reliant questions for this project. Some /r/AskHistorians flairs could be receptive to working as a consultant in this way. However, if you wish for a flair here to do this work for you, you will need to organize this with them yourselves.

For more general advice about doing research to inform a creative project, please check out our Monday Methods post on the subject.