Today:
You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.
As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.
Ramseyer's article got thoroughly destroyed on the New Yorker today
In one striking example, Ramseyer wrote about a young Japanese girl who went to Borneo to work as a prostitute: “When Osaki turned ten, a recruiter stopped by and offered her 300 yen upfront if she would agree to go abroad. The recruiter did not try to trick her; even at age ten, she knew what the job entailed.” (Ramseyer raised no question about a ten-year-old’s ability to consent to sex.)
How the hell did the journal even pass this through?
This is just ridiculous
For years, travelers coming into Nashville from the south on I-65 have been greeted by a very large statue of Nathan Bedford Forrest on a rearing horse, cartoonishly rendered in fiberglass. The town has had a remarkably unified opinion of it: residents who hate Forrest hate the statue because it's Forrest. Disciples of the Lost Cause who love Forrest hate the statue because it's jaw-droppingly ugly. The owner, Bill Dorris, has never cared what people think. When it was recently vandalized with pink paint, he shrugged and stated it'd turn red and look fine. Years ago, somebody managed to loop some steel cable around the horse's hooves and string the other end across the nearby railroad track, obviously hoping a passing L&N freight would wrench it free and drag it north into town. Instead, the cable just sheared through the base and briefly toppled the statue, and so Dorris had it repaired and put up again ( if it had worked, the person(s) who'd done it would have people buying them beers in most every bar in town.... for years) .
Now Dorris has died. Having no children, he's left about $5 million to his dog, a border collie.
It is unclear what the dog intends to do with the statue.
Oh sweet heavens, I've spent much of this week transcribing highly stylized 19th-century German hands, from Germans who pepper their writing with other languages' words in very weird places. It started out a slog, and now I'm getting fairly good at recognizing the ligatures and 'swallowed' letters. My German isn't fluent, and certainly not archaic regional dialects and older spellings, so this is a real godsend. I've had a passel of scanned letters for nearly eight years that I've only lightly picked through because of the writing to this point, but I decided to just buckle down and power into it with a little jumpstart on common words and particles via the Kurrent HTR of the very user-unfriendly, fidgety, and sometimes persnickety Transkribus. I've managed to go from taking a day to get through a couple of pages tolerably well to requiring a quarter of that time, which has now made the task economically possible to do myself--and better in that I know the specialist terms and most of the South African highveld Boer lingo that's being literally translated into German. (Why do you need to use 'Distanz' AND 'Entfernung' within two sentences of each other? Why?!? And subject-verb agreement, c'mon man, I you went to Realschule so I know you know better!)
I'm in the final month of my fellowship time and haven't written nearly as much as I hoped, and I haven't been able to go overseas as was meant. So that's a disappointment--but it's been a difficult time for everyone, so I'm doing my best not to feel despondent about it. Going back to teaching, even just a seminar, is not something I'm looking forward to though. Unlike most of my colleagues, I will be new to the process of planning a course for Zoom from the ground up. This ought to be ... interesting.
So I'm fleshing out the maps for a naval encounter in my fantasy series. I'll try not to get too heavy with the details, but basically imagine that a fleet of Greek triremes had to row upriver to secure something approximating the China's Grand Canal during the Ming Restoration. In researching how battle like this might play out I've come across a ton of fantastic resources for everything from the kinds of formations the Athenians used to the effects rowing upriver would have in various currents, but there is one fairly simple question that I cannot seem to find an answer to: when ancient triremes were rowing in formation, how much distance was there between each ship?
In other words, if I had a fleet of 18' wide Triremes sailing through a mile wide stretch of river (5280 ft.), and the ships were spacing themselves out roughly the same way the Athenians at Salamis would have, how much distance would there be between each ship? My gut says somewhere around 50 feet between each ship to give them enough berth to do all those fancy tricks (diekplous, periplous, etc) while still keeping them close enough to each other for there to be a real formation. If anyone could give me a little advice about whether my estimates are at least kinda close to the historical reality, I would be immensely grateful.
I am trying to find some good documentaries about lake ladoga. do you have any tips?
Your Weekly /r/askhistorians Recap
Friday, February 19 - Thursday, February 25
###Top 10 Posts
| score | comments | title & link |
|---|---|---|
| 15,597 | 396 comments | Black Panther members once openly carried firearms and would stand nearby when the police pulled over a black person. They would shout advice, like the fact that the person could remain silent, and assured them that they'd be there to help if anything went wrong. Why did this stop? |
| 8,188 | 139 comments | Millennials in the US widely believe that getting hired was easier for their parents & grandparents, who are known such stories as “I walked right up to manager and said, ‘I’d like a job, when can I start?’ He hired me on the spot!” How true was this in, say, 1970? |
| 6,218 | 173 comments | Why did the US Government name its states after Native American tribes it was actively trying to wipe out? |
| 4,998 | 88 comments | In Mad Men the ad-men are always depicted with a decanter of whiskey in their offices and taking drinks in the afternoon. When did alcohol become a “thing” in the workplace and when did it stop becoming such a thing? |
| 4,041 | 33 comments | This list of causes of death for 1632 Londoners has some familiar causes (consumption, drowned, etc.) and others that are not so familiar, such entries for "Rising of the Lights" killing 98, and "Planet" killing 13. When did death records start being collected systematically in standardized form? |
| 3,843 | 171 comments | Why do Communist societies that we've seen tend toward authoritarianism and dictatorial-style arrangements? |
| 3,257 | 151 comments | A strange thing I noticed about US states is that usually, the capital of the state is not the largest city in it. Why is that? |
| 2,748 | 53 comments | During the Industrial Revolution, factories full of women like the Triangle Shirtwaist factory worked 12+ hour shifts with no bathroom breaks. Uh, how to put this politely... how? |
| 2,679 | 55 comments | In the movie Gladiator, Russell Crowe's character Maximus is taken as a slave from his own villa. What recourse did Roman Citizens and others have against being kidnapped and sold into slavery within the Roman Empire? |
| 2,557 | 78 comments | When and why did the word "overmorrow" fall out of usage? |
###Top 10 Comments
If you would like this roundup sent to your reddit inbox every week send me a message with the subject 'askhistorians'. Or if you want a daily roundup, use the subject 'askhistorians daily'. Or send me a chat with either askhistorians or askhistorians daily.
####Please let me know if you have suggestions to make this roundup better for /r/askhistorians or if there are other subreddits that you think I should post in. I can search for posts based off keywords in the title, URL and flair. And I can also find the top comments overall or in specific threads.
When people mention to me Mohammed the prophet being a paedophile because of Aisha's age of marriage at age and consummation , what hadiths do they refer to?
A good book on the history of Switzerland? Preferably through the prism of ‘how did this mad little country even become a nation state and then become stupidly rich?’
Any ideas?
Why is there more attention, energy, reparation and praise directed toward African Americans for the atrocious things that European colonizers did to them than to Native Americans? Surely what was done to Native Americans was objectively worse i.e. genocide?
There is many a celebration for the first African American Baseball player, Astronaut, Governor, President etc. because these things were historically not achievable, but rarely any publicized praise for Native Americans that might achieve the same thing.
Because what was done to Native Americans, historically, was done prior to African slaves being brought to the Americas, I was wondering if there is a statute of limitations on the atrocities we choose to remember?
Question: can you recommend heavily illustrated book about everyday life in Antiquity/Early Middle Ages? I would like to know better about everyday life in the past, especially Late Antiquity, but most of the books about it are mostly text. So I am looking for something with many illustrations, be they photographs or pictures. The region doesn't matter that much, whether it's Europe, Middle East, South or East Asia.
I was listening to the History of Rome podcast, and recently listed to the episode where Cinncinatus was made dictator and I was wondering if anyone had further details on exactly how they chose the dicator?
Why do random elderly farmers, or far removed family members of well-known Romans end up leading the army and society into war ? It mentions each of the memorable dictators but is skant on details as to why and how they were chosen, was this information lost to time?