I imagine that during the medieval era and beyond that a nations territory was vague, and difficult to police. How long have countries had definitive borders that monitored entrants and regulated who can and cannot travel through? Did historical nations even have any desire to doing so?

1 Answers 2020-01-28

Pre-Colonial Rhodesia/Zimbabwe - Would Lobengula have had any knowledge of the Berlin Conference?

After listening to the excellent Askhistorians podcast episode 50 with u/ProfRhodes and reading some other material, I was wondering whether, given the Berlin Conference was in essence the green light to colonial ambitions in Africa, would any African leaders, and in particular Lobengula, have had any knowledge of the Berlin Conference and its outcome? If so, would it have given them cause to have reservations when signing agreements such as the Rudd Concession in opening the front door to colonialisation? When Lobengula subsequently attempted to rescind the Rudd Concession, was there any real effect from petitioning Queen Victoria, and would she have been in any way likely to go against Cecil Rhodes and the South Africa Company and support Lobengula in maintaining an independent Ndebele state?

Apologies if it is too many questions, but I have a slightly separate one related directly to the podcast, on the 1896/7 uprisings. u/ProfRhodes mentioned that Cape Coloureds were used to put down parts of the Ndebele and Shona rebellions. Was there any evidence of the Cape regiments in any way supporting a fellow African peoples rebellion against colonisation?

Thanks for your time and Knowledge! Sean

1 Answers 2020-01-28

How close was Germany to the development of an atomic bomb and did we discover any plans of what they intended to do with it?

1 Answers 2020-01-28

Did the Middle East invade Italy some time before the 1800’s began?

I heard on the radio that sometime maybe during or long before the Middle Ages, Italy was invaded by the Middle East, then there was a death toll of 3,500, and Italy had to toughened up afterwards.

I’m only going by poor memory of something I heard on the AM radio.

1 Answers 2020-01-28

What resources existed in Ancient Egypt that made it so desirable for Greece, Rome, etc. to conquer?

It seems to me somewhat as though Alexander diverted significantly from a path into Southwest Asia into Northeast Africa, and as far as I can tell he wasn't provoked by the Egyptians into war or anything; he chose to attack them.

And while Augustus conquered Egypt as a part of defeating his rival Marcus Antonius and becoming emperor, he then declared it a part of his personal territory, not Rome's.

Both of these suggest to me an intent to conquer Egypt, which I would assume is to acquire the resources contained in the land.

But what resources are these? I've tried looking online, but all I find are the resources of modern Egypt, such as oil and gas (largely undiscovered and useless to the ancient world), or else basic claims about Ancient Egypt's resources being the fertile Nile and copper.

1 Answers 2020-01-28

Where did Hitler get his start-up funding?

So apparently (according to this Netflix documentary anyway) Before Hitler even ran Germany his private army had over three million men. That can't be fucking cheap. Shortly later he's building massive infrastructure overhauls all while Germany is supposedly dirt poor.

I know during the war a lot of Nazi expansion was funded through conquest and the spoils, but it's the initial boom that confuses me, how did he pay for all that?

1 Answers 2020-01-28

In the game Shogun 2: Total War, many clans have "traits" in which they are the best at a certain thing, such as archery. Is there any accuracy to these traits?

In the game, the Chosokabe Clan have improved archers, the Mori have improved ships, etc. The only one that seems accurate is the Takeda Clan having improved cavalry, as Takeda Shingen's cavalry was renowned.

Besides Takeda Cavalry, however, is there any evidence that one Clan was regarded as having the best archers, ships, katana samurai, etc.?

2 Answers 2020-01-28

why is orthodox Christianity not as widespread as Catholicism or Protestantism

Why is Orthodox Christianity not as widespread as Catholicism or Protestantism?

1 Answers 2020-01-28

Did Confederate leaders see slavery lasting indefinitely? Were there plans to eventually phase-out the institution years down the line after the Civil War, or was it assumed that it would last forever?

4 Answers 2020-01-28

What were other Allied Forces soldiers opinions on the Americans M1 Garands?

I am watching Band of Brothers and it's got me thinking when Americans did operation with forces that used bolt actions (Lee Enfields for example) what were their opinions on the garand? Jealousy? Upset that their country didnt get better rifles?

(I'm not American btw)

1 Answers 2020-01-28

Crimes for Bootlegging during Prohibition?

I am writing a paper about the crimes for bootlegging during the Prohibition and I’m having trouble finding a source where it says the charges for bootlegging?

1 Answers 2020-01-28

Why was the Cotton Gin invented in 1793 and not earlier?

It seems that they have all the knowledge, resources, and motivation necessary to have invented it centuries earlier.

1 Answers 2020-01-28

Who are the Druze and how did they come about? They seem to be quite distinct from other Muslims and Wikipedia has surprisingly little information on them.

1 Answers 2020-01-28

If Japan lost against the Soviets during the early stages of WW2 (Siberian Invasion), what made them think that they could beat the Americans which has a far better military and industrial capacity?

2 Answers 2020-01-28

After the liberation of the concentrations camps, many survivors immigrated to America, where they were told to not speak of their experiences to ease their assimilation. Was this a well-meaning band aid slapped on the horrors of the Holocaust? When was it “acceptable” to talk about the camps?

I’m also curious as to how historians (in general, not just the US) began collecting the memories and testimonies of survivors, once it was acceptable to talk about it. How did historians get documents and photos? Were there organizations set up to handle the flow of documents? Who translated them from German? Did the huge influx of information influence the presumed casual and institutional anti-Semstica present in academia?

2 Answers 2020-01-28

Was the whole “the earth is flat. If you sail far enough out to sea you’ll fall off into oblivion!” Actually accepted science at one point or just folklore. Was it actually “published” science?

1 Answers 2020-01-28

What are some good historically focused podcasts to listen to?

For example, I've been listening to Dan Carlin's Hardcore History and I've found that I really like that sort of in depth style. Any similar sorts of podcasts out there would be great.

4 Answers 2020-01-28

Why did the Dutch got so little in the treaty of the peace of utrecht(1713) considering their efforts in the war of the spanish succesion?

1 Answers 2020-01-27

Silver is a commonly used trope as an anti-supernatural metal, from repellant to weapon. What is the history/origin of this mythos? Was it simply it's antibacterial properties or something more?

3 Answers 2020-01-27

To what extent did Germany attempt to get Mexico to invade the US in WWI?

I can't seem to find a lot of info on the internet regarding Germany and Mexico's relationship during the war. The Wikipedia article for the Zimmerman Telegram mentions Franz von Rintelen oversaw funding of $12 million to Victoriano Huerta in 1915 to start a war, but doesn't go into any detail at all.

So I wanted to know just how much effort did Germany put into starting a war between the US and Mexico prior to the Zimmerman Telegram? Also, did the Kaiser and the German commanders like Ludendorff or Hindenburg know about the telegram? And if so did they approve of it or the general idea of starting a second Mexican-American War?

1 Answers 2020-01-27

Historians, How accurate is the Ken Burns Vietnam War documentary?

And would you show it to college students if you were teaching a class on the Vietnam War?

2 Answers 2020-01-27

How did Portugal survive the expanding Spanish speaking kingdoms in Iberia?

1 Answers 2020-01-27

So I found a book from 1917

Okay, so in my college library I found an old book titled “Russia from the Varangians to the Bolsheviks” by R. Beazley, N. Forbes and G.A. Birkett and I think the book is from around 1917-1923. This is because it has a signature in it which is dated at February 1923 so had to be printed some time before then. I was wondering if anyone had any information on this book? I would post a picture, but I’m incapable with technology. Thanks in advance

1 Answers 2020-01-27

Before modern science (ex: the Middle Ages), top Catholic/Christian church officials were the some of the most powerful and richest people in their communities. Did they actually believe in God, or did they just see their positions of power as an easy way to become rich and manipulate people?

Religion was central to social life in the times before modern science (for example, in the Middle Ages) because people had no other way to explain natural pheomena. Common/poor people believed in religion due to a lack of education, they were probably at the mercy of being exposed to only information the rich and powerful decided to give them, and they might have looked to religion for hope for a better future.

On the other hand, there were the top Catholic/Christian church officials. They were rich, more educated about the world, and were the ones creating the rules to rule over the commoners/poor. Did they actually believe in God, as well, or did they just see their positions of power as a way to easily manipulate the masses? Being the ones pulling the strings, I don't know if it was an, "I know the way the world works once the curtain is pulled, and I know there is no God" type of situation, if that makes sense.

1 Answers 2020-01-27

Do Holocaust survival depended on who liberated the concentration camp?

So I was under the impression that the Soviet Union did their own ethnic cleansing similar to the Nazis (if I’m wrong then please correct me) so my question is, did Soviets liberated people that were on camps (I mean when there were the first army to arrive to it) or just were like “well, we already have this infrastructure, we might just use it”. Thanks.

1 Answers 2020-01-27

1545 / 7255

Back to start