Today:
You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.
As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.
Internet is out for tons of folks up here in Canada-land, so I'm sitting around with nothing to do. So figured I'd throw up a random prompt for any passer bys.
What is your favorite piece of art in history? Pictures, paintings, architecture, whatever really speaks to you as art. What always makes you stop when you see it and just go "Wow, now thats beautiful/fascinating/great/[insert amazement word]"?
I gotta tell you, this is my favorite subreddit of all. It's like a smorgasbord, buffet, tapas bar of mini history courses, all bite sized and washed down with fine wine. Thank you, historians, for sharing these delicious morsels of fascination!
Any tips for non-professional researchers/historians? I do have a background and good understanding of proper research but don’t have the same access I had in academia. Any great tips anyones discovered? I’ve been researching to get a podcast started (finally decided to just do it!) and of course I love the more “off the radar” topics - that seem to be not in English/another language I speak and I’ve been struggling not to break the bank ordering tons of books. Any advice is so much appreciated! Also in case anyone is a specialist and wants to connect I’m currently researching a few topics - •Stille Hilfe in post-war Germany with a bit on its present-day impact on Germany. •Ostraca in Athens and asking why we don’t see voting people out of office/the city in modern times. •Emma B Andrews, her life (or what I can “dig” up) and her role in the Egyptology craze in America.
Didn't get any book recs yesterday but maybe someone has some insights/can make a short comment or point me in the right direction here?? Here's what I said yesterday:
I find it very difficult, as a 21st Century American, to grasp the mindset of (European) post-French Revolution, pre-WW2 monarchists, reactionaries, anti-liberal people like that. There's a lot of books that try to explain fascism but I don't think I've ever seen one that tries to explain other kinds of prewar right wing people. (There's also plenty out there about, say, post-Goldwater conservatives, but it's so different, I don't think it helps.)
I take it for granted that these people weren't thinking of themselves as bad guys and the sort of basic unexamined liberal/Whiggish narrative ("they were just stupid and evil lol!") is very unsatisfying. I feel as though I have a better idea of the ideas of Japanese ultranationalists than I do about European conservatives and that is sort of strange.
I just want to correct something u/dagaboy wrote in this answer the other day — it wasn't a Kino tribute band, we just kind of only had a dozen songs and a third of them were Kino covers. College, you know. Really, if anything, it was supposed to be a ska band, but that semester we only had access to an acoustic guitar, a banjo, a djembe, a flute, and a keytar, and our fifth member couldn't even really play any instruments at all, but we needed a bassist and he wanted to join, so he played the keytar. And that's how we became a Russian folk-ska fusion band with Jethro Tull characteristics.
Later, of course, in other semesters, the drummer and keytarist graduated, I brought an electric bass to campus, we got two other guitarist friends to join, and our banjoist learned the drums, so we became a lot more normal, instrument-wise, at least.
Your Weekly /r/askhistorians Recap
Friday, July 01 - Thursday, July 07
###Top 10 Posts
| score | comments | title & link |
|---|---|---|
| 5,173 | 36 comments | Soviet required every working citizen to take at least two weeks a year of government-paid vacations in sanatoriums (health spas with medical checkups). At peak, one sanatorium could handle half a million guests at a time. What was it like? |
| 4,119 | 76 comments | In 2001 Crown Prince Dipendra of Nepal killed nine members of the royal family with an assault rifle including his mother and father before committing suicide. Why? What effect did this have on Nepal's politics? |
| 3,506 | 67 comments | I heard recently that the majority of what people believe about Satan, the devil, etc is actually from the works of Dante and that even many Christians believe things about Satan that aren't actually referenced in biblical texts. How accurate is this and what are examples? |
| 3,454 | 178 comments | Jack Welch extracted record profits from GE for 20 years, but left it a hollowed-out "pile of shit," according to his successor. What exactly did Welch do that was so damaging, and how did he get away with it for so long? |
| 2,995 | 38 comments | If the Rosetta Stone was never found, have we discovered anything since that would have enabled us to decipher Ancient Egyptian? |
| 2,435 | 69 comments | In the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, I’ve seen a lot about the differences in how a fetus is perceived by the Jewish faith tradition as opposed to Christianity. Where did this split come from, theologically? |
| 1,852 | 149 comments | [Linguistics] Does Kamala Khan's (Ms. Marvel) family speaking Hindi make sense? |
| 1,393 | 126 comments | I don't know how to phrase this, but: How and why did we choose 100 as the maximum percentage of something? Why not 1000? Or 200? Also, are there examples of alternate maximums? |
| 1,376 | 64 comments | Not sure if this is the right place but, why is/ was pre-clovis culture so controversial? |
| 953 | 6 comments | England's elite noble families gathered in London each summer for "the season," finding matches among themselves for their children and generally hobnobbing. This went on into the 20th century. What happened to the season? How did it fade away? |
###Top 10 Comments
If you would like this roundup sent to your reddit inbox every week send me a message with the subject 'askhistorians'. Or if you want a daily roundup, use the subject 'askhistorians daily'. Or send me a chat with either askhistorians or askhistorians daily.
####Please let me know if you have suggestions to make this roundup better for /r/askhistorians or if there are other subreddits that you think I should post in. I can search for posts based off keywords in the title, URL and flair. And I can also find the top comments overall or in specific threads.
Historians, how do you keep track of all your research / conclusions? I frequently have the feeling I keep mixing things up and I often feel unsure about my historical knowlegde.
Edit: thank you all for your answers! It looks like trusty ol’ reliable sticky notes will be really useful in the future
Can you propose a lineup for a Justice League and a Legion of Doom composed by real historical characters?
I am quite into biographies of historical figures, but as a non-historian it can be difficult finding quality books that have been researched with proper standards and don’t just cater towards the author’s biases too much.
Now, usually I’d pose a question on here for reading recommendations, but I don’t want to be too spammy. Is there any resource that points towards quality biographies?
Thanks!
Edit: I know of the biography list in this sub, but it’s very focussed on US presidents, so looking for a more general resource
How do historians, or researchers generally, find other historians working on the same topic? Like, let’s say I was developing a new theory on a certain obscure topic. How would I make sure my theory hasn’t been thought of before, or that there isn’t anyone currently working on the same thing?
Say I want to not only stay historically informed, but help to promote historical literacy, especially so people will be less likely to fall for politically charged mythistories. What can I do to not only stay historically informed but also help others get interested in history, even if my day job is technically unrelated?