I recently learned that 85% of Argentina’s population is white. When I mentioned this to a friend, they said that 50% of them are descendants of Nazi’s who presumably fled to Argentina after WW2. How much truth is there to this?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
I understand that the north is Siberia, the west is desert, and south is mountains, but was there ever a time a Chinese leader tried to expand beyond these lands? If they didn’t , why not? Was China rich enough in resources that there was no reason to?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
Glass has been around since the ancient Greece, maybe even earlier. However this kind of glass always had a taint of color and probably also during the European middle age. But when did we start making transparent and colorless glass as we know today?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
All accounts of the battle (that I could find) tell of an axe wielding Viking that held the bridge preventing the Anglo-Saxons from crossing, cutting down roughly 40 of them by himself before meeting a rather unfortunate end. This seems like a very notable feat, enough so that he may have had a reputation as a skilled and courageous warrior among other Vikings prior to the battle. Have historians been able to come up with potential candidates for who this may have been?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
1 Answers 2020-08-30
How often did this actually arise? Was in just propaganda in many ways? Was there ever an army that actually taught this idea?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
Question is inspired by Lee Carver’s recent tweet!
https://mobile.twitter.com/carterforva/status/1299950936383787009
1 Answers 2020-08-30
1 Answers 2020-08-30
I understand that it’s necessary to have a certain amount of sodium in the diet to be healthy, so I got to thinking about sodium intake in ancient times.
I’m aware that elsewhere in the world people have been mining and trading salt for quite a long time, but in pre-colonized America, how did they get their salt?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
Today:
Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.
5 Answers 2020-08-30
It was claimed recently that from almost 500 AD – 1,700ish AD, European nations were far behind India when it came to running a very advanced administrative apparatus, extracting tax, maintaining large bureaucracies, a large standing army (the standing armies and navies in India were supposedly 100 times larger than than European armies since the fall of Rome).
Basically India ran a large, diverse and prosperous state unlike Europe which lagged behind in all aspects.
To me this doesn't sound true, given the recent estimates on GDP per capita, the fact that Europeans colonised India and that nothing similar to the Domesday Book exists for India.
How true are these claims?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
Is this true and if so what was it about Greek/Hoplite warfare that made it so difficult to assault wall based fortifications.
Found in this Wikipedia article. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Walls
1 Answers 2020-08-30
You sometimes hear teenagers complain that they were "born in the wrong generation," and artists like The Beatles, The Doors and Jimi Hendrix remain popular among young people today. Is this a relatively new phenomenon, or were there kids in the 1960s who, for example, listened to ragtime and complained that rock 'n' roll required no talent?
2 Answers 2020-08-30
/r/AskHistorians is a specific experience that many people enjoy, but which others don't. Most people in the latter category are normal, well adjusted people who are able to recognize 'different strokes for different folks' and since the Mods aren't literally in their homes, forcing them to browse with a gun to their head, they just... don't come here, or give it a try, decide it isn't for them, and continue on with their life.
Awesome! If you do have something you might suggest, or just want to better understand why the rules are they way they are, you might be interested in earlier entries in this series which discuss just about every aspect of the rules there is. Otherwise, we still think you're pretty cool, so keep on keepin' on.
But some people seem to have not been socialized well as children, and have such an egotistic view of the world that they find it inconceivable that something they don't enjoy could possibly appeal to other people.
This Roundtable is for You, jerkwad.
Putting it in the most basic terms, if you don't like this subreddit, then fuck off! We mean that in the nicest way possible. We deeply appreciate constructive feedback that engages with the intentions behind the subreddit's mission, and take it seriously, but if you just need to vent about how much we suck, just save everyone involved the time.
Here are the ways to 'fuck off' if the issue is that you simply don't know how:
How to Unsubscribe on the Mobile App
How to Unsubscribe on Desktop in 'New' Reddit
How to Unsubscribe on Desktop in 'Old' Reddit
Filter /r/AskHistorians using Reddit Enhancement Suite
No one is forcing you to come here (unless, again, a mod is literally in your home with a gun to your head. Sorry if so, not my fault though), and if you aren't enjoying the experience this subreddit offers, we certainly don't want you to continue to suffer for it, so please leave and try not to embarrass yourself by making a scene. The only thing telling us you've unsubscribed does is let me know to add an RES tag so I can laugh a few months later when you slink back in to ask a question.
We don't mean any of this in a mean way, but we certainly mean it quite seriously. We have over two million unique visitors to the subreddit each month, and most of them come here purposefully because they find what we have to offer to be worth their time, and we aren't going to go about changing things because you don't like it. Complaining about how we won't let you do something against our rules is little different than yelling at the librarian who kicked you out of the silent reading room for blasting Megadeth at full volume, or someone kicked out of Open Mic Night because they decided to literally poop on the stage. People came to that space for a specific experience, and you have no right to impose your own preferences on them or expect your needs to be accommodated in such a way.
You are on one of the biggest websites in the world, which has communities to meet just about every single interest. You can go post on /r/Megadeth if that's your thing, and while I won't look for it, there probably is a subreddit to share pictures of your poop too. And similarly, if you don't like /r/AskHistorians we hardly hold the monopoly on history on reddit, nor even on being a place to ask questions about it. /r/AskHistory is the original community, in fact, and one which we encourage users to go to if they don't want what we have to offer. Similarly /r/History provides a much more general platform for discussion, and /r/HistoryNetwork maintains an extensive list of subreddits on their Wikipage which can provide for almost any interest.
What it comes down to in the end is that the Mod Team here has a specific vision, and we welcome everyone into that space. We don't expect it to be one that fits everyone, nor would we try to make it so. But while we might not expect everyone to enjoy this community, we do expect everyone to respect it. If you can't do even that, then it isn't really our problem, but it certainly says a great deal about you, so fuck off.
For previous Roundtables in this series, please go here.
173 Answers 2020-08-30
Good Day Everyone. During a conversation with a holocaust denier. In regards to them trying their hardest to provethat The Nuremburg Trials were a sham, they brought up the Number of people killed in Auschwitz are different from the Offical Count (1.1 million) and from Rudolph Hoss, who was he longest-serving commandant of the Camp (3 Million) Why is there a decrepency in thes two figures
2 Answers 2020-08-30
How accurate is the Indo-Aryan migration theory? What are your views on the new archaeological evidences found in North India that completely debunk this theory?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
It's commonly claimed that the Khmer Rouge were CiA puppets. If so, why? What reason did America have for toppling the King of Cambodia and replacing him with communists?
Edit:
1 Answers 2020-08-30
I am quite familiar with Roman history, but despite a great wealth of books and podcasts, I have never found a clear explanation of how a roman citizen became a senator. In Latin class I learned about the elaborate system of election used for the magistries in the republican era, and for a long time I believed that membership of the senate was a benefit conferred on those who held senior magistries. But I think that is actually wrong, particulary since the size of the Senate was generally fixed. I've also often seen references to the "Senatorial Class", in a way that implies that it is a separate group to the actual senators and it's membership is defined by property. I understand that the senate's nature, power, size and composition changed dramatically over the course of the republican era and the principate, but no one ever seems to explain how a citizen actually became a senator.
1 Answers 2020-08-30
Is this true? Why didn't they stop, did people not know the end was nigh?
1 Answers 2020-08-30
1 Answers 2020-08-30
3 Answers 2020-08-30
1 Answers 2020-08-30
I would understand if this gets deleted, but the thing I wish to know is why Africans were more prone to forced to go to USA as slaves than South Asian people which was if not more, equally colonized as Africa...
2 Answers 2020-08-30
I’m a historian myself, I studied renaissance, the style, architecture, etc. But after a trip to Tuscany I’ve realised the extensive use of dark green (marble?) and I wonder why? Is it due to the existence of local supplies?
2 Answers 2020-08-30
Hello! I am interested in reading more about the institution of military slavery, which produced such famous soldiers as the mamluks and janissaries. I have read “Slave Soldiers and Islam” by Daniel Pipes.
Is there any more recent research on this issue? I would also be interested in sources from Middles Eastern scholars.
I am mostly intrigued by social history (how these people lived and their relationships with other people) but military/political history is fine as well.
Thanks in advance!
1 Answers 2020-08-30