Is the bombing of hiroshima and nagasaki considered a war crime, considering thr targets were civilians?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Is it true that MLK Jr. was not a man of upstanding character?

I have heard that MLK Jr. cheated on his wife, participated in orgies, witnessed and laughed at a rape and did nothing to help her, and even raped someone himself. This was supposedly all recorded by the FBI under J Edgar Hoover but if that's true, shouldn't there be proof? Is any of this actually true or are people just trying to slander him?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Did Britain in the 1600 dislike that cities in America put “New” in front of Britian cities. Or was it seen as a good thing?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Given that a lot of the Nordic countries claim to have had Vikings, where did the Vikings truly originate from?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Why did Belgian colonial rulers in Rwanda create a 'two-tiered' education system, privileging the Tutsi ethnic group over the Hutu ethnic group?

I'm basing this question off Mahmood Mamdani quoted in Ben Nugent's 'Africa Since Independence'.

1 Answers 2020-01-21

[Career Advice] Looking to possibly transition into career as historian - advice sought

Hello! I apologize if this isn't the right place to post this question (and if not, please delete!), but I'm doing a lot of research into a potential career change, and I wanted some professionals opinions.

I'm currently an attorney that focuses on civil litigation. I've always been a history "enthusiast," with a particular interest in the middle ages. The thing I like about being an attorney is the research, writing, and opportunity to teach people about things they didn't know before.

I've recently been reading a lot more, and I've been brainstorming some ideas on things I would like to write about related to my historical interests. I'm not a trained historian, so I'm sure this wouldn't be that useful of an exercise at this point. So this got me thinking about going back to school and getting an MA in history and then potentially continuing on to a PhD program if that suit me.

I'm not worried about cost because I'm fortunate enough that that isn't an issue. but I wanted to ask /r/askhistorians about what beginning this career path would potentially look like, how a person could come into this from another career, and whether it's even a recommended course of action. In case it's relevant, I'm 28.

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Why does pop culture depict vikings as generally being shirtless, despite they usually being in cold areas? Is there a histotical basis for this?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

The 'kyōkaku' or chivalrous commoner seems to be the Japanese equivalent of Robin Hood or the knight errant. Were these figures equally fictional?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

How were casualties replaced in World War 1?

I heard that Armies had reserve divisions, and replacements often entered depleted divisions through reserve batalions. But what about existing batalions? Did they receive replacement, smaller military units (reserve companies, squads etc)? Or were depleted units simply merged

1 Answers 2020-01-21

How Did Deaf Native Americans Communicate?

Did the indigenous peoples of the Americas have one or more sign languages?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

How sovereign were the Bailiwicks of the Teutonic Order, after the dissolution of 1525?

After Grand Master, Albrecht of Brandenburg took his title as Duke of Prussia, what became of the Teutonic Order's remaining territories across France, Germany and the Netherlands? I understand these territories were organised into "Bailiwicks," each ruled by a Land Commander. Each Bailiwick was a conglomeration of Parishes, small landmasses owned by the Knights and priests. These lands were often either donated to the Order, or else they were purchased, as if like private property. My question is: Would these lands be recognised as sovereign territories of the Teutonic Order? Or rather, after the dissolution, did the Teutonic Order evolve from being a nation, to more of a religious organisation? The lands which were purchased and donated, were they ultimately just under the control of the non-Teutonic counts, dukes and Kings who offered them?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Is the "nation states are a modern/enlightenment invention" idea globally applicable?

I have encountered the sentence: "Nation states are a modern/englithenment invention." in several publications now, but not one has given a source for this claim yet. As I have some background in East and Central Asian history (although it's not my main area), this has always struck me as odd. We quite explicitly learned about an emergence of something very much like a nation state in Korea at the beginning of the modern era, I would myself argue that even early Tibetan history is also very nation-state like.

Can anyone point me to a recent publication which deals with the idea of nation states globally and not just euro-centrically, or perhaps a source which would shed some light on the origins of this claim? Thanks in advance! :)

2 Answers 2020-01-21

How did European explorers breech the language barriers when they found a new land with people speaking entirely different languages, which they had never interacted with before?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Is it incorrect to think that the ideas of nation and national identity are a modern invention?

Learning a bit more about European history, I've come to the conclusion that the whole idea of nation(that is, a group of people bound together by shared culture and language) didn't really exist until XIX century, with many being basically constructed by a small group of intellectuals.

Would that be a misconception? I imagine that it's far more complicated than that, but it would still be interesting to know what the historical consensus on this issue is.

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Where there any plans on what to do if hitler was captured alive by any allied powers?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

How did the name "Roger" become accepted as "command received"?

Is this mainly an American pop culture creation? Not sure what the origins are.

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Why many foreign countries call the American Civil War the Secession War?

I've checked Spanish, French, German, Portuguese and Polish, they all translate to "Secession War". On the other hand, in Russian and Greek they translate to "Civil War".

This is probably a niche question, but why the split? Is there a clear reason?

My first guess was to claim Confederate legitimacy, but one of the Spanish documents using the term shortly after the war, praises general Grant. So it's not obvious the relation. Maybe people simply considered it a secession war and didn't have any reason to avoid that term, in contrast to the US government?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

During the Black Death, Christian populations famously blamed the Jews for the outbreak, resulting in continent-wide massacres. Did the Jews themselves have a similar scapegoat? Who or what did Jewish populations blame for the epidemic?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

European Feudal Knights followed the code of Chivalry while the Japanese Samurai followed Bushido. How serious did the average Knight or Samurai strive to acheive the "ideal embodiment" these Codes?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Did the Finnish Winter War influence Hitler’s decision to invade the USSR in 1941?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

I’m a blacksmith in a Vandal tribe close to Rome between 400-500AD. What’s my life like?

Hello all!

As the title suggests, I’m interested in the lifestyles of so called “barbaric” cultures in the periphery of Rome following Caesar’s conquest of Gaul and the Pax Romana. I’m fairly familiar with Celtic/Gaelic history from Hallstatt to La Tène, but I’m currently interested in other groups from later on in the Iron Age, in particular the Vandals.

As far as the term “blacksmith” goes, let’s assume that it encompasses all forms of common metal working, stretching from art and decorations to weaponry and armor.

My main questions are primarily as follows, though any broader inputs would be gladly welcome as well.

What’s my status in the Vandal hierarchy? Is smithing considered to be a valuable skill worthy of respect, or just a menial task?

How am I compensated for my work, and how does that compensation compare to other occupations within the Vandal culture? Am I a member of the working classes or the aristocracy? Is there an institutionalized monetary system in place, or does compensation occur at a more simple and direct bartering level?

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-01-21

What types of materials did northern Europeans use to stay warm in subzero temperatures in medieval times?

I just read that the first goose-down jacket was produced in 1936, and I didn't do any additional research but it got me wondering-- since coats like we have nowadays were obviously not always available, how did people stay warm in Scandinavian areas when temperatures dipped below zero, sometimes far below zero?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

Why does Ancient Greek art frequently depict soldiers wearing helmets halfway on? Is this authentic to how a soldier would wear it when he wasn't in immediate need, or is it a purely stylistic choice?

Examples:

This coin dated 340-330 BC

Bust of Pericles

1 Answers 2020-01-21

It’s 1905 and I’m at a lynching of an African American man somewhere in the Deep South. If I looked into the crowd of whites gathered to watch it, what would be the class makeup of them? Would they be middle class? Rich? Or poor?

1 Answers 2020-01-21

This Week's Theme: Arms Races.

1 Answers 2020-01-21

⯇ 1557 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start