Jimmy Carter's so called "malaise" speech is remembered as failure but at the time polling showed it to be popular. Why the contradiction?

Also, who coined it the malaise speech?

1 Answers 2022-08-30

What was the reaction and perception of the Islamic world towards the Holocaust?

1 Answers 2022-08-30

It's the 1950s. I am a closeted gay businessman, and I have just moved to New York City. I don't know anyone in the gay community and of course I don't want to out myself. How do I find other gay men? How do I locate the gay hangout spots?

1 Answers 2022-08-30

how did the caribbean react to the american civil war? what were their reactions? did any west indians, etc immigrate to fight for any side?

title. did they comment on the war, etc? did they even know about it?

1 Answers 2022-08-30

How much discretion did consuls have to go on campaigns for the Roman Republic?

The Senate would choose two consuls to lead the Roman army in a given year. To what extent were these consuls allowed to make decisions about how the army would be used? Would the Senate say something along of the lines of, "We're going to conquer Region X this year, and you, Consul Y, are assigned for the job"? Or was it more like, "Consul Y, you're in charge of the army this year. Go out and make a name for Rome"?

This kind of gets at a bigger question as to whether or not there was what we might call "civilian oversight" of the army. I also wonder about the difference in short-term interests and long-term interests. Maybe multiple consuls might've tried to cultivate a relationship with a foreign nation over many years, only for it to be squandered by one reckless consul. Was this ever something to be considered?

So yeah, did the Senate assign consuls with a certain policy, or did consuls pretty much do whatever they wanted?

1 Answers 2022-08-30

Did Japan in WWII ever consider a raid on the Panama Canal?

It seems like cutting off the American’s ability to transfer ships between the Atlantic and the Pacific would have been a significant blow, and surely the Canal wasn’t as well defended as targets like Pearl Harbor.

It also seems like a much more plausible plan than the far fetched attacks the Japanese did consider. Was there a reason that it wasn’t feasible?

1 Answers 2022-08-30

How did the role of the Roman Emperor change when the culture shifted from believing the Emperor to be a living God to Christianity, where the Emperor could not be God?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

What century did the majority of people switch from having outie bellybuttons to innie bellybuttons?

Was just a random thought I had. Does it have to do with the evolution of surgical practices? Or is trying for one or another a cultural choice?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

Old newspapers from the United States, from the period of the 1870s to the 1890s frequently misreport the truth. What is this misreporting this called? How does one cite such a reference, when one knows that facts are indeed being misrepresented or blatantly lied about?

I am doing significant railroad research from the period 1870-1890, and will frequently come across newspaper articles that are mistaken, misleading, or just plain wrong.
Sometimes it's clear that the intent was to deceive, as in a case of an unfinished railroad where the stock was being offered for sale, but the newspaper article implies that the line was finished.

Sometimes, it just seems like a mistake or an accident, where the writer did not have all the facts, or misread, then misreported the facts.

So, first, what is this called? And how does one professionally deal with it, knowing that some of these articles have been cited as references in other works?

Today we use a term called "Fake News" which I really dislike, and would never use in a presentation on the history of a railroad.

I have seen so much of it over the decades of my research that I now realize that much of it was probably not by accident.

I know that the newspapers of the era I am describing was the primary media outlet available to people to get news and information, so I assume there was some intentional manipulation, but I don't know enough of the underlining issues with ownerships to understand it all.

1 Answers 2022-08-29

After the Bolshevik revolution, to what extent were members of the upper and wealthy educated/upper middle classes able to stay in Russia so as to keep at least some of that part of their culture alive?

Did they manage to find similar roles in government or industries, did they downshift in their occupations or did that part of the old culture just completely die out?

Are there any remnants of the culture of the old upper and educated industrial/government etc classes in the cultural genome of modern Russia, other than purposefully copied aspects of culture, or is this cultural genome mostly or completely dominated by the new upper class culture (mostly government / party members I guess?) that was brought on by the Soviet rule and later its collapse?

And just to clarify I don’t mean biological genome, I believe talent, capability to succeed and maintain a high social status are prevalent through all social classes. So I’d assume eventually a similar upper class would form in the place of the old, but the question is, how much continuity is there between pre and post soviet upper class culture in Russia?

And upper class here means most of the well off classes that were persecuted and killed by the soviets.

1 Answers 2022-08-29

In the first Sherlock Holmes novel, A Study in Scarlet, Dr. Watson says that he got his M.D. from the University of London in 1878. Assuming Watson was like most students at the time, how old would he have been upon graduation, and how many years would he have spent studying?

“In the year 1878 I took my degree of Doctor of Medicine of the University of London, and proceeded to Netley to go through the course prescribed for surgeons in the Army.” — A Study in Scarlet, Ch. 1.

I was curious if it was possible to approximately determine his year of birth with this little piece of information (the most explicit one in any of the stories, unfortunately).

As it happens, I read that med school at the University of London was comparatively tough: for example, that the Universities of Edinburgh and Glasgow were much quicker to award an M.D., while the usual graduate degree in England was a Bachelor of Medicine, the M.D. being awarded more rarely; and that medical school in Scotland only took four years (with the students being sometimes as young as fourteen – http://www.jstor.org/stable/44444674), while “The University of London had demanded since 1837 a bachelor of arts degree or its equivalent before commencing four years of graded medical study in basic science, anatomy and physiology, and then clinical instruction (“the whole of Science to be taught before the Practical division”), followed by two years of practice in a hospital or dispensary.” (Thomas Neville Bonner, Becoming a Physician (1995), p. 207).

Can anyone elaborate on this, or provide further sources? How old would a student have been when attaining a bachelor of arts degree? etc. etc.

Thanks very much in advance.

1 Answers 2022-08-29

Modern-day people suffering paranoid psychosis often have delusions with modern themes, such as being targeted by government intelligence agencies. Do we have examples of how these types of delusions might have manifested in people of the past?

3 Answers 2022-08-29

Were Ireland, Scotland and England raided by the same bands of vikings?

In history we were told that the vikings came from Scandinavia, which consisted of Norway, Sweden and Denmark. We also know they raided countries nearby such as Ireland, Scotland, England and that they also pillaged the coasts of other countries but never settled such as Spain, France, Portugal and Egypt, but were the vikings who raided Ireland and England from the same place or were they members of different bands? For example did Norwegian vikings invade Ireland and England and Swedish vikings took Scotland or did the vikings of these three countries go to different places from eachother?

2 Answers 2022-08-29

What did General MacArthur and the U.S. government consider so valuable that they were willing to pardon the members of Japan's Unit 731 during WW2?

  • Unit 731 Wiki-Warning, contains graphic descriptions of the Unit's crimes. Not for the faint of heart.
  • When I first read the history of Unit 731, what shocked and disturbed me almost as much as the Unit's horrible actions was that General MacArthur and the U.S. government pardoned the members of Unit 731 despite the horrendous atrocities they committed.
  • The main reason the Unit 731 members were pardoned was the U.S. did not want any other country to get its hands on the data and results of the Unit's biological experiments, as well as the fact that the U.S. knew that they would never be able to get the results from conducting their own experiments, as the Japanese were only able to get their data from performing lethal experiments on thousands of prisoners they took during the war.
  • But from what I have researched, the results of Unit 731's experiments were neither groundbreaking nor even practical for most purposes.
  1. So what exactly did the U.S. consider to be so valuable that they were willing to let these monsters go unpunished?
  2. Was the U.S. aware of the full extent and nature of the Unit's crimes when they pardoned them?
  3. Although this idea may come across as pretty dark, I feel that in this case, it is fully deserved, and that idea is that the U.S. would tell the Unit 731 members they would pardon them, and once they got the data, they would just execute them after. Why didn't they do this?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

Why does Bertrand Russell’s classic “History of Western Philosophy” give such a negative view of Nietzsche?

Nietzsche is genuinely my favourite philosopher of all time. He shows the most incredible authenticity of human experience and a vital expression of being alive. I love his scorn of religious belief. I love his use of aphorisms. I love his appreciation of pre-Socratic philosophers. I love his hatred of Idealism. I love his naturalistic worldview. Basically, he shows why life is worth living.

Why does Bertrand Russell describe him with such hostility and within the lineage of philosophical and historical thought which created Naziism?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

Shaka Zulu never married and had no children - may he have been homosexual, and what were contemporary Zulu views on homosexuality?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

I saw a meme about a guy named Josef Mencik who fought in WW2 on horse back in full plate armor and lived in a castle. I cant find any english sources on this how true is this story?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

how were pirates organized in historical times (other then the golden age of piracy in the Caribbean)?

assume we are talking about pirates before the 1850's. how were Chinese pirates organized ? in other places and times where there was significant pirate activity? did they have ships articles? were they democratic in voting in and out their captains ? any other organization differences between historical golden age of pirates? any areas or times that had unique pirate organization rules ?

2 Answers 2022-08-29

Dark humour often revolves around tragic subjects like 9/11 or Kennedy's assassination. Is this a typical 21st Century thing, or did people make jokes about stuff like the assassination of Empress Sisi or the Lisbon Earthquake of 1755?

Like did people in the 19th Century say things like:

"Oh man, I'll never forget the tragedy of the 13th of March. I lost my Uncle Ignacy that day!" (Ignacy Hryniewiecki blew himself up in 1881, killing Tsar Alexander II and 20 other people).

"Damn, I've just been on the worst cruise ever. I'll never sail with the Medusa again! The catering was horrible!" (In 1816, the French ship Méduse sank off the coast of Africa, leading to the death of 140 people. The 15 survivors, drifting aptop a raft, were forced into cannibalism until they were rescued)

1 Answers 2022-08-29

Is it just a coincidence that ConSTANtinoPLE sounds similar to Istanbul?

Having looked up the etymology of Istanbul I was surprised to find "Constantinople" just wasn't relevant to how Istanbul came about, with Istanbul being a Turkish corruption of Stamboul from eis tḕn Pólin with it's own origin and everything.

Was that it? The two city names sound similar and it's just a coincidence they do?

For all I know, eis ten polin is just a pun in a way. Sounding close to Constantinople and referring to Constantinople, but being a different phrase itself. Just like how nobody would normally say something like "Sauce?" when asking for a source if not for the fact the two words sound similar. Do we have an answer for this? Is it just a coincidence like it really sounds? Are the two linked in any way?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

the psychological nature of religious self-harm? (specifically the early middle ages in europe)

(this post keeps tagging as military and war each time i post it and idk why im very sorry if that happens this time)

so, i'm taking a history class about the period from 300-1000 CE in western europe. it's our second week and we're currently on the rise of christianity within europe. i just read a statement about ascetics and their actions and i found it really strange (in a fascinating way) the nature to which self-injuring was glorified for the sake of a divine relationship. i know this question veers towards the psychological side, but i've seen questions about the nature of PTSD in the ancient world show up in the FAQ, so i think it's appropriate.

basically, my question is this: to what extent was this sort of behavior different or similar to our modern understanding of self-harm as a coping mechanism? ascetics of the early middle ages starved themselves, whipped themselves, wore hair-shirts, etc. in the name of getting closer to the big G, and this sort of behavior was, on average (at least from my understanding), glorified by the theologian and church theorists around them. how did (if we have enough sources into their psychology) these ascetics feel about the harm they did to themselves? and why was it so popular a movement (in the sense that your average christian regarded ascetics as wise, virtuous people, and not that weird hobo on the outskirts of town that you clutch your toga to yourself when you walk past him)?

And, maybe in a broader sense, how have societal perspectives on self-harm/injury/parasuicide, etc. changed from this stage, where it was okay to harm the self if it was in search of God?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

US high school textbook and curriculum tout voting as the people’s way to participate in the world’s greatest democracy. Yet, there is no standardized lesson plan on real-life ways on how voting works on a practical level. What explains this huge discrepancy? Simple oversight, intentional lobbying?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

The famous early civilizations rose on river valleys of Nile, Tigris-Euph, Yellow and Indus. Is it a coincidence all of these valleys are at least partially surrounded by desert?

Egypt is the starkest example of this with the Nile being a bright green strip in the middle of the Sahara and basically every Egyptian living there. But the others are also surrounded by desert or arid landscape on at least some of their path to the ocean. Tigris and Euphrates is surrounded by the Syrian and Arab deserts once it leaves Anatolia. Yellow River partially flows through the Gobi Desert. Indus flows through the Thar Desert and the Iranian Plateau.

Did the desert offer an early barrier to foreign enemies and give these people a breathing space to develop their civilization? Or is this just a coincidence?

2 Answers 2022-08-29

In this conflict between Palestinians and Israelis on the land, is there a time line for civilizations that occupied that land through history?

In this conflict between Palestinians and Israelis on the land, is there a time line for civilizations that occupied that land through history?

1 Answers 2022-08-29

I'm Ken Mondschein, a professional historian of swordfighting and medieval warfare who's so obsessed with Game of Thrones I wrote a book about it! AMA about the Real Middle Ages vs. GoT/HotD/ASOIAF!

My name is Ken Mondschein, and I'm a professional medieval historian (PhD from Fordham University) who's a wee bit obsessed with George R. R. Martin's fantasy world (just as Martin is a wee bit obsessed with real medieval history). Besides my book Game of Thrones and the Medieval Art of War, I've written on the history of timekeeping and medieval swordfighting, and translated medieval and Renaissance fencing books (1) (2). I also write for medievalists.net; two of my recent MdN Game of Thrones writings are here and here.

Oh—not the least of my qualifications, I'm also a fencing master and jouster!

AMA about medieval history, medieval warfare, swordfighting and jousting (the real history of it, not "what's the best sword?" or "could a samurai beat a knight?"), or how Game of Thrones/A Song of Ice and Fire stack up to the real Middle Ages! If I can't answer off the top of my head... I'll research it and get back to you!

BTW, here are my social medias so you can follow my stuff:

YouTubes (vids and rants)

Twitter Machine (s**tposting)

Tikkedy tok (short vids)

Facebooks (professional page)

Amazon page (my books)

Insta (tattoos, jousting, etc.)

Edit: I had to work my horse and teach fencing Monday evening 8/29, but I will be back on Tuesday 8/30 (before I go teach more HEMA) and will get to all your questions. Some of them are really cool, and I want to give in-depth answers!

114 Answers 2022-08-29

139 / 7255

Back to start