When talking about medieval Europe why is discussion mostly based on Western Europe, and not Eastern Europe as well?

2 Answers 2020-07-07

What's your favorite history book you would recommend anyone remotely interested in that topic to pick up.

Preferably an easier read book. Around highschool level Even if the person is not interested in that topic, a book you would recommend to someone who either likes to read or is showing interest in history.

2 Answers 2020-07-07

History of the US School System

I’m in search of a podcast, audiobook, YouTube series, articles, books, etc on the history of the United States’ public school system.

Specifically its origins and how the system was influenced.

I’ve talked with my dad (who was a public school teacher for 8 years) about some German influence on the US education system. Any specifics on the German or even Nazi influence specifically interests me.

Thanks in advance for any help!

1 Answers 2020-07-07

Interested in presenting at the AskHistorians 2020 Digital Conference? Abstracts are due July 10th (This Friday!).

#AskHistorians2020 - Sept. 15th-17th

Hello Everyone! As you are likely aware by now, we are planning to host the AskHistorians 2020 Digital Conference, "Business as Unusual: Histories of Rupture, Chaos, Revolution, and Change" on September 15th to 17th.

The Call for Papers went out last month, but if you have been on the fence about submitting an abstract, it isn't too late to pull the trigger (and seriously, you should!). If you are interested in submitting, you'll find the full CfP linked below, as well as on our Conference site. We ask that abstracts of no more than 200 words and a short biography of no more than 100 words be sent to us at askhistorians@gmail.com by 11:59 PM EDT on 10 July 2020.

If you have any questions for the Planning Committee, you can ask them here, or send them to the above. And of course, please be sure to circulate this Call for Papers within your departments and networks as well, as we want to really get the word out as much as possible!

The Full Call for Papers

1 Answers 2020-07-07

In Weird Al's song Amish Paradise, he sings "If I finish all of my chores and you finish thine Then tonight we're gonna party like it's 1699". What would a party in 1699 have been like, and are traditional Amish celebrations similar?

1 Answers 2020-07-07

I just read a 2004 article that St Marks body in Venice might be the body of Alexander The Great. It is the first I ever heard of it. Was/is it a credible theory? How is this theory viewed now?

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/does-the-tomb-of-st-mark-in-venice-really-contain-the-bones-of-alexander-the-great-732020.html

I read this article in the askreddit thread about mysteries. The article is from 2004. Did anything happen with this? Did the theory gain or lose credibility? This is the first I’ve heard of it.

1 Answers 2020-07-07

How did women in the olden days (English, Scottish, etc...) wear those big, long dresses that trailed on the ground when the paths were muddy and also filled with animal poo? Wouldn't they carry disease into their homes from their clothing and wouldn't it rip and cause damage to the garment?

2 Answers 2020-07-07

How accurate the story of "Suspiro del Mauro" sigh of the Moor ?

Is it a Myth or a true story ? If it's accurate, how the fact of the sigh came to the population So that it is passed on from generation to generation until now?

1 Answers 2020-07-07

Throughout the ages of religion the most hated of main religions seems to be the Jews, how did this hatred start? And why are the Jews blamed for so much?

If it seems like this question was phrased in an anti-Semitic it was unintentional, I’m just curious why some people don’t like them.

1 Answers 2020-07-07

When did the west "lose" 8 years (it should be 2029 now)

Hi! I know that Russia threw out these 8 years during the rule of Peter I. Basically he just looked at the west and unified the calendar. When did a similar change happen in other countries? Not that long ago I came across someone mentioning this. Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-07-07

How did the white planter class monopolized power in the antebellum South?

1 Answers 2020-07-07

Was President Lincoln prejudice, racist or bigoted in any way?

After his death, Frederick Douglass said of Lincoln “Though Mr. Lincoln shared the prejudices of his white fellow-countrymen against the Negro, it is hardly necessary to say that in his heart of hearts he loathed and hated slavery ...”

Did Lincoln actually show any signs of prejudice?

2 Answers 2020-07-07

Is it accurate to conclude that racism and classism were purposeful strategies used by the colonial ruling class to divide the poor white, enslaved, and Native America residents?

I have been reading Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States. A common theme I’ve found has been that the ruling class, merchants, politicians, and wealthy slave owners, used racism and classism to divide the much larger and poorer lower classes/slaves. Zinn implies that racism and classism were purposeful tools (although initially accidental ones) of the ruling class.

I’m curious what evidence history provides for this type of conspiracy, that is, where the “ruling class” purposefully divides the poor and enslaved using racism and classism to maintain their power. Could it be that racism and classism were more of a coincidence which benefited these rich colonists, and less of a conspiracy, as Zinn implies? I find it hard to believe that the ruling class was capable of executing such a strategy. Below is an excerpt, from pages 54-58 in the chapter “Persons of Mean and Vile Conditions”. Thank you for your time and patience.

By the years of the Revolutionary Crisis, the 1760s, the wealthy elite that controlled the British colonies on the American mainland had 150 years of experience, had learned certain things about how to rule... With the problem of Indian hostility, and the danger of slave revolts, the colonial elite has to consider the class anger of poor whites... as violence and the threat of violence increased, the problem of control became more serious.

And so laws and were passed prohibiting free blacks from traveling to Indian country...Negroes were forbidden from carrying arms, while whites finishing their servitude received muskets...

There was still another control, [the middle class], which became handy as the colonies grew... Those upper classes, to rule, needed to make concessions to the middle class, without damage to their own wealth or power, at the expense of slaves, Indians, and poor whites. This bought loyalty. And to bind that loyalty with something more powerful... the ruling group found... that the language of liberty and equality... could unite just enough whites to fight a Revolution... without ending slavery and inequality.

3 Answers 2020-07-07

I know that Corsets were just underwear and generally fitted to the wearer, and tightlacing was not the norm in the eras that wore them, but what did pregnant women wear as undergarments when the belly got in the way?

1 Answers 2020-07-07

Did some of the 101st Airborne participate in the amphibious assault on Normandy?

I know it sounds like a weird question. I had always just assumed that Airborne was just...well, Airborne. However, I was recently watching footage of the invasion as narrated by Jack Lieb in which he recounted being on landing craft with elements on the 101st. I tried to find some information on this and I cannot find anything. I included a link to the footage below, and he mentions the 101st around 7:50. Regardless, it's pretty interesting narration and footage.

https://youtu.be/a4kmRTZrgMQ

1 Answers 2020-07-07

How did the fledgling United Nations coordinate forces from several different nationalities during Korean War peacekeeping operations?

The United Nations can't have had much time to put in place many bureaucratic institutions or coordinate the compatibility of military equipment across its member nations. So how did all these different countries operate effectively in the Korean War?

At the minimum, I'd think radio equipment, encryption practices, and tactical doctrines would need to be harmonized.

1 Answers 2020-07-07

How can we consider the Shang or Xia to be Chinese “dynasties” if they didn’t rule a unified China like the Qin did?

So I’m watching Crash Course World History and this question popped up for me.

Chinese Emperor Qin Shi Huang Di of the Qin Dynasty became the first ruler of a unified China after a warring states period. That’s why if I google “first emperor of China,” his name will show up first. Makes sense.

However, since China was not always from the beginning a unified state, and the Qin Dynasty wasn’t the first Chinese Dynasty (the Shang or Xia are believed to be the first dynasties and it wasn’t until after a warring states period that the Qin came into power), my question is: how can we consider the Shang or Xia to be Chinese “dynasties” if they didn’t rule all of China like the Qin did? Isn’t the point of a ruling state to rule over all the states?

Additionally, if China wasn’t unified before the Qin came into power, how could there have been ”dynasties” at all? Was China just separate states/city states that fought each other for power, even though they were all “Chinese”?

If China consisted of multiple states during the Shang/Xia dynasties, does this not mean that multiple dynasties/states could have ruled at the same time then, since each Chinese state would have its own rulers and therefore, dynasties?

Like, for example if China had 100 non unified states during the Shang Dynasty, but only one of these states were actually ruled by a group called the Shang, how can we call this period the “Shang Dynasty” if the other 99 states were ruled by those who were NOT the Shang?

Also, who was the very first emperor of the non-unified China then, if it wasn’t Emperor Qin during the Qin Dynasty? But then again, how can you have a singular ruler/emperor of separate states that aren’t united?

1 Answers 2020-07-07

What were the counter arguments Abolitionists made to sway the religious minded against slavery when the Bible so clearly seemed to tolerate and support it?

1 Answers 2020-07-07

Hygiene in 18th century America - how bad did colonials smell?

Lately I've been hooked on reading about colonial America (and primarily the American revolutionary period). One particular subject I haven't been able to find much on is the hygiene and bathing practices at the time, of which I've read conflicting reports. Can anyone here shed some light on this? Mostly interested in the hygiene practices of the average colonial family in the second half of the 18th century.

Main questions are:

  1. How did they (and how often did they) bathe, or otherwise wash themselves?
  2. Oral hygiene
  3. Hair care and wigs
  4. Laundry and care of clothing

Thanks!

2 Answers 2020-07-06

When the barter system was replaced by cash, were there wild conspiracy theories that the government was trying to control citizens?

1 Answers 2020-07-06

During the holocaust, were there any Jews that got overlooked by the regime, because they weren’t very involved in the Jewish community, or otherwise “obviously” Jewish?

Not everyone identifies strongly with their ethnicity or religion. I know many Jews that would consider themselves lots of things before “Jewish.” I think maybe some of my friends know that my dad is Jewish and wouldn’t be surprised if they forgot, because it’s not something that comes up a lot. If it weren’t for our last name, no random acquaintance would guess anything was Jewish about us without being told.

I’ve read many fascinating stories about about how people managed to avoid getting deported to the camps. But did it happen that someone went unnoticed by the nazis, because they didn’t have jewish relatives where they lived, didn’t go to temple, didn’t have a Jewish name, etc?

1 Answers 2020-07-06

The History of Partridge Island, New Brunswick.

Myself and my roommate are filming and narrating a video of ourselves exploring the abandoned Partridge Island and want to include as much accurate history as possible.

I have done some preliminary research online and have compiled a rough time line and jotted down some notes. I was wondering if anyone hear had anything to add pr had more insight on the island.

Timeline:

1785-Island first Established as quaratine station, 1812-Gun Batteries Built/military base, 1816-First used as quarantine station, 1830s- first hospital is built on the island, 1840s- Ireland suffers great potato famine, 30k people are processed through partridge, 1196 of which pass away, 1846-Typhus epidemic, 1890s-original celtic cross monument destroyed in WW1, 1927- New celtic cross erected, 1974- Island is declared a historic site

Compiled information:

1830s-1920s 6 mass graveyards were created on island (Protestant, Catholic and Jewish that I know of)

1800s-1947 served as Saint John's Military base

1982-1995 Boat tours hosted to island

1830-1941 used as quarantine station

1955, 1998-1999 buildings are demolished

I was wondering if anyone also had any insight on how much of this is true as we would obviously like the information to be as accurate as possible.

1 Answers 2020-07-06

From the country's founding until the civil war, what percentages of non-enslaved americans (north and south) support the institution of slavery?

1 Answers 2020-07-06

George Wallace the man famous for saying, “Segregation now, segregation tomorrow, and segregation forever.”, would later win the 1982 Alabama gubernatorial race with a whopping 90% of the black vote. How did that happen?

1 Answers 2020-07-06

In the Domesday book, Kimmeridge Bay, Dorset, is noted for having an oil well. What would an oil well have looked like and how would the product have been refined and used in the 11th century?

1 Answers 2020-07-06

1229 / 7255

Back to start