The Qing Dynasty claimed Outer Manchuria until the region was annexed by Russia in 1860. How much control did the Qing actually have over Outer Manchuria?

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Why are US elections on a Tuesday?

After browsing this thread, I felt I should just come ask the experts. Was it for travel time? Religious observance? Pay day being the 1st? All sound plausible. Why do we vote on Tuesday? What's the history behind that decision?

1 Answers 2020-08-04

In his treatise on the French Revolution, Georges Lefebvre claimed that "racial prejudice was foreign to France," in 1791. How accurate is that claim, and what evidence can be used to either support or refute it?

This claim can be found at the end of Chapter 10, in the section on The Colonies.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

On medieval/middle ages life expectancy

I often see the "myth-busting" fact touted around that the age 25-30 average life expectancy of medieval peasants was brought down by an extremely high infant mortality rate, and that if a medieval peasant made it past their first few years, they could generally expect to live to ages comparable to that of modern people.

Now, I can easily believe that the middle ages have been overly denigrated to make people of the Renaissance and afterwards feel better about themselves, but the above strikes me as over-corrective romanticism.

What I'm really curious about is...where exactly do all these statistics on lifespans and infant mortality rates come from? Exactly *who* was tallying all these dead peasant babies? Where can I look at these records or the analysis thereof?

3 Answers 2020-08-04

Announcing the Best of July Winners!

Another month has passed us by, so it is time to recognize some of the most enjoyed posts of July!

For the 'Flairs' Choice' Award, two competing perspectives on "How did Richard I come to be so fondly lionized in British cultural memory given how marginal of a King he seems to have actually been?" by /u/coeurdelionne and /u/j-force took the top honors, not only answering the question, but also a window into the historiography and interpretation as well.

On the other side, taking the 'Users' Choice' Award was /u/lord_mayor_of_reddit provided insight into "George III and George Washington -- would they have had the same accent?".

The 'Dark Horse' Award, recognizing the top-voted non-flair, was, as always, a close fought contest but in the end the votes recognized /u/sammmuel by a nose for their answer to "Why are there monuments commemorating an SS Division in Canada?".

This month's 'Greatest Question', voted upon by the mods, saw quite a few interesting candidates, but in the end honors "Modern language assumes a degree of agency when dealing with illness ("fighting cancer"/"don't give up"/"giving up and dying") and that personal will contributes at least a little to healing. Would someone in Mediterranean antiquity or Medieval Europe have thought the same way?", which was asked by /u/screwyoushadowban, as well as masterfully answered by /u/UndercoverClassicist.

Finally, the Excellence in Flairdom Award for July goes to one of our superstar FAQ Finder! /u/DanKensington tirelessly defends the gates of "Was medieval medicine really that bad?" and "Drinking water in the Middle Ages would kill you, right?" and has been a fantastic community member all around. Thanks, Dan Kensington!

As always, congrats to our very worthy winners, and thank you to everyone else who has contributed here, whether with thought-provoking questions or fascinating answers. And if this month you want to flag some stand-out posts that you read here for potential nomination, don't forget to post them in our Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check them out here!

3 Answers 2020-08-04

Operation Paperclip involved bringing Nazi scientists to the USA to get an edge in the space race against the USSR post-WWII. How did American scientists react to showing up to work one day to see Nazis in their midst?

I could ask a number of questions about this, which I just found out about the other day, but the fundamental thing I can't stop musing over is, how do you react to being expected to work with members of a nation (and often, believers of an ideology) that your nation just spent four years mobilizing to destroy? Was there any dissent from within these institutions (in general, but particularly from rank-and-file scientists expected to interface with them on a daily basis)? Was there a range of reactions? Did this evolve? Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

The chairs in the recent interview at the White House: what's unique about them? Why are they so short? Was that a trend at some time?

President Trump's recent interview with Jonathan Swan has a lot of comments asking about the chairs: why are they so short? And I want to know, too. Are these chairs antiques? Was this a style at some time? Why? Why do they use them for these one-on-one interviews, is there some significance to these particular chairs? What's the story behind them?

Thanks in advance, sorry for the barrage of questions.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

I've read that when James VI was born, his mother refused to let a priest spit into his mouth at his baptism as was the custom at the time. What was the origin and the meaning of this custom?

And why would she refuse, if it was customary to do so? It seems odd that she would think of it as "gross" if it was a commonly accepted practice.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

How do I find information about my grandpa’s company in WWII? (Rangers 2nd batallion B company)

Pretty much what the title says. I grew up hearing stories from his time in the war and I’d like to learn more about the big picture of what they did. Any information is appreciated. Thank you.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Were the deaths of knights at the Battle of Agincourt considered an attrocity or merely a surprise victory (clarification below)?

I was taught that killing knights (especially by peasants) was heavily taboo in the Hundred Years War, instead being taken hostage for ransom. I have also read accounts of the thousands of dead French knights at Agincourt and even the English soldiers wading through the mud with knives the end the lives of the dying after the battle. What context am I missing that reconciles these two facts? Thank you in advance for the answers!

1 Answers 2020-08-04

TUESDAY TRIVIA: “The problem with the world is that everyone is a few drinks behind” (Humphrey Bogart*)- what did they drink in your era? Let's talk about the HISTORY OF BEVERAGES AND DRINKING!

Welcome to Tuesday Trivia!

If you are:

this thread is for you ALL!

Come share the cool stuff you love about the past! Please don’t just write a phrase or a sentence—explain the thing, get us interested in it! Include sources especially if you think other people might be interested in them.

AskHistorians requires that answers be supported by published research. We do not allow posts based on personal or relatives' anecdotes. All other rules also apply—no bigotry, current events, and so forth.

For this round, let’s look at: BEVERAGES AND DRINKING! What drinks, alcoholic or otherwise, were popular in your period? Were there any interesting customs related to drinking? Did anyone do anything really nuts under the influence? Answer one of these or totally spin off into your own thing!

Next time: THE MOMENT IT ALL CHANGED!

^(*two Humphrey Bogart quotes two weeks in a row is down to sheer coincidence as well as Humphrey Bogart being awesome)

4 Answers 2020-08-04

The christian saxon poem Heliand (describing Biblical events with a germanic-compatible narrative) is credited by one author as the origin of "culture of knighthood and become the foundation of medieval Europe". Is there validity to this claim ?

I'd never heard this theory before. it was mentionned in /r/france through the Wikipedia article about Heiland : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heliand.

In this article, it is written that an author, G. Ronald Murphy of Georgetown University wrote in a 1989 book, The Saxon Saviour: The Germanic Transformation of the Gospel in the Ninth-Century Heliand that :

Murphy depicts the significant influence the Heliand had over the fate of European society; he writes that the author of the Heliand "created a unique cultural synthesis between Christianity and Germanic warrior society – a synthesis that would plant the seed that would one day blossom in the full-blown culture of knighthood and become the foundation of medieval Europe."

This claim surprises me. Could someone knowledgeable on the matter enlighten / correct me ?

Thanks !

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Is it true that Harry S. Truman was an anti-semite?

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Books about the Mongol Empire (and, if possible, the attempted Mongol invasions of Japan)

I've just finished playing a video game called "Ghost of Tsushima" set during the first Mongol invasion of Japan and it piqued my curiosity. We never really covered this period of history much in (British) school (the 13th century was just "dark ages") and I'm looking for a good primer / overview of the Mongol empire, and if possible a book with a sub section about the attempted invasions of Japan.

Many thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Why were soldiers specifically targeting civilians in the Yugoslavian wars?

Hi everyone!

I am wondering why soldiers (I am mainly thinking of the Serbs in Sarajevo) were specifically targeting civilians? I am not talking about carelessness or accidents, but about deliberated targeting.

What was their objective by doing so? Was it part of a policy of punishment-revenge? Was it "simply" soldiers not giving a fuck and """having fun""" by doing these things? Did they consider civilians as actual threats so shot them "whenever they had the chance"? What's in for them to shoot people who were obviously civilians in "Sniper Alley"?

Thank you very much for your time.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

How did the King of France react when his subordinate, Duke William, became an independent King of England

I don’t remember ever hearing about a war ensuing immediately after this, but I find it hard to believe that a King would willing let his subordinate become independent without trying to claim that all of England was his by default.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

In ancient Rome, what are Plebeian Aristocrats?

I'm reading Augustus by Adrian Goldsworthy and have seen them referenced a couple of times. My understanding of this era is limited, but I've always assumed that the Plebeians were the poor or the working class or something like that, and the Patricians were the rich and were presumably nobles - or something like aristocrats. Is it the case that some plebeian families were quite rich and therefore considered to be aristocrats? Or is there some distinction that I'm not grasping here? Thanks in advance.

2 Answers 2020-08-04

Were there Moors in Hernan Cortes' army?

Speaking that Granada fell in 1492, some 27 years before Cortes and his band of colonizers invaded the Aztec Empire, I assume that they were some Moors or Iberian Muslims who joined the Conquest if they were all not expelled by then.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Why did a portion of the Iraqi Air Force escape to Iran during the Gulf War? It seems to be an odd choice since both countries concluded their conflict just a few years before.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

"Cornfields now are where Troy once was". How do abandoned cities physically disappear and have to be excavated?

I am thinking not just of Troy, that was repeatedly destroyed and repopulated, but also of cities of Mesopotamia that literally became hills, many Chinese of Egyptian capitals whose locations had to be guessed by archaeologists, and even Rome, which clearly was mainly fields in between ruins of bigger buildings in the Middle Ages, when its population was about 3 percent of the Ancient peak. How does this happen?

Edit: in particular, what did those cities look like at different stages of the process, say Ur just before and a hundred, and five hundred years after being abandoned, or Rome not long after the end of grain shipments and war population losses? Was it an endless stretch of empty buildings with a few inhabited ones in between? Could you just walk into a palace or mansion and say "okay, this will do for me"? Sorry about the typo in the title.

3 Answers 2020-08-04

Was Adolf Hitler intelligent or just a good orator?

I know the defendants at Nuremberg were given IQ tests and scored fairly high, one as high as 142. They all praised Hitler’s intelligence and character. So has there been any attempts to analyze Hitler’s intelligence on any scale?

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Could Japan have invaded Australia?

So It's "common knowledge" here in Australia we were under serious threat of invasion by the Japanese in WW2, but I don't really think the threat was that great given as I understand Japans situation at the time, fighting in China, lacking serious oil resources, fighting in west Asia and threat of the American fleet in the Pacific. Was Australia actually under a serious threat of invasion from the Japanese? To me it doesn't seem so.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Why didn't the Russian Empire expel its Jewish population like England did in 1290 and Spain in 1492?

1 Answers 2020-08-04

How did the common folk of Revolutionary America really feel about "No Taxation Without Representation"?

I'm curious about how much the taxes on tea (and other goods by the British) impacted the average American. I thought these were more like export taxes, which would surely only affect the exporters. Were there also sizable taxes on goods into the colonies resulting in high prices paid? And how much importing did the average American do because I would assume most people lived a bit minimalistically and provided for themselves or locally for the most part.

And that ties into the representation side too since that was the rallying cry.

Were these causes of taxation and representation important to the average American?

1 Answers 2020-08-04

Roman legion troop rotation in centuries

I had decided to rewatch Rome on HBO which i had not seen since latin class 2006, (great class better teacher) and the opening scene has lucious vorenus, a centurion blowing his whistle to rotate troops from the front line of the century ostensibly to keep those fighting fresh.

My question (well questions...), was this a roman innovation? Did the Greek phalanx do this or something similar? Did this come about from the Marian reforms or was this something the hastati principes oe triarii used during the maniple system?

Apologies for formatting and errors am on my phone and thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2020-08-04

1173 / 7255

Back to start