I assume familiarity with Hannibal’s tactics at the Battle of Cannae.
Even after a fair amount of study, I remain confused about how exactly Hannibal flanked the Romans with his Libyan troops. How did he manage to hide both columns of his best infantry?
I assume the Romans didn’t just ignore the Libyans on each side as they fought the Gallic and Spanish troops. Had the Africans been visible, the Romans would’ve presumably engaged them as well to avoid exposing their flanks.
I understand that the Libyan troops weren’t positioned miles away from the fighting or anything. Rather, they sat right next to the cavalry.
I’ve read anecdotes indicating that Hannibal had his men kick up dust to obscure the Libyans, but that alone seems insufficient. What am I missing here? Thanks!
The solution to this problem proposed by Adrian Goldsworthy, and to the question of how a convex could've prevented a line from breaking (and personally, if it works why didn't everyone else use it) can be seen in the deployment here. As you can see, if the Libyans were deployed both between and behind the cavalry and Spanish/Gaellic infantry, then they would be blocked from view of the Romans simply by the bodies of men and horse in front.
In his previous battles with the Romans, Hannibal saw that even when put into a disadvantageous position, the main thrust of the Roman infantry were able to break through the Carthaginian line. He therefore advanced his center first into a convex to deal with this problem. But whereas scholars before Goldsworthy assumed Hannibal's convex also prevented the Carthaginian line from breaking, Goldsworthy's hypothesis is that Hannibal turned this problem to his advantage. The Romans would naturally crowd towards the center where the fighting was, and troops would be committed to where a breakthrough seemed imminent, also the center, as it retreated. The position of the Libyans also served to stablize and reinforce the Carthaginian infantry on the wings to make sure they do not break. Instead of trying to prevent the Romans from breaking through the center, Hannibal counted on the fact that they would. The Carthaginian center breaking is reported by Livy in the infantry battle:
At first they were evenly matched in strength and courage, as long as the Gauls and Spaniards maintained their ranks; but at last the Romans, by prolonged and frequent efforts, pushing forward with an even front and a dense line, drove in the wedge-like formation which projected from the enemy's line, for it was too thin to be strong; and then, as the Gauls and Spaniards gave way and fell back in confusion, pressed forward and without once stopping forced their way through the crowd of fleeing, panic-stricken foes, till they reached first the centre and ultimately —for they met with no resistance —the African supports. These had been used to form the two wings, which had been drawn back, while the centre, where the Gauls and Spaniards had been stationed, projected somewhat. When this wedge was first driven back so far as to straighten the front, and then, continuing to yield, even left a hollow in the centre, the Africans had already begun a flanking movement on either side, and as the Romans rushed incautiously in between, they enveloped them, and presently, extending their wings, crescent-wise, even closed in on their rear. From this moment the Romans, who had gained one battle to no purpose, gave over the pursuit and slaughter of the Gauls and Spaniards and began a new fight with the Africans. In this they were at a twofold disadvantage: they were shut in, while their enemies ranged on every side of them; they were tired, and faced troops that were fresh and strong.
You can see Goldsworth's interpretation of what happened here. Once the Romans broke though, as they've always done, in their pursuit they would expose themselves to the Libyans on the flanks which were originally blocked from view. The Libyans would then naturally turn inwards and sandwich the Romans, who would be crowded and disorderly from pursuing the Carthagnian center (and as Livy reported, tired). This would also give Hannibal and Mago the opening to rally the Carthaginian center and re-commit them to the fight.
I like this interpretation for many reasons: