[Meta] Is there a right (or appropriate) way to ask questions here at askhistorians?

by gomi-panda

Just curious to know if the historians here prefer that questions be asked in a certain way to be more intelligible in order to encourage responses.

LegalAction

I mean, there are the rules in the sidebar.

I'm more likely to answer a question that has a specific context. I think the last one I wrote about was something like "why don't we know where the Rubicon was?" I can focus in on the period, and I know the sources and the scholarship. The question gives a structure to my answer.

I despise questions like "I'm a Roman youth with denarii in my pocket to burn. What do I do?" When? Where? Are you a Roman in Rome, or a Roman in, say, Alexandria? How many denarii? What sources would I use for an average Roman youth?

The clarifications needed to narrow that type of question down are immense, and while I know others enjoy those questions, I can't begin to answer them without getting the question down to a specific point, which frustrates myself, the questioner, and I expect the mods.

A targeted question is easier and more fun to answer, and more likely in my case to produce a more in-depth answer, and I'm already one flair that writes relatively (for this sub) short answers.

A question that is too broad is going to cause me to spiral out of control, or more likely, just ignore it.

Georgy_K_Zhukov

Many approaches to this, but this old Roundtable on asking questions may be of interest for you.