How did blacksmiths keep up with the constant demand for armor and weapons during medieval times?

I have been watching a few forged in fire episodes(for those of you that don't know, it's this show kind of like a masterchef for blacksmiths, where a group of blacksmiths all have to compete and make certain types of blades every episode) and there is something that I don't understand. These professional blacksmiths usually take 3 hours to work on the blade of a dagger alone, usually taking a few more hours to make a handle, and they can take days to craft a bigger sword. And even after all that crafting time, most blades bend or break after a bit of use. So my question is, how did medieval blacksmiths make enough durable and effective weapons and armor to fuel all the wars that happened in Europe at the time?

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Why are various unrelated semitic dynasties often given names ending in "-ids"? E.g. from the Carthaginian Didonids and Barcids all the way to the Nasrids of Granada, 2500 years later.

Edit, that should be 2000 years later, not 2500

Just curious about whether there is something about semitic languages that makes this a natural way to form these dynastic names or whether there is a historiographical or cultura reason for this consistency.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Did the Taiping Rebellion have any impact C. Perry opening up of Japan or the Boshin War. And did those two events effect the Taiping rebellion in anyway?

1 Answers 2020-05-28

How dangerous was big game hunting in the 1800's?

I've been reading a few of H. Rider Haggard's stories about big game hunting in Africa, and he portrays the profession as extremely dangerous, his characters frequently face danger and appear closely matched with the elephants and lions and other animals that they face. Although these are works of fiction, Allan Quartermain is based largely on a real big game hunter, Frederick Selous. Exactly how realistic are these depictions of big game hunters in this time period? What were these kinds of people actually like?

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Did (some) European women from the Middle Ages have property rights?

This article claims that Anglo-Saxon laws allowed women to own property during the 800s (Norse women are also mentioned); however, they provide no sources and I had no success with Google, but I've found some other, later examples of female property rights in Europe, such as in Kiev and Turin.

I realize that some countries transitioned to a coverture system, but, before that, did places like England allow women to own property?

(Respectable sources for further reading will be greatly appreciated)

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Can anyone tell me more about a historical event my Great Grandpa was involved in? He was a POW in Siberia during WWII and escaped on a train near Iran.

So here's the gist of the story as I've heard it from my family. It's been a while, so I don't remember a ton of the specifics. This would have happened in 1943 or 1944:

My great Grandpa was in the US Air Force in the Pacific Theater (I think Alaska) when his plane went down in Siberia. Key to this was that the Soviets weren't involved in the Pacific War. My grandpa was found, captured, and taken to a camp in Siberia where he was kept for a short while until he was put on a train to be taken to another camp. He and the other Americans on the train apparently formed a plan to escape, and ditched the train when it was stopped near the border of Iran and found their way back to the US.

The event was apparently classified until a few books were written on it (one of which had my grandpa's name in it), and in the 70s or 80s Congress passed legislation that officially recognized him and the others as Prisoners of War (I'm not sure if it was just this event or others, and him specifically or a group in general).

My question is, does anybody know more specifics on the event or similar ones? I'm looking for the legislation that enabled his POW status, the book, where these camps were and where/when this escape might have happened. Thank you so much in advance!

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Why did the Ottoman Empire never conquer Circassia?

While most of the Caucasus and the territories south of Circassia and the territories northwest of Circassia were in Ottoman rule, they left out the Circassians. Why was that? Did they have some kind of deal or respected them so much that they left them alone? (which I hardly can imagine because even though the Circassians were fierce warriors , they couldn't have taken on Ottoman technology and manpower I would think). So what was the reason?

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Looking for an opinion piece regarding Bill Barr's first confirmation as Attorney General in or about 1989?

This is a bit of an odd request, but I'm researching Bill Barr and remember reading a newspaper clipping someone had photographed and uploaded, but I've been having trouble locating it. Obviously, a Google search of "Bill Barr" "confirmation hearing" "opinion" is like looking for a needle in a haystack.

I remember it was relatively short. It was an opinion column from a former classmate of Bill Barr's and discussed his time in school. It was referencing his first confirmation hearings as Attorney General in Bush I's administration, and discussed briefly Joe Biden's role in the confirmation process.

I'd be really grateful for any American political historians' help in finding this source which I think dates to 1989.

1 Answers 2020-05-28

I keep hearing Ethiopia has a fascinating, underrated history, but get little details on it. Any ELI5 summaries of events or advice on where to start?

I'm not a huge history buff, but games like Civ 5 and AOE 2 sometimes get you curious about history. Ethiopia is one that consistently gets included but probably isn't seen as a "major power" or anything when compared to most of those others.

I've also noticed that on lists of countries that were never or rarely conquered, Ethiopia ranks near the top. Only Japan seems to get credit as never being conquered, and they cheating cause they live on an island. Ethiopia, from what I could tell (again, different accounts and vague details), was occupied once in WWII, but never properly conquered or the resistance efforts fully defused/the emperor fully dethroned so much as forced into hiding. Even here, I'm unclear on if Ethiopia was conquered or not, only that Italy was mad cause Ethiopia kicked their butts ages ago. Either way, being the only African country to hold off European countries during the age of imperialism is certainly impressive and worth asking what made Ethiopia so special/how and why did they succeed.

I'd love to hear just some examples of interesting points in Ethiopian history, old or recent. Was Ethiopia properly conquered by Italy in WWII or not? What made Ethiopia a more influencial African country throughout history? Was there any particular reason they've been able to avoid being conquered whilst every other landlocked nation ever has at least been conquered once or twice?

Thanks in advance for any and all information. As I've said, I've tried finding stuff before, but I find the info rather difficult to come by if you don't even really know where to start. (or even then, WWII as an example, I've read articles claiming they were conquered and ones saying they weren't)

2 Answers 2020-05-28

How many servants/attendants would a typical Samurai have?

Specifically, a samurai of the Sengoku Jidai earning between 100 and 200 koku.

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Say I’m a soldier in 1860s United States at the height of the war, worried about dying and not being identified. Did they have an early form of dog tags at this time, or was information taken during enlistment only?

Edit: As well as in terms of enlistment, how would the process go about?

1 Answers 2020-05-28

What is the earliest period that is academically viable for a historian? How far back in time can we look?

3 Answers 2020-05-28

How were the construction of Royal Navy ships funded?

I was reading about HMS Duke of Wellington and the phrase:

she thus saw no active service after the Crimean War and paid off in 1856.

Is in there. She was completed almost 3 years prior to that date, so who paid to whom? I see it commonly when reading about other ships as well.

1 Answers 2020-05-28

What do historians think about the narrative laid out in Greenblatt's "The Swerve?"

"The Swerve" sounds exciting. It got a lot of acclaim: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Swerve. It won the Pulitzer Prize and the National Book Award.

Interestingly, I can only find one thread about it, and the thread was upvoted once but never commented on: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2c098h/greenblatts_the_swerve/.

I read this thread about "grand narratives" and it gave me a healthy skepticism about whether popular books are always able to capture all of the complexity: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1k6cf5/are_there_any_grand_theories_of_history_that/.

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Why wasn't Arabic imposed in India, as it was in other regions during the Muslim conquests?

2 Answers 2020-05-28

I would like to learn more about the strategic happenings of World War 1, the courses, backgrounds and aftermaths of battles and their effects. What can you recommend?

First of all, I am sorry if this is the wrong sub to ask this, please tell me if this should be the case.

I am looking for any books, podcasts, series etc. that can help me to understand more about the course of battles in World War 1. You always hear or even read about the biggest battles, mostly the Western Front, Flanders, Verdun, and many others, but I fail to get the bigger picture. It would be very interesting to understand what lead to some fronts, or what effect some offensives had.I was just hoping, that maybe someone can give me an idea or a direction where to look, and I am aware that this may be a weird question.

Thank you anyways for your time, and I am looking forward to any answer you may give!

1 Answers 2020-05-28

The idea that scholars in the Middle Ages believed in a Flat Earth is apparently a myth, but what about non-scholars? How much do we know about what non-scholars and the general public thought about whether the Earth was flat/spherical/etc.?

This is interesting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_flat_Earth. But what about non-scholars; what did they think?

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Would a medieval Duchy or County be ruled from a "capital" city/town, or from a Duke / Count's castle ?

I have two somewhat conflicting mental models of how a medieval kingdom is split up:

  • One in which the feudal lords mostly own / control the countryside, and the cities exist outside the feudal system and do their own thing with a town council or whatnot, and the lords pretend that they don't exist until they get powerful enough in more recent centuries
  • One in witch the territory is split into juridictions (duchies / provinces / counties etc.) each with their own capital, as is basically the case in modern times

More specifically, if one looks at this map of 1145 France, France is divided into counties and duchies, who have major cities, but it's not clear to me whether those cities were "capitals" (or if it was mostly ruled from a castle in the countryside), and whether there were other important cities who weren't administrative capitals.

Or is this something that depended of the time and region ? (I expect at least that as we got nearer to modern times, with cities being more important and power being more administrative, power became centered in cities)

1 Answers 2020-05-28

How did the HIV/AIDS epidemic of the 1980s and 1990s affect the Deaf community in the U.S.?

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | May 28, 2020

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

5 Answers 2020-05-28

Were dinosaur fossils ever discovered in antiquity, and if so what was the effect?

I was reading a book to my son which said dinosaurs were discovered in the 1800s. I can't imagine none were ever found before that. I always wondered if the legend of dragons was related.

2 Answers 2020-05-28

How did Edward V come to be recognized as a monarch of England while both Arthur and Matilda came to be regarded simply as "claimants?"

Edward V was age 12 upon the death of his father, Edward IV. He "reigned" for two and a half months before he was formally deposed (and likely murdered) by his uncle, Richard III. He was never crowned, was a minor, and controlled effectively zero territory, as his uncle Richard had taken control of the country even before Edward's deposal was confirmed by parliament. Despite this, Edward is included in historical lists of English monarchs and his regnal number is recognized by later monarchs.

Arthur, duke of Brittany and earl of Richmond, was age 12 upon the death of his uncle Richard I. Sources differ as to whether Richard preferred his nephew Arthur or brother John as his heir, and Arthur was never crowned, but Arthur had the stronger claim on the tradition of primogeniture. Arthur claimed the throne and -- unlike Edward -- controlled some territory, though not in England, but at least in the broader Angevin empire, and lived to maintain his claim far longer than Edward (around four years) before he was captured (and likely murdered) by his uncle, King John.

Empress Matilda was age 33 upon the death of her father, Henry I. She was his designated heir, had the support of much of the English nobility and, though she was never crowned, she controlled southwestern England and all of Normandy for decades.

How did Edward V come to be recognized as a monarch of England despite never being crowned while both Arthur and Matilda -- neither of whom were crowned, but both of whom controlled significant territory, made strong claims to the throne, and pressed those claims far longer and more seriously than Edward V did -- came to be regarded simply as "claimants?"

1 Answers 2020-05-28

Researching Salem Witch Trials

Hello everyone,

I’m writing a book that takes place around the time of the salem witch trials and was hoping for a recommendation on a book that will help give me a sense of how people lived during that time period in new england.

Looking for an enjoyable read with maybe real stories of the time and not too textbook-y. I’m trying to get a feel for what life was like back then, what their daily routines were, how many people were able to read and at what age, etc

Thanks for your help

1 Answers 2020-05-28

How did Asia (specifically the east i.ie China, Korea, Japan) react to the introduction of coffee into their respective commerce and societies, particularly for countries who have such rich culture and tradition surrounding tea.

Sources would be lovely, if possible at all. Thank you in advance, sorry for the very broad topic.

5 Answers 2020-05-28

During ww2 did the german infantry just stand there to fill the frontline and wait for the armor division to breakthrough and fill the gap or did they take part in the breakthrough independently( without armor support) too? If they did how and when did they decide to go on the offensive?

1 Answers 2020-05-28

1306 / 7255

Back to start