Did Italy hold any special significance to the Byzantines?

As it was the ancient heartland of the empire I imagine that it would be considered special to the medieval Romans. Obviously after the Arab conquests the Romans were never again in a position to retake the peninsula, but if the stars had aligned the right way would retaking Italy have been a higher priority than say, Syria?

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Why didn't Germany go threw Switzerland

Switzerland didn't have a treaty with Britain so why risk Britain joining the war.

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Is there an unbiased "history of the world", as in not written by the victors of conflict?

Things like how Colombus is seen as a hero in certain cultures, but a villan in others.

Is there a nonbiased version of world history available online?

2 Answers 2020-01-03

What exactly was the purpose and intent behind the Monroe Doctrine?

I’ve seen the Monroe Doctrine interpreted as the beginning of US imperialism in Latin America by effectively declaring the Western Hemisphere an American sphere of influence. However, couldn’t it also be interpreted as the US seeking to protect the newly independent Latin American republics from recolonization by European powers? Which interpretation reflected Monroe’s initial intentions and how did the implementation of the Monroe Doctrine change over time?

1 Answers 2020-01-03

What were some tattoos that Vikings actually had, if any

With Nordic tattoos being sort of in style right now it got me thinking. How many of them are something that a Viking or nord would have actually had? Are we westernizing and stylizing them just to make them look cool or are we being at least partially historically accurate? Or did Vikings even have tattoos? I really have no idea. Thank you in advance for any response!

Edit: I’m referring to the Viking age from ~800-1050.

2 Answers 2020-01-03

Harold Bloom states that Shakespeare "invented" the modern human (i.e a 3 dimensional, relatable character). As a theatre goer in 16th century England, am I able to pick this up from Shakespeare especially, as opposed to Peele, Johnson or Marlowe?

1 Answers 2020-01-03

What is the status of Fredrick Jackson Turner's Frontier Thesis among historians today? Is it still used as an explanation of broader aspects of US historical trends, or closer to something that illuminates how Americans in the early 20th century thought about their own past?

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Why did the USA performs its nuclear testing in relatively populated Arizona rather than much less populated Alaska?

1 Answers 2020-01-03

The Rise of Fascism and Communism as Challenges to Democracy: Teaching Ideology and Power

Hey folks,

I hope this is relevant. As I have spent months browsing fascism and communism related material on Reddit, I've recognized how valuable posing this question to the community might be. I am attempting to design curriculum (as a social studies and history teacher) surrounding the challenge to liberal democracies that originates post-WWI across Europe in the form of fascism, communism, and socialism, often coupled with authoritarian and potentially totalitarian ruling methods. Students (and people in general) tend to really struggle to both define and understand these ideologies and resultant labels today despite their increasing use, often in the form of insults. As a result, I have a few questions as I undertake this process:

  1. Can anyone recommend fundamental secondary or primary sources (both small and large in scope) that may help to address these concepts and historical content at a secondary (high school + college) level? I've enjoyed reading Umberto Eco's essay on Ur-Fascism as well as Paxton's The Anatomy of Fascism. I have also considered Mark Mazower's Dark Continent a fundamental text for my unit. Would anyone have similar interesting sources addressing the the concepts of socialism and communism? Obviously, the use of primary sources from Mussolini, Hitler, Marx, Lenin, Faranacci, Stalin, and others are useful here.

One of the ways I am going about designing the teaching of this is to draw clear and direct parallels of the systems of liberal democracy, fascism, and socialism/communism to the organization and governance of a school system (specifically the school systems my students are currently in). I recognize that this can be simplistic and poorly done, and thus I am hoping to ensure that I generalize to this organization (the school) in the most valid and accurate way possible, even if there are necessary problems in this analogy.

Fundamentally, I am working with this assumption: the division of power, decision making, and control in a school system can be analogous to the division of power, decision making, and control in society and thus can be used as an analogy to help students understand these different methods of society's organization (fascism, socialism, liberal democracy)

  1. Is this a viable way for students to understand these larger political, social, and economic systems? How do I ensure that I do not make critical simplifications.

Finally, can anyone help me add to (or correct) my current conception of the school-society analogy:

  • Leadership and administration (superintendent, principals, etc.): heads of government/cabinets
  • Press and media: school newspaper, school YouTube channel, other forms of indirect communication
  • Capital, labor, economic value: grades and schoolwork
  • Workers, peasants: students
  • Bourgeoise, owners, capital classes: teachers
  • Security (our school has much of this): police, military, etc.
  • Student organizations: trade unions, interest groups, activists, etc.

Obviously there are far more parallels to draw, what do you think of mine so far? I know this is not inherently a historical question, but I hope it still qualifies as valid to ask on this board as it has been an invaluable resource in my planning and understanding, and your responses (rest assured) will have important impacts on our future generations.

2 Answers 2020-01-03

How did the united states contribute to allied victory in the second world war?

2 Answers 2020-01-03

Building railroads use to be a huge and important industry, but why has it seemed to die off in the 20th century?

Half the wild west stories I read, or early Canadian history, places a huge importance on railroad building. Yet it seems like railroads started dying off in the 20th century. What happened?

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Announcing the winners for Best Of December!

The votes are in. All hail last month's winners!

Both the flair panel and mainsub unanimously agreed that December's best answer was that of /u/ucumu to the question, Choctaw historian Rita Laws, Ph.D, says the association we have of Native Americans with hunting and fishing is an massive exaggeration, and that the Aztec, Mayan, and Zapotec children ate 100% vegetarian diets until at least the age of ten years old. Is this factual? So they can take pride in having come first in both Flair's Choice and Users' Choice for December!

But since we have two awards to give out, second place goes to /u/woofiegrrl for answering The Deaf community today is split on the use of cochlear implants. Was there similar anger and argument during the spread of hearing aid use?

For the Dark Horse award, /u/sushiladyboner clearly won this category with their answer to Graffiti artist Chaz Bojorquez claims that graffiti took off on the West Coast after WWII, 20 years earlier than in New York. Is that true? How and where did graffiti originate in the US?

Greatest Question for December goes to the wonderfully named /u/OmnivorousWelles for Despite notoriety and commercial success in the 50's for their lurid and gruesome content, why was the very progressive and forceful social content of EC Comics ignored? Was there any perception at the time that the comics were more than a"bad taste" fad? Did anyone take them seriously?

Finally, our Excellence in Flairdom Award for December 2019 goes to /u/ShadowsofUtopia! Shadows specializes in a historical topic that is emotionally difficult even in the best of moments. Researching something like that is hard enough. Sensitively conveying it to readers--on the Internet--is another matter entirely. And ShadowsofUtopia does so with clarity and empathy every time.

As usual (but the first time from me specifically), a huge congrats to the winners, an equally huge congrats to all the nominees, and a no less huge congrats to everyone who contributes to the sub, even just by lurking and reading. You're all awesome!

Past winners can be found here!

8 Answers 2020-01-03

Was there an ‘active campaign to forget’ the pagan thoughts of how ancient world by Christian authority’s between the 6th and 8th centuries?

I read this theory in ‘The Swerve: How the Renaissance Began’ by Stephen Jay Greenblatt, Stephen Greenblatt. It makes the argument that there was an active anti-pagan campaign. Quote from p43

“To be sure, there were a certain number of abbots and monastic librarians who treasured not only the parchment but also the pagan world written on them...Between the sixth century and the middle of the eighth, Greek and Latin classics ceased to be copied at all. What had begun as an active campaign to forget-a pious attack on pagan ideas-had revolved into actual forgetting”.

Perhaps this would make a good topic by itself.

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Friday Free-for-All | January 03, 2020

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

8 Answers 2020-01-03

2019 in Reading: Share Your Reading List from the Past Year, and Plans for the Next One!

As is tradition, with the end of one year, and the beginning of another, its time for our little yearly celebration of books! You (probably) aren't subscribed here if reading is your least favorite thing to do, and I'm sure I'm far from the only one who plows through a large stack of literature over the past year - whether history, other non-fiction, or just a good story.

So, fellow historians, what did you read last year!? What did you enjoy the most? What was the biggest stinker? What would you recommend to everyone else?

And of course, what is on your reading list for 2020!?

11 Answers 2020-01-03

Martial arts prohibition during Qing Dynasty

Hello! I heard that the chinese Qing Dynasty banned the practice of martial arts and I'm trying to search more sources and facts about it. When exactly they banned it and for what reasons? What happened to martial arts in th aftermath of this ban?

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Arthur C. Clarke said that the US Space Program's Promise was lost in the Rice Paddies of Vietnam. Looking at things now, was he right?

To put it another way, I remember watching the landings in the late 60's and 70's and thinking I might retire to a nice lunar community where the gravity would be lighter. Where's my GD Moon Base? :-)

2 Answers 2020-01-03

In 1840, the British launched a military attack against China in order to recover confiscated drugs and guarantee future security for British drug smugglers, in violation of Chinese drug-laws and sovereignty. Was there any attempt made to morally justify this attack, domestically or internationally?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_Wars

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Particularly in the 1920s, how "spicy" were plays and pictures really?

I've been combing through old newspapers and often find reports on plays and pictures that were too "spicy" but how outrageous were they really? And what was the reaction from the public and government (particularly regarding censorship)?

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Did Roman Patricians possess predominantly "Nordic" features (light eyes and hair, fair skin) as white nationalists claim?

I stumbled across a table of early Roman Emperors with their hair color, eye color etc. listed on a white supremacist forum, according to which most of them apparently had blonde or light hair as well as blue/grey eyes. I also read that Romans prized features such as fair skin, light eyes as well as light hair (based on the number of Roman Gods or heroes described as having such features) and that there was a disproportionate number of Patricians possessing such features.

Of course, they draw the sort of conclusion where "Aryans" have always been considered Ubermenschen or whatever, but is the premise even true? If so, it does surprise me considering the occurence of such features in the Mediterranean now and back then. Are there any parallels between Ancient Rome and Greece regarding this?

1 Answers 2020-01-03

I need some advice on war tactic - medieval setting

So, I'm working on a story and I've hit a wall. I need some advice on war tactics with a medieval setting. The situation is this: The King has very much neglected the land and a count with support of the people and a claim to the throne has risen up and started a revolt. The King has the tactic of staying in the castles. Works well in the colder season but poorly in the warmer ones. At this point, his battle trained wife has had enough and takes command. By now the count has most of the land and a bigger army. She should win but I want the battles to actually be smartly planned out instead of the, typical stuff you see around.

What kind of tactics should I look to and what kind historical events should I look to for reference? What situations are similar to this one?

2 Answers 2020-01-03

Early 20th century saw the rise to prominence of several Hungarian scientists, referred to as "Martians". What lead Hungary to producing so many scientist at the time?

Martians

1 Answers 2020-01-03

What happened when someone lost a duel but survived?

I bet this happened very rarely, if ever, but I imagine it must have happened at least once or twice!

1 Answers 2020-01-03

Showbusiness in the hundred years war

Hello, I am searching for any information related to all kinds of showmanship during that period in Europe, mainly France. Theatre, magicians, religious reenactment, what kind of spectacle was being put up, how did people tour along, what did they get in return. Etc. Book recommendations would be perfect, thanks a lot.

1 Answers 2020-01-03

When and how did France split from the Holy Roman Empire?

I've been trying to get a better grasp of medieval history and much of that has involved moving my focus High medieval France and Germany. From what I've managed to grasp, Charlemagne was crowned emperor of the Holy Roman Empire in 800 A.D. Before that, he also was king of France, bringing control of France under that of the HRE. However, I've had trouble figuring out the relationship between France and the Holy Roman Empire after Charlemagne's rule. Did they immediately split? Or did it take time? Or was France never truly part of the HRE? I'm fully aware I could just have a poor understanding of the time period.

As a side question, I'm also curious about France's relationship with Germany before the Holy Roman Empire. From what I've managed to gather, Germany was a result of the Franks splitting into two kingdoms: west and east Francia, one of which became France and the other of which became Germany. Is this at all accurate?

Thank y'all in advance!

1 Answers 2020-01-03

1586 / 7255

Back to start