[WWII] Could the Allied Powers have feasibly negotiated a Japanese surrender?

http://www.liberalviewer.com/Hiroshima.htm

The above article claims to refute the common narrative that the use of nuclear weapons in Hiroshima and Nagasaki were justified in order to prevent the far greater loss of life from the prospective Operation Downfall. It claims that the Allied powers could have negotiated a Japanese surrender provided that they did not mandate the transition away from an imperial system in the Potsdam Proclamation and that, as such, a peaceful conclusion to the Pacific theatre of WWII was a historical possibility. How accurate is this analysis?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

In Canada, what caused Francophones to be treated differently from Anglophones?

I just finished the Netflix series Anne with an E which takes place in Eastern Canada. One of the characters, Jerry is a Francophone farm hand who has had some racist(?) encounters with an Anglophone who called him Froggy and beat him. I also felt it was quite strange that the only Francophone character was an uneducated farmhand.

I did some digging around the show's sub to see what would cause the treatment towards Jerry and came across this interesting comment:

Being French, he's probably from a Catholic family, so higher education probably wasn't encouraged. This also probably meant that his family was very large, seeing as a-dozen-kids-or-more familes were common for Catholics at the time. Chances are he's working to support his family, and is working for an Anglophone family because the job opportunities are better than in his own community. His family is probably poor, because, well, 12 kids is a lot of mouths to feed, but also because given the historical context of Canada at the time,it was much harder for Francophones to climb the social ranks, especially with the arrival of industrialization and the creation of the middle class

From my understanding, I never though that French Canadians faced discrimination in Canada given that the second language is Canadian after all. What would've made it difficult for a Francophone to climb social ranks? What was the cause for this discrimination and how long did it last for?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

How did the average catholic church-goer view cherubs in religious paintings? Especially since unbaptized babies don’t go to heaven.

I’ve seen cherubs (flying or floating, usually naked, babies / toddlers) in a variety of religious paintings. Even in paintings where only the head is represented, they tend to be playful sprites or sleepy / cuddly companions. A lot of these paintings were commissioned to be displayed in churches, especially to an illiterate populace. But child mortality used to be quite high, especially for children under 5yo, and Catholicism is pretty specific about what happens to unbaptized babies. So how would an average illiterate person (who had likely buried one or more young children) understand these symbols?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

How did the United States become a dominant military power in WW2, given the economic damage from the recent Great Depression?

I am curious about the economics of how America developed supreme military capabilities in the years leading up to WW2. In my understanding, the ramifications of the Great Depression were severely felt throughout the 1930's. Furthermore, politics at the time was influenced by isolationism, which would have made it difficult to siphon significant funds toward militarisation.

And yet, the US seem to have had the largest financial reserve dedicated to military spending, judging by the Lend-Lease Act, as will as foreign aid for the re-development of Europe after the war.

Was there a large armaments project taking place in the 30's parallel to other efforts at economic re-building? If so, did this register in public opinion? And how did it come about in the first place?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

What's the actually origin of Ahir people?

Ahir is usually considered a caste in India. Some say Yadava (Ahirs, according to some) is actually a race rather than a caste. there are different theories. I'd really appreciate a well explained answer. Thankyou.

Actual *

1 Answers 2020-05-03

My tribe was invaded by Roman legions, I’m one of the lucky few men who survived, as a POW. What happens to me? What about my my brothers, sisters, and fellow? What are my chances of assimilating into Roman society?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

What effect did the Red Scare have on the US' decision to use nuclear bombs against japan in 1945?

I was wondering what about the Red scare, and thought it would be interesting to know how it effected the US's desicion to use nuclear bombs against Japan.

I have been having a hard time finding any reliable reading material about this. I would therefore love it, if i could get a link to do some reading together with any info you give me.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-05-02

To what extent was Nazism in Germany an evolution of 19th century eugenics/scientific rascism?

I have heard it said before that Nazism grew out of scientific theories on race of the 19th century, exactly how true is this?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

What were US-Ottoman relations like from the adoption of the US Constitution in 1787 to the end of the Ottoman Empire in the early 1920s?

I know that the United States and the Ottoman Empire were on opposite sides during World War I but that is the extent of my knowledge of US-Ottoman relations.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Which ships were used in western europe in the 11th century?

After doing some research about medieval ships, I saw that, in the Viking Age, the scandinavians had naval superiority over their enemies. The Knarr and the Drakkar allowed them to go further into the Atlantic sea, even reaching the Americas. Even after the Viking Age, their ships were among the best in Europe. However, other countries must have had their own ships in this period (11th century). The franks, the saxons, the germans, italians, asturians surely had ships, but while I was doing research about them I couldn't find any good information. Do we know other ships designs used in the 11th century in western Europe? Are they adaptations of the Scandinavians?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

My grandmother was born in Kilsyth, WV in 1920, my great-grandfather was a coal miner before they moved back to Sicily with my infant Nonna. He died of black lung. Can you tell me what his life was life was like in America?

I’m especially curious as to how Sicilians were treated back then, especially in WV, as I also see photos of black and white miners working alongside each other.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Did Jews control the Caribbean slave trade slave trade between 1492 and 1866? Were there any Jewish slave trading companies or captains during that time?

My brother got into an argument with some anti-Semites at work and asked me for help, sadly this is way out of my area of expertise.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

In WW2, did the US have a panic option in case news came through that the germans have successfully invaded the UK?

I can only presume that they would have focused on an invasion from North-Africa instead.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Did any Anglo Saxon kings take the fight against vikings to Scandinavia? Why not/How'd it go?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

how effective were spears

(both in group fighting and one on one)

sorry if this has already been asked

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Are there any surviving records from the German surface fleet in World War 2? Particularly things like ships logs and manifests

Hope this is the right sub, I can remove if not

Short version:

I'm looking for some detailed firsthand records from the German cruiser Prinz Eugen and I was wondering if there are any good resources for that kind of stuff online

Longer version:

I'm trying to translate my late grandfathers journal from his time serving on the Prinz Eugen near the end of the war. I am looking for some other resources to try and give more context to the dates and locations he mentions in it. I want to be able to pin down the dates and places of some of his old stories. This is proving to be especially difficult since he didn't always remember or wasn't always willing to share details when he talked about the war. I know most Naval ships kept precise logbooks of their maneuvers and encounters (which would be ideal), but I don't know if these survived the war or were translated or are available online. The Prinz Eugen also famously sailed alongside the Bismark and Lützow and other ships, so accounts from those could also be helpful and are generally interesting to me. Just hoping this sub might know a few tools to help me out.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Why would baccarat be James Bond's preferred casino game? My understanding is that it has a low house edge but also no skill component.

I know that baccarat was popular among the British upper class at the time Fleming wrote the novels, but why and what does Bond playing the game tell the audience?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

What are the differences between all the different forms of government historically referred to as Communism?

I remember learning Russia had Leninism then Stalinism, but China used Maoism. But in school we never learned what actually made these systems different from each other. And what is Trotskyism?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Did RAF turret gunners train separately to the pilots in WW2?

During WW2 and in particular The Battle of Britain, did gunners for aircraft such as the Boulton Paul Defiant train with the pilots?

Were they also given wings and able to fly themselves or were they trained separately and paired with a pilot?

2 Answers 2020-05-02

How were the French Parliamentary elections handled with respect to the German occupied French territory in World War 1?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

In the James Bond novel "Goldfinger", Ian Fleming describes Korean people in extremely racist terms, with Bond viewing them as lower than apes. Was there widespread anti-Korean sentiment in the UK following the Korean War or does this stem from personal prejudice on Fleming's part?

This Time magazine article goes into more detail:-

Goldfinger took the cat from under his arm and tossed it to the Korean who caught it eagerly – “I am tired of seeing this animal around. You may have it for dinner.” The Korean’s eyes gleamed.


“They are the cruelest, most ruthless people in the world…When they want women, street women are brought down from London, well-remunerated for their services and sent back. The women are not much to look at, but they are white and that is all the Koreans ask – to submit the white race to the grossest indignities.”


Bond apparently share's Goldfinger's view:

Bond intended to stay alive on his own terms. Those terms included putting Odd-Job or any other Korean firmly in place, which in Bond’s estimation was lower than apes in the mammalian hierarchy.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

I’m a middle class Roman citizen planning to check out the Colosseum. How do I find the schedule? Do I bring friends or go alone? Should I eat before, or will they have food?

5 Answers 2020-05-02

In 1945, the Grand Alliance of World War II, spearheaded by the United States, unleashed a brutal firebombing campaign on Japan, followed by two atomic bombings

How much worse than a standard firebombing were the nuclear weapons? Is there validity to the idea that the Japanese government didn't even recognise that Hiroshima and Nagasaki had been hit by a nuclear weapon instead of several incendiary bombs? What would have been the projected death count if major cities like Tokyo and Kyoto were nuked instead of the large but comparatively smaller Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

When did firearms start being made of steel?

While steel production (of varying quality) has existed for over two thousand years, mass production only began after the discovery of the Bessemer process in the 1850s. Was this the game-changer that replaced iron barrels with steel ones in Europe's growing armies, or was steel in common use before that?

1 Answers 2020-05-02

Why aren’t there any ancient cities/temples in the African rainforest (not Africa as a whole) comparable to those in the rainforests of Asia or South America?

When looking at the Machu Picchu in Peru or Angkor Wat in Cambodia, I was curious if there are any similar sites in the African Rainforest. If not, why could societies rise up and create them in Asia and South America, but not in Africa?

(Edit) I am aware of other “lost” cities in African continent, but I am not aware of any in the actual rainforests of Africa.

1 Answers 2020-05-02

1362 / 7255

Back to start