To what extent were camels considered as a mode of transport in the Old American West?

I understand that Camels can carry more and walk farther than horses, particularly in desert climates, which would make them much better for hauling cargo across the American West during its expansion. I also understand there was an experiment done just before the Civil War which actually proved to be successful, but it was never picked up again by the government because of its associations with the confederacy.

Apparently most of the camels used during the experiment were sold at auction, so what happened to those that were sold? Were there no big private organisations that decided to use them? Would they not have been useful as stagecoach drivers for example? Or on ranches? And what about the ones that escaped? Is there any particular reason that wild camels didn't become more commonplace since they would be well suited to that habitat?

I know there's a lot to unpack there but thank you in advance if you can answer any or all of these questions!

2 Answers 2020-04-04

Questions about Brunhilda if Austrasia

Ok somewhat obscure topic but I got down a Wikipedia rabbit hole last night and the story about the rivalry between Brunhilda and Fredegund is fascinating. Couple questions I couldn’t find an answer to.

  1. After being jailed by Fredegund, how did Brunhilda get out of jail to be able to marry Merovech?
  2. Why was Brunhilda exiled by her grandson Theudebert II?

Thanks in advance for any additional insight. Any book recommendations are appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-04-04

In American D-Day (Normandy, France) popular culture why are some units more famous and repeatedly shown over others?

For instance the 101st Airborne (specifically the 506th PIR) is shown far more than the 82nd Airborne Division, even though some elements of the 82nd were already battle tested. Another example is the prefrence for showing the 2nd Ranger Battalion and 16th IR of the 1st infantry Division over say the 29th Infantry (which took a huge hit on DDay especially the Bedford Boys company), or 4th Infantry.

This doesn't even include units that came in the following days that heroically partook in the Normandy liberation and subsequent break out (such as the 2nd Infantry).

Why does popular culture choose to look at a couple heroic units vs other equally heroic and admirable units when it comes to their portrayals of the American DDay Operations (Omaha Beach, Utah Beach, and the Airborne forces dropped on the peninsula)?

I am a big history buff but want to know others theories and insights.

Thank you

1 Answers 2020-04-04

What did muslim commoners drink in the Middle Ages to quench their thirst?

I'm unsure if this is true, but I've read that commoners in medieval Europe preferred drinking beer and/or wine over drinking regular water, because the former was considered safer than the latter.

This begs the question what medieval muslim commoners (for example in the MENA region) drank to quench their thirst, considering many muslim realms forbid the consumption of alcohol.

1 Answers 2020-04-04

What did Ethiopians themselves call their country during the 12th century?

Before modern Ethiopia was created, it was known as Axum, which collapsed by the 8th century. Then Europeans and others began to refer to the territory as Abyssinia around the 15th century. Ethiopia itself started referring to itself as Abyssinia until the first half of the 20th century, when it officially changed its name to Ethiopia. Interestingly, the Bible and ancient Greek records referred to the territory as Ethiopia. But during the hundreds of years between the collapse of Axum and the country being known as Abyssinia, how did its people themselves refer to their country?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

Was there much debate over naming Israel, Israel, instead of Judea?

2 Answers 2020-04-04

How was the British Navy so vulnerable to air attack during the Falkland's War?

I've spent many hours researching this and reading this up and watching documentaries and it's almost clear to me that during the war, British Naval vessels were pretty much sitting around in open water, waiting around for limited attacks by Argentine Air Forces (Armada) and limited in their ability to defend against them.

Why weren't the vessels sunk by the Argentine Armada able to provide for their own defenses?

Was the Pucara air-assault aircraft something special or was there something else going on?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

Did high-ranking Viking women nurse their own children?

If not, who were their wet-nurses and what role did wet-nurses have in Viking society?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

Is histories(Herodotus) realiable or fiction

I always took scholarly historical publications as facts, but recently a thought came to my mind.

I always thought that some pages or chapters from histories survived and historian just used radio-carbon dating to tell the age of the script and if it is accurate.

I just found out that the oldest surviving complete copy was written in 10th century CE

The oldest fragments of the histories is dated to 1st century CE.

But herodotus talks about events from 500-400BCE.

I don't doubt the existence of herodotus, as there are other sources for that.

But how do we know that the original copy contained what we think it does.

How can we say that some guy in 1st Century CE didn't interject pages or whole chapters into the work.

Or hell does the original work even exists.

Feel free to correct me :)

3 Answers 2020-04-04

Before corrective lenses were invented, how often did people just have to learn to live with poor vision?

To add to this, were people with poor vision allowed in the military or the nobility, or were they most often relegated to lower classes?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

What impacts did the German 48ers (refugees from the failed revolutions of 1848) have on Civil War Era American politics? (1850s/1860s)

I've already posted this question a few months ago, but I am posting this once more because I got no answers. :(

German immigration peaked during the period of 1850-1860, with over 900,000 German immigrants immigrating to the United States. As well, it is reported that people from all over the world tried to enlist in the Union Army during the Civil War (though they were turned down because actively recruiting them would break neutrality laws) along with massive numbers of immigrants within the United States. (Out of 2 million Union soldiers, an estimated 543,000 were immigrants and another 317,000 were sons of immigrants)

This would mean that these refugees (many of which were in influential, high-level positions) would have a large influence on Civil War Era politics. So, what impacts did they have on Civil War Era American politics?


As well, some separate questions I have are:

  • What percent of the German refugees would be sympathetic towards 48ers but not a 48er?

  • Where did many of 48ers migrate to and why? (I've heard New York City, Chicago, Wisconsin, Missouri, and Texas which all seem like wildly different places)

  • What general resources would you recommend so that I can learn more about the role German 48ers played during this time period?

2 Answers 2020-04-04

Who existed in Scandinavia before the Vikings?

As far as I know, the viking period began 793 CE, but who came before that? Who were the ancestors to the vikings who came right before the vikings in the Vendel period? I assume they spoke Proto Germanic or North Germanic.

1 Answers 2020-04-04

Why did Henry Hopkin Sibley's New Mexico Campaign fail catastrophically?

It seems that Sibley's advance toward Colorado was going as planned until they had to retreat back to Alburquerque following the Battle of Glorieta Pass. Sibley was granted reinforcements, but then decided to retreat back to Texas. I can not see the reasoning behind him ordering a retreat, when he could've waited for his reinforcements to arrive. Can anyone explain this to me?

2 Answers 2020-04-04

Why didn’t the Guillotine catch on in America ?

To the extent of my knowledge while Europe still had capital punishment most executions where carried out via Guillotine. However as far as I know the US has never had a Guillotine execution what explains this difference ?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

My local news station did a story about the Spanish Flu of 1918, they said that soldiers were often victims of the flu because their lungs were damaged by chemical warfare from WW1 and Civilians on the Central Powers side were vulnerable because of malnutrition. Are these statements accurate?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

Why did people in the British Isles make Crannogs? Why build yourself an island when there's perfectly good land right beside it that doesn't require so much extra work?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

Similarity between Ancient Roman and Greek religions

So I was wondering about why the Greeks and the Roman's have very similar mythologies. Essentially I'm wondering why they're similar but also why they're different? Like was there some sort of a schism at some point? Is it pure coincidence?

Side question, a history buff friend of mine once told me that when the Romans invaded Greece, they did not raze their temples as they felt that the Greeks worshiped the same gods they did, they just called them by the "wrong" names. Apparently they effectively were like "silly Greeks, this is Jupiter, not Zeus". Is there any truth to that?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

How did spartan Warriors train?

1 Answers 2020-04-04

Aside from burning much of Georgia, did Shermans army perform any other widespread atrocities like mass rape, killing unarmed civilians, etc?

While I have no doubt there were isolated incidents, you often hear of uncontested armies in "enemy" territory doing horrific war crimes. Moreso the concept of war crimes in the 1800s wasn't what it is now.

1 Answers 2020-04-04

Why did François Gérard paint African & Middle Eastern solders at Austerlitz?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Austerlitz#/media/File:Austerlitz-baron-Pascal.jpg

I was looking at this painting and the presence of what seem like African and Turkish/Arabic soldiers on the left really intrigued me. I couldn't find any information through Google as to why they were there, nor does the Wikipedia article on the battle mention any kind of foreign soldiers that were present. Does anyone know why they're in the painting? Were soldiers from those areas of the world really present at Austerlitz?

1 Answers 2020-04-03

Why was the Anchor the symbol of the Seleucid Empire?

I read this previous question but I was wondering if anyone else had further information? Thanks :))

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1ijuzx/why_was_the_anchor_the_symbol_of_the_seleucid/

1 Answers 2020-04-03

The Hapsburgs forged the documents that gave them their special Archduchy title and privileges. The documents were known to be forgeries at the time, and even included texts from Caesar and Nero. Why weren't they laughed out of court?

1 Answers 2020-04-03

History of Science: What Are the Three Kingdoms of Natural History?

I'm working on translating documents related to education in Colombia revolutionary period so I can post them online for public access. The Congress of Nueva Granada passed in 1826 an Organic Law on Instruction, and when discussing what curriculum should be taught, they mention historia natural en sus tres reinos, or natural history in its three kingdoms. After a little research, I found a couple of old reference books which use this terminology, but none actually define it. Can someone help me with this?

1 Answers 2020-04-03

What was education like in the late Russian Empire (1900-1917)?

What were the literacy rates among the general population? What about certain social classes, like the military or clergy? How were schools organized, public or private? What about universities? How widespread was access to education, especially in the more remote (Siberia) or non-Russian areas (Caucasus, Central Asia, etc.)

2 Answers 2020-04-03

Are there any sources dedicated to Japanese soldiers of the Rape of Nanjing?

I was wondering if there are any journals, interviews, etc that focus on the Japanese soldiers who committed the atrocities in the Rape of Nanjing. Maybe they shouldn’t have been given any attention because of how brutal and awful they were, but I was just wondering how it may have been attempted to be justified, like how Hitler justified his own atrocities.

1 Answers 2020-04-03

1426 / 7255

Back to start