Dutch Jews?

by GrandpaGenesGhost

Whenever I talk to my dad he loves to bring up the fact that we are "Dutch Jews." Sure I live in the US, but my last name means that I am Friesland.

I guess my question is what are / who are the "Dutch Jews?"

hannahstohelit

I mean it's a pretty broad question but Dutch Jews are fascinating so let's give it a go!

For the purposes of this question, I'll trace the Jews of the Netherlands back to the 1590s, because before that the communities were small, sparse, and often persecuted. This was especially true for much of the 16th century, when the Netherlands were under the control of the Spanish part of the Austrian Empire, which was, unsurprisingly, intolerant of Jews. However, after the declaration of Dutch independence in 1581, this soon changed. Conversos (sometimes pejoratively called marranos)- Jews whose ancestors had converted to Christianity before/at the 1492 expulsion of the Jews of Spain, some of whom still retained secret Jewish identities and beliefs- took the opportunity to leave Spain, France, and the parts of the Low Countries that remained under Spanish rule and settled in Amsterdam, where they were able to live openly Jewish lives.

These Sefardic Jews, for dozens of years following, faced a complicated challenge- to restart their Jewish lives after a century or more of Christian assimilation. The history of the Jews of this era in the Netherlands includes many with double names- the Christian, Spanish name and the Jewish name adopted as they decided to embrace their identities. These Jews were often successful physicians, merchants, and artisans, and were able to construct for themselves a tight-knit community with a rigid structure (or kahal), a beautiful and renowned synagogue (the Esnoga) which still exists today, educational institutions, and more. As the Atlantic World grew in importance, Jews, particularly Dutch Jews, played important roles in its settlements- first in Dutch colonies and then in others as well. The Amsterdam Jewish community became by far the most influential and important Sefardic community in Europe and served as a "mother community" not only for the newly resettled Jewish community of England in the late 17th century but also for the Jews of the Americas, serving as a source of information, rabbis, Jewish items and books (there was a thriving Jewish printing culture in Amsterdam), and more. Amsterdam also served as a center of opinions- and fundraising- moving eastward, as well. For example, when the Sabbatean movement, in which Shabbetai Tzvi, a Turkish Jew, claimed to be the messiah and galvanized Jews across Europe and the Middle East to his side in the 1660s, Amsterdam was a hotbed of activity and opinions both by his supporters and his detractors which often spread far and wide. Amsterdam was also a key destination for fundraisers from the Jewish communities in the Land of Israel (Ottoman Palestine).

The Ashkenazic Jews (from Northern Europe) were, especially at first, not as wealthy, influential, or highly esteemed- they played clear second fiddle to the Sefardic community. Even as the Ashkenazic community grew substantially, whether through economic migration from farther east or through refugees escaping various wars and the Tach v'Tat massacres in Poland in 1648-9, it tended to be poorer and less consequential. This didn't stop it from becoming of consequence in and of itself, with, as mentioned above, a prominent and highly regarded printing culture which produced holy books as well as works in Yiddish. With time, as the 18th century progressed and the Sefardic community (which had always been more acculturated) assimilated further into Dutch society and shrank, the Ashkenazic community climbed in importance. The Ashkenazic chief rabbinate of Amsterdam became a coveted position within the overall Northern European Jewish world.

Not that much changed as the Jews of the Netherlands were officially emancipated in 1796, as Dutch Jews had been granted a large degree of freedom for the most part since the late 16th century. The biggest change was the placement of religious organizations under the control of the state rather than as an autonomous body (I discuss what impact these sorts of changes had in France in the same era here). Once these governmentally sanctioned organizations were created, there remained two different ones- one for the Sefardim, and one for the Ashkenazim. While non-Orthodox movements didn't arrive in the Netherlands until the 1920s- surprisingly late for a western European Jewish community- by these changes in the 19th century Dutch Jews had been modernizing and acculturating for decades, and these changes continued, with Dutch overtaking Western Yiddish as the language of the Jewish community and an overall increase in the Jews' level of secularization. Culturally, the Dutch Jewish community retained a significant amount of distinctiveness relative to Jews elsewhere in Europe- it retained its own customs and traditions even as Eastern European Jews began to emigrate there in the 1880s, and to this day observant Dutch Jews are known for their unique custom that they only wait one hour between consuming meat and dairy (other communities wait between three and six hours).

By the 20th century, Zionism, particularly religious Zionism, became relatively influential in the Dutch Jewish community with an increased influx of Jews from Central and Eastern Europe. Otherwise, the community remained largely traditionally minded though secularized, with flashes of religious revival. With the rise of Hitler in the 1930s, Central European Jews flocked to Amsterdam (including Anne Frank and her family) which provided a hospitable home for them until the Nazi invasion in 1940. After that point, the Jews' situation understandably became precarious, as deportations began to camps in the Netherlands and elsewhere in the Nazi-controlled lands. From 1942-44 the deportations greatly increased until, by the end of the war in 1945, more than 100,000 Dutch Jews had been deported to German concentration camps and murdered, about 75% of the prewar Jewish community (a much larger percentage than were lost from, for comparison, the Belgian and French Jewish communities). After the war, the remnants of the community rebuilt (concentrated largely in the cities) and continues to thrive, though certainly in far smaller numbers than before the Holocaust (and with some demographic shifts).