In some Second World War films, trains were considered a viable form of transportation to travel between cities. How likely were non-military trains attacked by the allies and was it enough where people stopped traveling?

Were there restrictions to civilians on traveling on these trains? Could one commute or travel for personal reasons using the trains?

1 Answers 2020-05-30

What happened to the Generals that Hitler fired.

Was listening to Dan Carlin’s hardcore history discussing the eastern front. During this he mentioned numerous times when a General at HQ disagreed with Hitler he would fire him. Did that mean demote, reassign or as used currently remove him from the military?

1 Answers 2020-05-30

I know about famous Allied entertainers during World War II, like the Andrews Sisters and Vera Lynn. Did the Axis have similar performers?

I ask because I had a story idea involving a Japanese singer who's also an anti-imperial spy.

1 Answers 2020-05-30

What were the opinions of the Wright Brothers regarding planes being used for warfare? Did they oppose the idea or did they insist on planes being used for this purpose?

1 Answers 2020-05-30

I’m a peasant in a small village in 14th century England. What does my relationship with the village priest look like? Do we see each other outside of church? Is he considered a leader in my community?

1 Answers 2020-05-30

What would my entertainment options me as a lower class, medieval city dweller?

I recently had the opportunity to get a bit more of an overview of the history of my home town (Edinburgh, if anyone has any specifically applicatible answers), and it's really got me curious about what the daily lives of it's inhabitants would have been throughout history. So, if I didn't have enough money for private musicians and such, what would have been my medieval entertainment options, were there affordable theatres, public storytelling, general partying, or would I have had to make my own fun at home?

1 Answers 2020-05-30

Where did European nobility come from? Were they really just descended from bandits and robbers?

I've heard that what became the nobility was initially just armed groups extorting farmers and towns, and eventually that extortion morphed into taxation and the feudal system. Is there any truth to this?

2 Answers 2020-05-29

Why were the mentally ill women who were confined to the Salpêtrière Hospital murdered during the September Massacres?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

Did the great Wall of China affect the 2nd Sinno-Japanese war in any way?

Did the wall temporary halt Japanese advance or did they easily go through it using dynamite and/other explosives?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

How much ammunition (powder, musket balls) would a Napoleonic soldier carry into battle?

Would there be anyone re supplying troops mid battle?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

Were civilian spectators during the American Civil War ever in serious danger?

I’ve often heard about civilians gathering to watch Civil War battles (like Bull Run) in a picnic setting. Were these people ever in any real danger of being under fire, or in serious harms way?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

How to display historical data

I run a discography website.

Lets say a pianist recorded a piece in Leningrad at Philharmonic Hall in 1935.

I have a link that lets you click on venue name and view all the recordings that occurred at venue.

The link I have is called Philharmonic Hall, Leningrad, Russia .

Should this be labelled Philharmonic Hall, Saint Petersburg, Russia?

Or should I have these be seperate?

When the user clicks on the link, it then lists from

How should I list it?

If the piece was recorded in 1935, should the list say Leningrad, and if the recording is made after 1991, say Saint Peterburg? Should it simply always say Saint Petersburg now, even though it was not that at the time?

Hopefully this makes some sense.

Would love the feedback. Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-05-29

Can anyone recommend resources for translating Early Modern theological Latin?

I'm working on some of the questions Oxford theologians were asking their Master's and Doctoral students for their Inception and I'm having trouble with the vocabulary. The words are recognizable, but most of my training was in Classical Latin and I know I'm missing the significance of some of the words.

For example - "An legis impletio sit possibilis?" I know this has something to do with "fulfillment" in the theological sense, but "legis" is throwing me for a loop. Whitaker's Words has been helpful, but I can't quite piece it together.

Are there any guides or side-by-side translations that could help guide me?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

Ottoman titles and what they saw themselves as.

So there have been talks about the Ottomans and the whole Rome claim thing. While it seems the Ottomans did not see themselves as Romans, and instead just ruling over Romans, I was wondering what they saw themselves as actually.

From the wikipedia page of Ottoman titles and appellations, Sultan precedes all other titles, but I’m not sure if this means anything.

Han is Turkic, as the Ottomans were a Turkic people. However they saw Turks as like peasant or tribal folk and sometimes disdained them.

Padishah is Persian, and since the Ottomans were influenced by Persian culture and language, I’m inclined to think the Ottomans saw themselves as Persianate.

But what was the Ottoman identity to the Ottomans? Did they truly see themselves as a successor to any of the ancient empires or their turkic ancestors? Or did they have a different concept of their identity altogether?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

How did people back then just abandoned Norse and Greek beliefs? Did they just one day decide their Gods weren't real anymore?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

Did the Boney M single "Rasputin" affect the popular perception of the Mad Monk?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

Are there accounts of southern children being taken after the Civil War to northern states to be used as servants?

Hello. I remember reading 10+ years ago accounts of children from southern states being taken north (Indiana being one of the states) after the civil war being placed in homes and used as workers until they were adults. I am trying to track down the accounts I had read but cannot seem to find any information on it now.

2 Answers 2020-05-29

Friday Free-for-All | May 29, 2020

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

15 Answers 2020-05-29

Were only ukranians targeted by the holodomor or were other nationalities like the russians georgians estonians affected?

I was taught in high school that ukraine was the breadbasket of the ussr and during the famine all of ussr starved except for the far east and moscow/leningrad. I was also taught that the holodomor was caused by the communist attempt at nationalising the farming industry and taking away land and tool from the peasants had and declaring the peasantry as enemy of the state no matter the nationality. Also was there any reason for stalin to purge ukraine from the ukranians to leave it for the russians since he himself was part of a minority in the ussr?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

Hwæt! We have new Moderators!

Hearken to me readers and contributors of AskHistorians for I bring you tidings! Today we, the AskHistorians moderators, your benevolent dictators friends, accept new members into our exalted ranks of comment removers and behind the scenes drudgers! In the high hallowed halls of our secret cabal, filled with smoke, mirrors, and ban-hammers we the AskHistorians mods have passed a new doom upon the land, and decreed that more lackeys valued contributors should rise to a new station and be given the keys to the kingdom.


Our decree thus follows:

In the interest of further preserving the strict no fun allowed policy high standards of our subreddit, we have deemed several new mods to be established herein who shall reign over the lands of our demesne, given in our grace, to our valued vassals.

May we all join together in fealty and gratitude to welcome:

/u/historiagrephour our Scottish historian extraordinaire, who shall sound off in the threads with raucous pipes and critical examination of early modern gender roles!

/u/DGBD who brings their musical talent to add to our own concerto and be heard across the subreddit!

/u/hellcatfighter adds their own knowledge of China and Japan to weave into our expertise!

and /u/Steelcan909! (What do you mean I'm announcing myself and speaking in the third person? I don't think our new mod would appreciate that kind of talk!)

Should any infringe upon this, our generous gift, may they be bound by the inextricable bonds of being hit with the banhammer and cast out, or the more greater, make amends through excessive begging and supplication!

108 Answers 2020-05-29

Nowadays it is almost universal across cultures for men to have short hair and women to have long hair How did this trend evolve? Was this always the case?

Nowadays everywhere around the world men mostly have short hair and women mostly have long hair. But was this always the case? I know that European royalty wore elaborate wigs but what about normal people with natural hair? Native American men had long hair too. So, I guess these are exceptions.

1 Answers 2020-05-29

When did glass bottles become disposable?

We've all seen this scenario in a movie or TV show: someone (a medieval rogue, a drunken cowboy, etc.) finishes off a bottle of alcohol and then nonchalantly throws it over their shoulder or otherwise smashes it on the ground. I've always viewed this as a waste of a valuable resource, especially in times of old. So my question is this: when did glass bottles become so cheap and easy to produce that they became a disposable commodity instead of a reusable one?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

When did people realize that Hitler was evil?

Assuming that the world came to this conclusion at different times. When did the U.S. conclude this? What about Germany?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

Why were there Greeks who took such an interest in mathematics but almost no mathematics innovations by Romans?

My limited understanding is that for hundreds of years Greece had innovators in math from the likes of Pythagoras to Euclid to Archimedes, but then Rome kind of 'took over' during the Byzantine Empire and it seems the drive for mathematical innovation heavily slowed for significant period of time. Was it actually stifled by Roman policies or did Roman academics just lose interest/not have any in this particular field?

1 Answers 2020-05-29

The Kievan Rus' and the now present Russia; Scandinavian descent or not?

I was reading up on the Kievan Rus', curious as to why modern Russia is so far depraved from Scandinavian culture and language today if they were originally formed by the Kievan Rus', vikings whom formed the first Russian estate.

Apparently, historians argue their origin, according to this section of Wikipedia.

One of the earliest written descriptions of the Rus as followed by'' Ahmad ibn Fadlan, an Arab traveler during the 10th century, provided one of the earliest written descriptions of the Rus': "They are as tall as a date palm, blond and ruddy, so that they do not need to wear a tunic nor a cloak; rather the men among them wear garments that only cover half of his body and leaves one of his hands free. ''

Which does sound fairly Scandinavian.

My question is-; if they were originally from Scandinavia, most likely Sweden- how come in today's Russia and Russian language, there seem to be very few traces left? Were the original Slavs there simply too many and the Scandinavians culture changed to theirs-or what happen'd? I'd love to read other sources on the subject of their origin and why its drastically different compared to the current day Scandinavian countries.

1 Answers 2020-05-29

1304 / 7255

Back to start