The Hungarian people likely originated out of Siberia and speak a Uralic language. Has this impacted Hungarian national identity through the years, including into modern times?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Why does Byzantine art and architecture look so different from classical antiquity stuff?

During Constantine's time art and architecture were still recognisably Roman as we know it, with realistic sculptures and classical style buildings. Yet barely 2 centuries later, Justinian's famous portrait in gold mosaics looks like a bloody anime figure with unrealistically big eyes. Gone are the grandiose buildings decked out in marble, replaced by buildings like the Hagia Sofia and the San Vitale Church that don't look all that Roman even before the minarets. Renaissance art meanwhile obviously has its roots in classical antiquity. While I can appreciate it on its own, how did Byzantine art culture stray so far from its Roman roots?

Also I have zero academic background in either history or art so please feel free to correct me.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Was the famine in 1943 Bengal a "man-made" famine in the same way that the 1933 Holodomer was?

It appears as though the vast majority of historians agree that 3 - 4 million people died as a direct result of colonial policy. If this is so, why has the event been almost entirely forgotten in the west? Whereas the holodomer is justly seen as one of the worst genocides in human history, compared to the holocaust, and even considered worse than the holocaust by some, the famine in 1943 Bengal isn't even considered important enough to get a full paragraph in most history books on The Pacific War.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Saturday Showcase | May 02, 2020

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Did US-backed coups in Latin America from 1945-1990 tend to have a positive or negative effect on the country's poverty, corruption, illiteracy, inequality, human rights etc? What about their economy?

Having read a bit about the US involvement in regime change over the years, primarily deposing left wing political leaders, I've seen it mentioned how a lot of the time the countries seemed to be worse off after US involvement. (Please feel free to correct me if I am wrong here or provide example to the contrary, I am keen to learn more)

I realise in some cases there wasn't enough time for significant economic change to happen but I was wondering how these coups affected GDP, currency value and imports and exports and whether there were any times where a positive economic change could justify the other negative effects, or whether it just served to maintain the status quo with the money going back to US corporations and banks.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Why did king Harold Godwinson die

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Farming and villages in 6th-8th Anglo-Saxon Britain

I can't find much pre-Norman information about what a hide actually was besides a reference to "space for a family" and it being roughly 120 acres. This seems like a lot of land for a mother, father and even several children to subsist on so I was wondering if a hide housed an extended family of a patriach and several grown sons with their families?

How would so-called cottage industries have worked during this era? Would several hides have had each one of them doing their own blacksmithery, tanning, milling and spinning or would there have been experts that serviced all of them? Would houses have been in the middle of their fields or would they have been on the edge alongside a few other hides forming a natural village?

What would have been farmed, I assume it would have been a subsistence polyculture with a few livestock, some form of legume, a vegetable garden and either one grain (wheat) or several taking up the lion's share of the fields?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

We’re ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics more like a type font or handwriting?

I have been watching a free online course from Harvard about the Giza plateau excavation and thought about something I had never considered. While I’m guessing hieroglyphic style changed over time, would hieroglyphics from the same period but different areas or person writing it have been exactly the same,more like fonts or would it be more like handwriting, where the basic shapes are similar but the style varies wildly based on the person making them? And in a related question-when we see hieroglyphics on things like tomb and temple walls, would it have been made by literate scribe/artisans with distinct styles or copied by workmen who wouldn’t have been able to understand what was being written? Edit: My phone hates me. I swear I know the difference between “Were” and “We’re” but I can’t edit the title that I can figure out.

2 Answers 2020-05-02

A weird old rusted axe

I have been told to check with r/askhistorians about my post in r/whatisthisthing

https://www.reddit.com/r/whatisthisthing/comments/gc4tfn/found_this_in_the_adriatic_sea_looks_like_some/

I couldn't post a picture, so here is the link. I hope it is not against the rules :))

1 Answers 2020-05-02

The usual answer to why LATAM is more mixed-race than NA is that there was a higher population density there, but what about the regions that weren't that dense??

Like, the answers always seem to have Mesoamerica and the Andes in mind, but forget they were the only regions in Latin America that had advanced urban civilizations. Places like the Venezuelan lowlands, Chile, Argentina, and most importantly the entirety of Brazil (half of South America) didn't have urban civilizations, and the colonizers intermix there just like they did in Mexico and Peru (ps: I'm not romanticizing these relations). So.. is there a reason why the English were more "secluded" compared to the Iberians?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Were people less affected by death hundreds of years ago because it was the norm?

I know it's hard to give a tangible answer to this, but when you see in history Mother's losing many children due to illness and not living past childhood, as well as the low mortality rate in general, were people less affected by death at all?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Why didn’t Henry VIII have more foreign princesses as brides? Was marrying subjects common in European royalty at the time?

Out of Henry VIII’s six wives, four were subjects in England. I had always heard there was a great advantage to marrying royalty from other countries. Were there political reasons for seeking brides from England?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Do we know why the Egyptians built the pyramids in the shapes that they did, there must have been easier shapes to build, was it a religious reason or something else?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Utsa Patnaik claims that the British siphoned $45 trillion from India.

To me the figure seems mind boggling to say the least. Is this so?

And if $45 trillion was taken then where did it all go?

2 Answers 2020-05-02

What happened to Rome’s citizens after after the Sack of Rome?

Roman history tends to fascinate me. There is just this amazing idea behind it because it is something physical in our world. It is there, and it used to flourish. It lasted for so long that no one is sure how it was founded and instead we have the legend of Romulus and Remus. Anyways, let me get to the point of my question. I do not know the exact number of the population of Rome after they were invaded by the Visigoths, but I know for certain they had at least a million citizens. After Rome was Sacked what happened to them? What did the poor commoners do? Did they just go to some other city-state on the Italian Peninsula? How about the wealthy Romans that have their roots among the first families of Rome? I get that they were invaded, but does that mean suddenly all economic activity of Rome halted? The businesses were still there... did any of them continue to function? To sum up my question in a single sentence, I’m asking what did Roman citizens who were alive during its fall, and had lived in Rome all of their lives before hand, do after it fell?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

How did South Korea develop?

I heard some things about Korean history, and I heard that many years ago South Korea had a dictator like North Korea, and was very poor. Today it is a very progressive country with a strong economy and a better government. How did it climb up?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Were Alexander Pushkin and Alexandre Dumas the same man?

I’ve seen this theory in a few places recently, and it seems like a real stretch based on what I can find. Is there anything more to the idea that Alexander Pushkin is/was Alexandre Dumas than similarities in their portraits and a coincidence in timing? Do any credible folks find this one convincing?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Is the estimate of a 2-4 megaton explosion in the show ‘Chernobyl’ accurate in terms of what was believed at the time?

I recently watched the HBO mini-series ‘Chernobyl’. Particularly in episode 2, the (fictional) character Khomyuk says that if the corium melted through the concrete and reached the water in the bubbler pool beneath, the resultant explosion would be somewhere between 2-4 megatons. This is way off the mark of any possible outcome, the upper bound being probably 0.00015 megatons as it is calculated here.

My questions are the following. Did the show include this number (2-4 megatons) because that is what was believed at the time or is the show just plain wrong? Could they be talking about the following fallout rather than the explosion itself? (In other words, maybe they were comparing the fallout that a 2-4 megaton nuclear bomb would produce).

Thank you in advance.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

There is a theory Beria may have assassinated Stalin. How seriously do historians take this claim, and why?

I have seen things ranging from Beria outright admitting it to other party members, to early drafts of the autopsy and medical records indicating poisoning. Is assassination considered plausible by historians or is this a debunked conspiracy theory?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

How "wild" was the so-called "Wild West" in the 1870s, 80s, and 90s?

I've been playing a lot of games lately and watching shows that feature the "Wild West" that took over the Western United States after the Civil War. I know from history classes that it was partly romanticized, but to what extent? Did this "Wild West" actually have some basis in truth (eg, cowboys and bank-robbing gangs, etc) or was it almost all just a romanticization after the fact? If it was mostly just romanticized, where did this popular idea of the "Wild West" come from?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Did Japan Ever Have Any Interior Revolts Against The Emperor?

When I look throughout Japanese history, nearly everyone serves or is under the emperor. Even under Daimyos or Shoguns, they all seem to fight each other but not against the emperor himself.

The Japanese have had an emperor for nearly or literally all of their entire history.

Has, let's say, Japanese Christians revolted? Shintoism seems to have the emperor as a divine figure, but Christianity thinks otherwise.

The emperor bloodline has existed for centuries, did anyone in Japan think "Hey why is this dude ruling!?" Or "This guy isn't that great!" and started a revolution?

I know Shoguns were thrown around, but what about Emperors?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Where does the modern viking aesthetic come from?

I just recently saw the trailer for the new Assassin's Creed game, which features vikings in leather armor, braids, guyliner, and face paint, a very similar visual style to the one we see in television shows such as History Channel's Vikings. While my knowledge on the subject of what the Norsemen wore and looked like is very limited, as far as I understand, they didn't look like that at all. Just like the operas of the 19th century romanticized vikings with horned helmets (which were inspired by bronze age ceremonial headgear), it seems to be a modern invention. Where then, does this unique look come from?

2 Answers 2020-05-02

Popular culture seems to primarily feature the Olypian Greek gods, Zeus Poseidon etc. Was that true in ancient Greek culture as well? If so, why didn't the titans or primordial gods receive as much recognition?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

What was the preferred Bible translation of Huguenots in early 17th century exile?

What did the translators think of the Apocrypha? How were the translations influenced by Sephardim in France (as opposed to the Ashkenazim in Germany)? This is just speculation, I don't know -- the question here is really whether the original text in France was the same as was used by Martin Luther or the translators of the KJV, and their use of the Masoretic text (or not) versus the Septuagint or Vulgate. Where would they have learned to read Aramaic?

How did the Huguenot translation(s) compete with that of other French Protestants?

I ask specifically about Huguenots in exile because I'm curious how the text was carried away from France and how it influenced the French spoken by colonists born overseas. Also, "early 17th century exile" more specifically means "before 1643".

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Honest question: Why have the British been so bad at holding on to colonies?

Just off the top of my head (maybe not all technically colonies, but some type of rule): USA, Canada, India, parts of Africa, parts of South America, Australia, Burma, Hong Kong, etc... pretty sure there's a few more.

So, I could understand losing a colony here and there, but seriously.... after you lose like 6 in a row, don't you take a hard look in the mirror and ask why none of these places want to stay with you?

Please break it down for a layman if you would.

2 Answers 2020-05-02

1363 / 7255

Back to start