Why is Alexander Mackenzie not as well known as Lewis and Clark?

by elmonoenano

I'm curious mostly about the historiography revolving around Alexander Mackenzie. Why does he get such short shrift when compared to Lewis and Clark? Was it just a typical case of Canada getting overshadowed by it's southern neighbor, is it all b/c I went to school in the US and if I was in Canada it would be Mackenzie all the time? (I doubt this b/c I go to Vancouver BC from time to time and I don't remember seeing anything with his name on it and Lewis and Clark is all over the place along the Columbia.) Did he just take less extensive journals? Was it the state of publishing in the Americas at that point?

For a guy who beat Lewis and Clark by over a decade, why doesn't he get more attention?

jschooltiger

Hi there! You’ve asked a question along the lines of ‘why didn’t I learn about X’. We’re happy to let this question stand, but there are a variety of reasons why you may find it hard to get a good answer to this question on /r/AskHistorians.

Firstly, school curricula and how they are taught vary strongly between different countries and even different states. Additionally, how they are taught is often influenced by teachers having to compromise on how much time they can spend on any given topic. More information on your location and level of education might be helpful to answer this question.

Secondly, we have noticed that these questions are often phrased to be about people's individual experiences but what they are really about is why a certain event is more prominent in popular narratives of history than others.

Instead of asking "Why haven't I learned about event ...", consider asking "What importance do scholars assign to event ... in the context of such and such history?" The latter question is often closer to what people actually want to know and is more likely to get a good answer from an expert. If you intend to ask the 'What importance do scholars assign to event X' question instead, let us know and we'll remove this question.

Thank you!