Why were Victorian era boys dressed as girls up to the age of approx. 6 years?

Apparently it was common to dress male children in frocks and keep their hair long for some reason, why was this?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

In the past hundred years, fantasy conlangs like Sindarin and Klingon have been created to enhance their respective worlds. Do we know of any civilization or person pre-1900 that invented or used conlangs to enhance their storytelling?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

When east-west U.S. state boundaries were surveyed in the 17th-early 19th centuries, why were there so many surveying errors?

Many purportedly-straight-line east-west state boundaries were first surveyed in the period from the 1600s up until the early 19th century, such as the northern and southern boundaries of Massachusetts, the Mason-Dixon Line, the southern boundary of Virginia, and the northern and southern boundaries of Tennessee.

Many of these boundaries notoriously deviate from being straight lines. Given that surveying lines of latitude (as opposed to longitude) was a well-understood technology during that time period, and land surveying lacks many of the challenges of naval latitude reckoning, why were there so many surveying errors, and why are some of those errors so severe?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

How did the concept of 'the founding fathers' of the US come to be?

The not-always-clearly-defined group of 'founding fathers' are central to the American mythos, but when did this idea take root in American society?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Was musolini popular with italians during his reign?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Was Thomas Jefferson a pedophile?

I guess it's by modern standards. Not sure if consent laws existed back then?

Jefferson brought his 14 year old slave to Paris. By the time they went back she was pregnant and wouldn't return without rights to her person. DNA testing today does suggest the child was Jefferson's.

So, in 1800s standards, would a man in his 40s having sex with a teenager be considered pedophilia? Let's ignore the race element here if needed. If she was white and this occurred, how would most people react?

If Thomas Jefferson, in his 40s, wed a teenager, how would the nation react? Would he be called a pedophile? Did such labels even exist back then?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Was Abraham Lincoln a conservative or a liberal?

I’ve been trying to research the party realignment but it’s been hard to find a lot of information about Lincoln

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Is Christopher Columbus credited for linking "lost peoples" to known world?

So on FB today, I came across someone making this claim, " The natives from the artic to the southern most tip of south America. Can all be linked to the 8 families that crossed the land bridge from Asia to Alaska. Columbus is given credit for linking the "lost" human race. That had no other way of contacting the "known" peoples. Until Columbus made his voyage. It is true that Columbus brought diseases to the Americas. But he also brought syphilis back to Europe. ".

I've used my google fu to no avail finding any way to confirm or discredit this statement. I've never heard of this viewpoint of Columbus.

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Looking for books about the history of Georgia [Sakartvelo]

I am looking for some good books to read about the history of Georgia, as it is a place that I am enamored with and have visited about 3 years ago. I will also take any good podcasts that you know as well. Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-06-30

How did navies even find eachother in the 18th century?

The sea is enormous. Ships during the age of sail where really slow and you could only see like ~10km.

Mahan always writes about "lanes" which where "known" and used by ships, but he never gives a specific example - or I didnt find it yet.

How did the mechanics of finding the enemy work in tje open ocean? Where there hundreds of small ships working together in a net and relaying information to the main fleet via signals?

Maha writes ships tried to intercept the enemy at the point of departure - fe the english fleet keeping a clode Blockade of brest. But how did this work in detail? Did they sail up and down a few km out of the harbor for months - until some other ships took there post?

I can understand the operational strategy of the navies at that time, but I just csnt wrap my head sround how these things could work in practice with such slow cumversome ships without any tech like radio etc.

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Does the study of history have a different standard for truth than science?

I'm not a historian or a scientist, so apologies if I'm completely idiotic in asking this, but does the study of history have a lower/different standard for considering something true than science?

I understand that, in science, you would normally need to be able to repeat and test a proposition to verify that it is correct, and I'd guess that generally isn't possible in history, so what do historians do when they find a document which claims a certain thing happened? How do they weigh the truth of one historical person's claim against another?

2 Answers 2020-06-30

TUESDAY TRIVIA: "A woman who cuts her hair is about to change her life" (Coco Chanel)- why don't you change our lives a bit with some fascinating discussion of the HISTORY OF HAIR!

Welcome to Tuesday Trivia!

If you are:

this thread is for you ALL!

Come share the cool stuff you love about the past! Please don’t just write a phrase or a sentence—explain the thing, get us interested in it! Include sources especially if you think other people might be interested in them.

AskHistorians requires that answers be supported by published research. We do not allow posts based on personal or relatives' anecdotes. All other rules also apply—no bigotry, current events, and so forth.

For this round, let’s look at: HAIR! How did people in your era wear their hair? Did hair have any special significance? Did people cover their hair- or lack thereof- with anything interesting, like hats or wigs? What about hair removal? Answer one of these or come up with something else of your own!

Next time: TRANSPORTATION!

3 Answers 2020-06-30

Why did the mortality rate of the gulags rise suddenly in 1933?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag#Mortality_rate

I understand that the death tolls that the high mortality rates in the early 1940s was due to WW2, but what caused it to rise from 4.8% in 1932, to 15.3% in 1933, and right back down to 4.28% in 1934?

I know it was probably due to the famine, but I find it hard to believe it rose by more than 3x in one year

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Why do so many medieval manuscripts depict butt trumpets?

https://designyoutrust.com/2020/06/why-so-many-medieval-manuscripts-depict-butt-trumpets/

Thought this article was explaining why, but alas. Mayhaps you could endeavour to enlighten us

2 Answers 2020-06-30

A question about casta and status in Puerto Rico

I know this is a bit of a weird question, but I'm trying to understand the way the casta was applied, particularly in Puerto Rico.

Take for example, me. My (legal) grandfather was mixed indigenous and African, thought I can't say what percentage of each. And from what I see on the casta charts, he could be anything from China cambuja, to Lobo, to Albarazado, to Barzino, or like five other things. My grandmother was blonde-haired and blue-eyed, which I take to either be Mestiza or Torna atras. My mother is completely white, though she has dark hair and dark eyes.

My father, on the other hand, is half-Italian and half-Polish. I know that the Casta was manipulated by people it ruled over by claiming to be one thing in one setting, and another in another setting (for tax or conscription benefits). If my grandparents had been born two or three centuries earlier, I'm sure they could have taken advantage of this (was that even possible in Puerto Rico?).

My question is about my European father. The casta charts all start with Españoles y Españolas. Were all Europeans subsumed under that title? Or were children of non-Spanish but European parentage something else in the casta system?

Generally, how strong was the casta system applied in Puerto Rico? The demographics of the island seems (to my cursory understanding of the island's colonial history) to change pretty dramatically, and pretty quickly. I know this is a bit of a weird question, but I find trying to understand the casta to be like trying to grab something slippery.

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Why was Egypt the main target of most of the Crusades, and not "The Holy Land"?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Are there any accounts of sword fights? I have googled it to no avail, I have always been more interested in the human side of history, as in what was it like for the bystanders? How skilled were tbe participants etc.

2 Answers 2020-06-30

Were any Allied soldiers held accountable for any war crimes they committed(WW2)?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

any good books to learn about canadian history/politics?

So I'm looking kinda an academic book to learn about the history and politics of Canada, not searching for novels or anything like that, i'd like something a bit professional, hope you guys can help me :)

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Were the dogs of the Americas domesticated independently of those in Eurasia?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

In the seven years war and thirty years war, Britain and Prussia were allies. When did this fall apart and why?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

David Graeber suggests that Roman gladiatorial combat (particularly audience participation in the fate of the loser) was purposefully designed by the wealthy to teach the lesson that self-governance would result in violent mob rule. Is there historical evidence that this was intentional?

I certainly wouldn't dispute the idea that gladiatorial combat contains an anti-democratic kernel. I just wonder if there's evidence to show that those who organized the circus intentionally included this aspect of audience participation as a piece of anti-democratic propaganda.

Please see this excerpt from David Graeber's Batman and the Problem of Constituent Power for context:

Authoritarian regimes often make a point of setting up similarly sadistic forms of entertainment, always, to make the same subtle political point. Roman games are just the most notorious example. Where in Athens, the largest occasions for citizens to gather together in public were democratic assemblies, where citizens voted on the great issues of the day, Roman grandees instead sponsored vast organized lynch mobs, where voting consisted of casting thumbs up or down to decide whether to cut some defeated gladiator’s throat. The underlying message—that democratic self-governance would be disastrous, as it would instantly descend into just this sort of violent mob psychology— was so effective that opponents of democracy have pointed to the behavior of the Roman circus ever since.

1 Answers 2020-06-30

How did the Ashkenazi Jews get to Europe?

My understanding had been that Jews were exiled from Israel, and some of them went to Central Europe (France/Germany) and later moved east (Germany/Poland/Russia/etc). Looking into it though, it seems there have been multiple exiles of Jews from Israel (and that there were European women that converted among the Ashkenazim but that's not relevant here), and some Jews that simply moved out of Israel, for various reasons.

So, how did the Ashkenazi Jews get to Europe? Were they exiled, and if so, in which exile? If they chose to leave, when did they leave under what circumstances?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

Wasn't the US Revolutionary War a civil war, since the colonies were British territories?

A civil war is a war between citizens of the same country. Colonists, in large part, were British citizens and the territory they fought in was British territory.

1 Answers 2020-06-30

How accurate the translators were in the ancient world?

How accurate the translators were in the ancient world, for example, did the Athenians had people who spoke Persian perfectly and vice versa for all the other languages they had to trade in and interact, or the translators were just good enough translating the core meaning from each language without very much detail. If someone from Europe at the same time period wanted to trade with very far way places in Asia, how hard communicating perfectly with them was?

1 Answers 2020-06-30

1242 / 7255

Back to start