Did Harald Fine/Fairhair actually exist?

I know this has been asked before but as far as I know this has not been answered. What is the current academic stance on this issue? How do Norwegians feel about this?

1 Answers 2020-09-04

Was Aaron Burr as bad he was portrayed in Hamilton?

Maybe this is just how I perceive it, but it seems Hamilton portrays Aaron Burr as a not so great guy. Was he really that sneaky?

1 Answers 2020-09-04

What did Wilhelm II think about the Weimar Republic and the rise of the Nazi Party in Germany?

Basically, as the title says. I was wondering what Wilhelm II's thought about the Weimar Republic and its failures, and the rise of the Nazi party and its establishment as the main dominant political party of Germany after his abdication. Did he agree with the Nazis' ideology? What did he think of the economic turmoil brewing in the Weimar republic?

Much appreciated to anyone who can answer this question.

1 Answers 2020-09-04

What happened when a Roman legionnaire had to relieve themselves or fell ill during a march or before a battle?

Is there any primary evidence of what happened? Would the soldier relieve himself and then catch up with his comrades?

In case of a battle, would they be able to sit it out due to illness or they'd be accused of cowardice?

Thank you.

1 Answers 2020-09-04

Why don't former French colonies in the US have stronger French influences than former colonies elsewhere?

Former French colonies like Louisiana lack the French culture and language laws (and active separatist movements) of Quebec. I know people speak Louisiana Creole but my understanding is that is a small part of the overall population and it isn't as formal of a version of the French language as spoken in Quebec. And people in Louisiana aren't trying to secede from the US to preserve their French heritage. This is despite Louisiana transferring from France to the US more recently than Quebec transferred from France to the British Crown. So what caused this divergence? How did the US do a better job of integrating former French territories than Canada did?

1 Answers 2020-09-04

How did a provocative dance like belly dancing come out of conservative Islamic countries? If it was pre-Islamic, how did it survive centuries of conservative laws for women?

I am curious how a provocative dance form like belly dancing came out of the conservative Middle East, where many women are forbidden from dancing in public. Is this dance form pre-Islamic?

If so, how has it managed to survive so long?

4 Answers 2020-09-03

How sexually promiscuous were young people in America in the 1700s and 1800s, compared to today?

It seems to be commonly explained that modern attitudes towards premarital sex and sexual liberation are development of recent decades. Is this actually true? Were teenagers and young adults having sexual relationships like we see today?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Why is Oliver Cromwell hated?

I feel like this is an obvious one that can just be googled but I am curious about why people don’t like him. Now, admittedly, I don’t know a ton about him but I do know he forced out the monarchy and ruled as something of a proto-democrat for a number of years which should make him a folk hero among republicans but I’ve noticed, especially in Ireland and Scotland, he’s seen as somewhere between loathed and disdained

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Do the "historians" at r/AskHistorians have any qualifications, or are they just layman? Do any of you have PhDs?

7 Answers 2020-09-03

How much did the Free French contribute to the western front in the year between the Normandy landings and the surrender of Germany?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Why have Jews been so utterly and consistently hated by so many different groups?

So, I watched "Fiddler on the Roof" recently.

I was not aware of the Pogroms.

I ended up on a deep dive relating to the very interesting history of the Jews.

Of course, everyone knows Hitler/Nazi Germany despised the Jews, but I don't think I had a full fathom of the level of hatred the the entire world had for them for a insanely long time. I don't think I found very many countries at all, outside of Israel, before like 1950, that was even remotely okay with Jews.

There have been tons of persecuted groups in world history, but for some reason it seems to me that Jews have had a remarkably horrible and consistent history of being absolutely hated... and what seem to be for essentially completely different reasons. Some groups invoked religious ideology, some on historical relationship with them and a million other weird ideas and theories.

I seriously don't understand how they have even survived up to this point to be honest.

The level of contempt for them, It's insane. Even in world history metrics.

1 Answers 2020-09-03

How did British colonialism and the state of British colonies compare to other countries colonialism and colonies?

So I was recently reading an article about the British in India, and someone had a really interesting opinion basically saying "The British were not good for India and colonialism is bad, but if colonialism was inevitable the British were the best", now this has me a bit confused mainly by the vagueness of the word "Best", I know that colonialism had many pros and many many cons, but how did the British compare to other nations colonialism?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

How deeply was the East India Company involved with the formation and expansion of the British Empire to the point of suggesting it was a corporate goal before it became a state goal?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

in the 1700's, were the cities in the north american colonies really considered paradises (or just superior in standard of living) to european capitals? why is this?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Learning about the crusades currently in World History class, but it’s very one sided.

I am in an Honors World History class, and we are learning about the Middle Ages. Specifically right now, the crusades. However it seems like we’re only getting the European perspective. Anyone care to provide Arabian, Muslim, or Turkish accounts? It would go a long way in helping me understand the conflicts.

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Did Some Helicopters Blast Out Music In Battles And Attacks During The Vietnam War?

This is a pretty common thing I see across media set in The Vietnam War. Here's two examples. Like in Apocalypse Now? Or in Kong: Skull Island? Blasting some awesome music during a battle or an attack, was this a real thing or was it something made up for all that media?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Spice trade via Greenland

Given that already before the 15th century in Europe:

  • Greenland (and even Newfoundland) were known
  • It was known that Earth was round, and even the approximate size
  • The existence of the rest of America was unknown to them
  • They wanted a faster way to trade spice with East Asia

Why did Europeans not consider to explore the possibility of a route to East Asia passing by Greenland? At least to see whether there was some in-between lands with enough frequency to establish ports and stock up on food and water before reaching the destination.

The resulting route could of course be only open during summer, but it would be possibly faster than around Africa or through land.

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Did anti-fascists fighting Nazis in the streets of Weimar Germany help or hurt the Nazis?

I live in Portland, where many anti-fascists believe that the lesson from 1930s Germany is that Fascism needs to be fought in the streets. My vague recollection of history class is that the street brawling ended up helping the Nazis. What is the academic consensus? Was confronting fascism on the streets a heroic last stand that happened to fail, or an integral ingredient in the success of the Nazis.

2 Answers 2020-09-03

Why was the 1940 German invasion of France and the Low Countries so successful? Extremely good luck, tactics, or both?

I've been playing a lot of Hearts of Iron lately which is sending me on a wikipedia frenzy. I always assumed that France had a terrible army in comparison and stood no chance, but it appears they actually had a respectable army that you'd think would be capable for holding out a lot longer than they did.

Checking out this picture of German invasion plans, it shows the evolution of their thinking, but I'm not too sure what I'm looking at. How did these plans differ, and what was so superior about the one they settled on?

Also, my understanding is that the purpose of the maginot line is to force an invasion through the north with unfavorable terrain, which is exactly what happened. Seems like a good plan on paper, why did it fail so horribly? A few Panzer divisions breaking through isn't good, but you'd think it's not the end of the world.

Thanks for reading! Any perspective or insight is appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-09-03

The American Old West, prices and railroads

I have recently been looking at old newspapers at the Library of Congress website. Chiefly Canon City, CO and Miles City, MT. One thing I was wondering about was cities like these (rather than the smaller places) and the prices of goods in the 1870s-1890s and how those changed when railroads came and such. I think these both got railroads in the early 1880s?

And besides prices, of course, how did wages change? Doesn't have to be for these places, specifically -other cities in the then-west in the time frame would be good, too.

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Where the Olmecs influenced by East Africans?

I’m currently a college student taking a history course on mesoamerican history primarily starting it’s focus on the Olmecs. My professor has said two things with which confused me.

First that the Olmecs had pre-Columbus contact with East Africans with which amazed me yet confused me because I’d never heard anything like this ever before, upon question he simply stated that “many civilizations made contact with the Americas before Columbus.” That still didn’t really clear things up for me.

The second odd thing being that he taught us that the Olmecs believed in a complex system of 13 heavens and 9 underworlds, but I thought that was the Aztecs? I’m aware the Olmecs influenced the proceeding mesoamerican cultures but I thought there wasn’t much specific knowledge on their religion. When I tried to clear it up all he said was that they believed that.

Am I confused, did I misunderstand something that my professor has right, or am I correct?

(Ps- I ask this respectfully I would never suggest I know more then my professor I’m just confused)

3 Answers 2020-09-03

Is it true the CIA gave crack to the black communities?. Is it on any historical record?

I heard about this since I was a kid and always wondered if it was true.when I ask people they just say that without further explanation...is it true?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Was Christopher Columbus always “celebrated” in the US, or was his profile heightened due to Italian Americans?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

What if anything does this very NSFW propaganda poster say about Japanese attitudes towards pornography, male on male sex, and sexual violence during the Russo-Japanese War?

I have asked about this poster before where u/ParkSungJun helpfully translated and explained the "literary" background of the text, and provided a possible context for it. But I have more questions:

This poster would be considered pornographic I assume, and as u/ParkSungJun suggests quite crude. How widely published would something like this be?

Would it be sold openly in a newsstand for example, or more of an irregularly distributed Tijuana bible type thing? What were Japanese attitudes towards male on male sexual activity during this time, and laws/attitudes towards publishing images featuring it?

Similarly, what were Japanese attitudes towards sexual violence and its depiction during this time? Was there a awareness/belief that the Japanese military was regularly committing sexual violence, and was that an accepted part of warfare, or is this supposed to be considered an over-the-top joke that's supposed to be depicting something rare, unthinkable, or unacceptable (I'd be surprised at this, since sometimes Japanese military the Russo-Japanese War is contrasted against the widely-published brutality of the military of WWII, which is not to say that violence outside the laws and traditions of war wasn't happening earlier, just that it's wasn't a feature of memories of the Russo-Japanese War)?

The possible role of the Russo-Japanese War as a locus for talking about sexuality in the early 20th century isn't apparently new, u/momplaysbass asked this question about perceptions on the Western side several weeks ago.

Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-09-03

Was US internment of Japanese Americans frequently cited and well known in Imperial Japan, and used in its propaganda?

1 Answers 2020-09-03

1114 / 7255

Back to start