Why did the term “Anglo-Saxon” stick around into contemporary times when there’s been 1000 years of that culture being mixed with the native Celts and absorbing the Danelaw settlers and other Scandinavian influences while also being dominated by the Norman conquerers and everything else?

by shitpostsmanship

For instance why is “Anglo-Saxon” specifically the thing to define white Protestants in the US? At the very least they were like 600 years removed from Anglo-Saxon dominance in England when their ancestors left for America. Were settlers to the new world from England actually literal Anglo-Saxon descendants that were fleeing Britain after centuries of not being given titles or important posts by their continental overlords?

Like for a resident of the Danelaw region when William the Conqueror came through and ensured that everyone was now his subject as the king of England and this was no longer an autonomous Danish territory or whatever, would they be left with their language and culture to do what they want? And they just slowly blended into the “anglo-Saxon” and “English” culture over time under their French lords? Like why don’t northern Englanders that likely are more descended from Scandinavians more recently and more often than saxons, have an anglo-Danish or anglo-norse label or something? What made “anglo-Saxon” stay the dominant label for 1000 years of other groups coming along and jumping into the gene pool?

Holy_Shit_HeckHounds

A lot more can be said especially about the origins of the usage in America, but consider this thread What do historians think about the term "Anglo-Saxon"? that links to older answers by u/sagathain and u/kelpie-cat. In addition to the linked threads, there are also more, shorter answers by u/sagathain and u/kelpie-cat in that thread. Most of the discussion is focused on the contemporary usage and controversies of the term, but there is some discussion of the origins of its usage

Holy_Shit_HeckHounds

In addition to my previous comment, The Anglo-Saxon-Jute theory presents issues. Celts call them almost exclusively... written by u/Steelcan909 is linked in one of threads I already posted, but is worth linking to separately as it tackles the Angles, Saxons, and Jutes history. That being said, it does not discuss the reasons for the continued usage