Did the Indigenous populations of North America, and especially of Central America, have a concept of nudity or nakedness prior to encountering Cristopher Columbus and other early explorers of the New World?

I've seen a lot of paintings / depictions of Cristopher Columbus interacting with the native inhabitants of the "New World", and in most of the them the natives are nude, or mostly nude, especially the women. The men usually have a loin cloth or something, but were these depictions accurate? Or are they simply a result of artistic embellishment?

Also this may be a silly question but were breasts sexualized, by the native populations (or even by the European settlers) in a way that is comparable to how they are sexualized nowadays?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

From a historical standpoint, Was Jesus a real person? What evidence do we have that he existed?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

The Conquistadors: Failed expeditions

I was reading one of Stefan Zweig's books, and he mentions Spanish expeditions in which the people involved all died, disappeared into the rainforest forever, and even went native.

Is this true? I know Cortez and co were very successful, but i'm more interested in expeditions which were great failures. Any resources on this?

Love you guys as always.

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Were entire cross sections of tree trunks actually used as wheels? If so, when did we change over to the better recognized spoke wheel?

The Turkish television series Diriliş: Ertuğrul portrays a wagon in the year 1225 near Konya as using cross sections of tree trunks for wheels; smaller sections in the front and larger behind. Does this form of wheel have historical precedence? Would it have been limited to this area, or was it more universal?

I recognize that this is a weird question, it just jumped out at me and I can't seem to find any answers on the web aside from one that was just commenting on their inclusion in the show.

If anyone needs the visual it is at about 12:35 in the first episode, the show is available on Netflix.

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Why were wealthy Italian cities so keen on helping crusaders?

I'm reading Thomas Asbridge and he doesn't really adress this (don't blame him for that, the book is thourough enough as it is). I get that they must have been paid for transport but he does note that Italian fleets were crucial for the naval defense of tyre, which must've cost them a lot of losses.

Did they do it out of the same devotion most crusaders cite as their motivation or were their motives more financial?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Religious Freedom in America

American children are often told the story of the Pilgrims coming to the New World in pursuit of religious freedom.

What was so different/radical about their beliefs that they felt the need to go into the unknown in order to live?

Second part: Could this be why we have such a fundamentalist attitude amongst Politicians and Christians in the modern day?

2 Answers 2020-07-16

Why was Leif Erikson's discovery of America forgotten?

This seems like it should be a very simple question but for some reason absolutely no source I have been able to find addresses this... if Leif Erikson discovered America before Columbus, then why does nobody in Europe seem to know about America until Columbus set foot on the Caribbean? Why didn't Leif Erikson tell anyone, and, since he did seem to keep it a secret, how did we even find out that he discovered it first?

2 Answers 2020-07-16

Why wasn't urban warfare as deadly to invaders in the medieval and classical periods as in the modern age?

In modern warfare, urban battles are very deadly to invaders (see for example, Battle of Hue, inter alia) and seem to be one of the forms of warfare that is most punishing and least appetizing for advanced militaries (the Germans' experience in Stalingrad, the Americans' experience in defeating the insurgency in Iraq, for example in Fallujah).

In the medieval and classical period, it seems that all the focus (and all the difficulty) in conquering a city was based on breaching the city's walls and getting one's soldiers inside. Once the soldiers are in, the city's inhabitants seem to have no ability to defend themselves. This is in contrast to modern warfare where even a small group of resistance fighters can tie down, hinder, and bleed an invading army for days or weeks. What changes account for this shift in dynamics in urban warfare?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Why does Belarus exist?

70% Of Belarussians speak Russia at home and the country has only been independent for a very short time under German occupation in WW1 before. The country has been under MANY different invaders, and unlike other USSR Republics it speaks mostly the same language as Russia and the culture is kinda the same.

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | July 16, 2020

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Did Sultan Mehmet legally buy Hagia Sophia or was it all just a hoax that got promoted because he conquered the Byzantine empire and he was the one in power. What exactly were the dynamics of the situation back then?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Tow rope girls (shanty)

So I’m not sure if this is even the correct place to ask this question but I’ve been listening to some sea shanties lately and while listening to tow rope girls I realised I

  1. Have no idea what a tow rope is.

  2. Don’t understand what’s meant to be portrayed by the girls having hold of their tow rope today

Is this something the wives of sailors did before the men set sail?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

I've heard that during the medieval era of Japan, as they lack of iron/copper deposit inside of their territory, the only piece of metal for a soldier was often their weapon, and even quite a lot have only wooden weapon, is that true?

Is it also true that as they have a lot of gold and silver deposit they often import weapon and armor from China in exchange of the gold/silver?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

When did music start being considered an integral part of the cultural identity of peoples, polities, regions etc?

When reading pre-modern sources I’ve seen a lot of authors defining “otherness” in terms of religion, clothing, warfare, social customs, sexual customs and even hair grooming (those long haired spartans), but I don’t remember reading “they are different from us because they use these weird scales/instruments/patterns etc”. In the XIX Century certain music made by white people went from being considered a functional tool to being considered “expressive art", and it is this Nationalist context that created the concept of “folk music”, but that’s not my point; clothing is purely functional and still a tool of cultural identity and difference- tunic vs pants for instance.

So, are there any examples of people using musical characteristics to conceptualize differences in identity before European nationalism?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Border between East and West Germany

You always hear about the Berlin Wall and the attempts to cross it, but what about the larger border between East and West Germany as a hole?

Was it policed well? Were there also notable escape attempts/smuggling? Were there also walls (or fences, barbed wire, landmines generally just barriers)?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

What soft furnishings were used in Vietnamese houses in pre-colonial Vietnam?

I am particularly interested in whether anyone can identify this piece of furniture seen in two 18th century paintings. (Full paintings here and here.) However, any general information about soft furnishings, or even any furniture, would be really helpful. Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Why was Giordano Bruno burned alive, Galileo imprisoned and Copernicus not even judged? Didn't they have the same theory?

2 Answers 2020-07-16

How did the people of Catalhoyuk know what fat people looked like?

The famous statue, the Seated Woman of Catalhoyuk has been on my mind because of its relative anatomical accuracy in portraying a person with large amounts of fat. I'm under the impression that nobody was actually like this in early neolithic settlements. Am I overestimating what it takes to extrapolate what an obese person would look like without ever having seen one, or is there more to this?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

How did the people of France go from executing a king in 1793 to near-unanimously endorsing an emperor in 1804? How was Napoleon able to convince people that his absolute rule was different to the kings'?

Inspired by looking at David's 1804 painting The Coronation of Napoleon, which looks to my non-specialist eye about as 'absolute monarch' and 'Sun King' as it's possible to get.

It seems difficult to reconcile the spirit of the French Revolution - more specifically, the anti-monarchical anger of 1792-3 - with Napoleon's openly and (apparently) hugely popular autocracy. What changed in little more than a decade to swing popular opinion round? Did he somehow convince people that 'liberty, equality, fraternity' could sit alongside one-man rule, or does his success show that the earlier opposition to the king was more about Louis XVI than the idea of monarchy?

4 Answers 2020-07-16

Why are the Iliad and the Odyssey considered poems? Was all ancient / classic literature written in poem? And if it so, why?

I’m also curious what the origins of poetry are and how it has evolved over the ages. Would you say the poetry of the 1800’s is comparable to the poems of Ancient Greece. Does poetry even exist anymore or is it a dead medium aside from the the music industry - or is that the same thing? insights on any of this would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-07-16

How did hitler get such a high % of people to vote for him? Were the votes rigged, before he was even in power?

Before hitler was even in power, they got 92% of people to vote for them. How did they archieve that. Were people actually convinced to that degree of him, or did they somehow rig the votes? What is the consensus on this topic?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

An ancestor was born in 1785 in Dusseldorf and by 1815 is listed as a "retired soldier". What kind of action could he theoretically have seen in his time?

But it's not reallly about him, I'm just curious what a regular soldier from a place like Dusseldorf would face, in what I imagine were pretty turbulent times in Europe.

Random facts, which may or may not factor into an answer: He gets married in 1815 in the Dutch city of Groningen, to a Dutch woman. He is 30 at this time, which seems pretty late to get married, but maybe that was normal for military men. Judging from his job descriptions and frequent address changes on the subsequent birth certificates for his children, he's getting by with odd labor jobs and eventually works as a garbage sweep. But sometimes he is still listed as "retired soldier". If he recieved an actual pension it would've been not enough to live from, I reckon.

1 Answers 2020-07-16

Can someone help me find out what language this is and how to go about translating it?

Hi there! I found this beautiful hand painted image at the thrift store today. Can someone help me figure out what is going on in this scene? Thank you!

https://imgur.com/gallery/LxJ85vg

2 Answers 2020-07-16

Was there any discussion of surrender by the colonies in the early setbacks of the American Revolutiuonary War?

From my limited understanding, the Continental Army had some hard days where victory was far from assured. Was there any talk of surrender or trying to cut a deal with the British in those times?

2 Answers 2020-07-16

How did Napoleon deal with the heat in Egypt?

I can not seem to find any logical means as to how Napoleon invaded Egypt with a 19th Century European style army before Khaki and other heat friendly uniforms came in to play during the late 1800s. From the paintings I have seen that Napoleon's army kept their iconic blue uniforms with long sleeves and trousers with tunics depending on the unit. This doesn't exactly scream "airflow" so I wonder if they adapted their uniform to the climate or did the Napoleonic French keep their European style uniforms on and suffer throught the heat.

TLDR: What uniforms did the French wear in Egypt?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

1210 / 7255

Back to start