Today:
AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.
Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.
So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!
1 Answers 2019-12-21
1 Answers 2019-12-21
I have to write a paper concerning culture (he made the topic very broad on purpose) and I want to discuss how gun powder was used differently in different parts of the world. But is it fair to call gun powder a part of culture? It was technically used as entertainment in China, and artillery elsewhere.... Is artillery use a part of culture?
1 Answers 2019-12-21
Our modern address system is ubiquitous, and it's hard to imagine a life without street names and house numbers... at least in the developed world. But how did people in ancient times do the things we take for granted today?
How would you send mail, in let's say the Roman Empire?
How would you meet your Athenian lover who lives far away? How would you arrange to meet up in the first place, without fast communication means?
I can imagine rural areas were chaotic as they still are today in many places. But I'm more wondering about huge well planned cities like Ur, Yinxu, Rakhigarhi, Babylon; Rome, Athens, Alexandria, and even later ones such as Baghdad and Beijing or even Tenochtitlan.
What address systems were used in ancient times, if any, and when did our modern address system arise? I'm basically interested in anything that isn't the modern thing we're used to.
2 Answers 2019-12-21
I was under the impression that there was a dialect continuum in northern Germany/Denmark at the time. If so the language of the Angles should be near the middle of the dialect continuum of Jutes and Saxons? Then why is it that when they migrated to Britain the West Saxon dialect and the Kentish dialect are very similar and both are very different from the Anglian dialects?
2 Answers 2019-12-21
1 Answers 2019-12-21
There is not much information about his military career available online, was Thermopylae the only major battle during his kingship?
1 Answers 2019-12-21
I just watched this lecture (https://youtu.be/1ZNe8WysEqM) and I’m interested in learning more about the history of the Rohingya. Could anyone recommend some good books on the subject?
1 Answers 2019-12-21
I tend to only here of the extinction of native cultures due to widespread infectious diseases brought by European settlers due to zero natural immunity, but are there any documented instances of the opposite: indigenous diseases becoming epidemics among the western populations?
1 Answers 2019-12-21
It seems on the one side Phoenicianist Lebanese politics supposes a common united and recognized identity of the Phoenicians and those scholars on the other hand, for example, Josephine Quinn, assert that they had virtually no common identity and thus cannot be considered a real people or civilization.
They seemed to have identified themselves according to their city, true, but so did the Greeks while having a general idea of Hellas. Can we say that these city-states had some sort of awareness of their common language, religion, and geography that united them, or is the idea of Phoenicia a fabrication?
1 Answers 2019-12-21
If the goal was extermination, why not just kill everyone or send them to the camps? Obviously NOT saying that's what they should've done.
1 Answers 2019-12-21
So I'm writing a scene in my pirate book right now and I tried to do a google search but can't find an answer. How did pirates spar each other during downtime? Did they spar at all? Did they use sharpened blades or were there blunted swords that they used. I have no clue...
1 Answers 2019-12-21
I'm referring to this passage from the Wiki article on "Origins of Judaism" - Google has also led me to some similar views elsewhere.
For centuries, the traditional understanding has been that Judaism came before Christianity and that Christianity separated from Judaism some time after the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE. Starting in the latter half of the 20th century, some scholars have begun to argue that the historical picture is quite a bit more complicated than that.[22][23] In the 1st century, many Jewish sects existed in competition with each other, see Second Temple Judaism. The sects which eventually became Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity were but two of these. Some scholars have begun to propose a model which envisions a twin birth of Christianity and Judaism rather than a separation of the former from the latter.
For example, Robert Goldenberg (2002) asserts that it is increasingly accepted among scholars that "at the end of the 1st century CE there were not yet two separate religions called 'Judaism' and 'Christianity'".[24] Daniel Boyarin (2002) proposes a revised understanding of the interactions between nascent Christianity and nascent Rabbinical Judaism in Late Antiquity which views the two religions as intensely and complexly intertwined throughout this period.
So the idea seems to be that modern, mainstream (rabbinic) Judaism was only really formed in the same era that Christianity was, and that both religions can be considered descendants of an older, proto-Jewish Abrahamic set of religions.
Is this Wikipedia passage accurate? If so, what is driving these interpretations/views? Is it new evidence? Particular ideological currents in religious history? And is this all just a matter of semantics, or are there real implications for this debate?
4 Answers 2019-12-20
This is obviously a broad question. But I'm talking before firearms were invented. Swords and shields, meeting in a field and fighting...Roman, Dark ages, medieval. These historic battles are often depicted in modern media. But how long did they actually play out for? Were they drawn out over hours or over in minutes?
1 Answers 2019-12-20
I'm looking for an introduction book on roman and greek engineering. Ideally, something that covers a wide topic and a large period of time. If there is nothing that general, then maybe these specifications might help clarify what I'm looking for.
era: roman late republic/early empire or greek 500 to 300 BCE
topic: military engineering (ships, siege equipment and so on), water distribution systems, architecture
Thank you for your suggestions : )
Edit: spelling
1 Answers 2019-12-20
Throughout the 19th century, Ireland and Britain were united under the Acts of Union. This new political entity contained many ethnic groups, including the English, Scots, Welsh, and the Irish. I know today that English, Scots, and the Welsh still fall under the category of being "British" but the Irish largely do not. When Ireland was united with Britain, did people in and outside of the nation consider them "British" or just Irish?
1 Answers 2019-12-20
E.g. in this interview Bojorquez talks about Chicano gangs in the Bay Area tagging their names, from ca. the 40s onwards. He would then take influence from Mexican muralismo art to create his own graffiti art in the late 60s. So was graffiti invented on the West Coast rather than late 70s NY? Were there influences between East and West Coast graffiti?
Note: I know that there have been graffiti as in painted words since ancient times - I'm asking specifically about graffiti art and images as seen in Hip Hop culture.
1 Answers 2019-12-20
I'm a third of the way through Stephen Kotkin's excellent Stalin: Volume I: Paradoxes of Power, 1878–1928 and between the years 1905 to 1917, it seems as if Stalin was exiled to Siberia, escaped, recaptured, and subsequently exiled at least five different times, almost always by the Ohranka. After so many repeated escapes and rearrests, why didn't they just execute him? If an answer exists that is indeed exclusive to Stalin, than I'd extend my question to his revolutionary peers, who seem to possess the same pattern of exile, escape, repeat.
1 Answers 2019-12-20
I recently came across a series of articles from various sources that either claim that Saint Francis Xavier's miracle claims are historically verified, or that they are not. Some sources offer examples of testimony given in his favor, such as that of a sailor who witnessed him turn sea water into fresh water. Needless to say I thought it was kind of strange that such wild claims were being made, and wanted to ask exactly how historians go about evaluating these sorts of claims.
http://www.therealpresence.org/archives/Miracles/Miracles_005.htm
http://www.debunking-christianity.com/2008/08/xavier-and-evolution-of-legendary.html
http://www.miraclesofthechurch.com/2010/10/raised-from-dead-saints-who-brought.html
1 Answers 2019-12-20
3 Answers 2019-12-20
I've been looking for books about Nelson as a Christmas present for my Dad (inspired by Jack Aubrey) and would be grateful for expert recommendations. So far The Pursuit of Victory and The Sword of Albion seem the front runners, and was wondering if one of these would be worthwhile or if there are any others I should be looking at? I'd be very grateful for your advice!
1 Answers 2019-12-20
2 Answers 2019-12-20