Why did the Cockade/Roundel become so ubiquitous among modern military forces?

TIL: The French Aéronautique Militaire was the first airforce to adopt the cockade, or Roundel, emblem for their planes in 1909. Several of their allies around the time if WWI followed suit. The existence of the cockade goes back much farther however, all the way back to medieval knights using cockades on their helmets in order to make sure their allies could distinguish them on the battlefield, as many knights heavily decorated/customized their armor individually(please correct me if I'm wrong, I'm very very far from well read on the subject).

I can't, however, seem to find out why the roundel in and of itself became so ubiquitous in the early 20th century, a quick scroll through a collection of Airforce emblems over the years shows several nations all adopting the Roundel in a relatively short time between 1909 to 1950 or so. Is there any specific reason the Roundel in particular was so popular, or was it just an aesthetic choice that people thought simply looked good?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

What were the goals of the people at Tiananmen Square? Were they liberals seeking a Western-style nation, or anti-revisionist Maoists who saw the leadership as state capitalist? Or perhaps a mix of both?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

Did polytheistic European pagans ever believe that their gods ‘loved’ them the way He does in Christianity and Islam?

I know that for the Greek and Roman pantheons, ‘gods’ were powerful, but ultimately considered humanity to be something of a toy. They were arbitrary and cruel to humans as they wished, and felt they had no obligation to them, often ignoring them entirely. Of course Allah and Christian God loved humans and do everything they can to guide them on the path to righteousness. They are able to watch over every person, believer or not, and punish or reward them as they deserve. God in many ways considers humanity as his child, and has no other duties to attend to. I don’t understand why there has to be only one loving god, or when you have more than one they become cruel. Did pagans ever think that their pantheon of gods was united in their love for humans and looked after them? Did monotheistic peoples ever think their one god was arbitrary and self-centered like the Hellenistic gods?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

Many people seem to think Billie Holiday and Ella Fitzgerald are rivals. But another artist's most famous songs, Doris Day also seem to include many of Ella's most famous renditions, such as Dream a Little Dream of Me, Stars Fell on Alabama, Cheek to Cheek etc. Was this all intentional?

Why do a lot of Doris Day's song sounds a lot like Ella Fitzgerald? Were their record companies trying to pit them off? I searched it and it seems that they recorded to very different labels. Perhaps in a effort to make the audiences judge who sang which rendition better? If so, who won? I also seem to notice that Ella doesn't speak much about the strange musical relationship between her songs and Ms Day's. I know she's not much of a talkative person, but I don't see any interview of neither one of them claiming they are friends either. Was there some sort of rivalry?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

How did tribes of Native Americans end up in the Philippines (macabebe)? And is it still possible which tribes they originated from today?

3 Answers 2019-12-02

How did Golden Age Muslims view Medieval Europe?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

Is it possible to identify the rank and military branch of a soldier from the Whiskey Rebellion based on his uniform in a painting?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-12-02

What was the point of trench warfare in WW1? Both sides probably knew that they were losing way more troops than was worth the small amount of land they gained. Why would they stay in the trenches when the troops there could be utilized much better in other situations for the war effort?

2 Answers 2019-12-02

Best of November Voting Thread

16 Answers 2019-12-02

Were statues in ancient Hindu temples painted?

I've found contradictory information online (e.g. https://www.quora.com/Were-temple-gopurams-in-South-India-originally-colorful-or-is-this-a-recent-change). Some say that the temples' statues would have been painted like ancient Greek and medieval European statues, but I didn't see them present any actual archaeological evidence of paint residue or anything like that. Others have said that painting statues didn't become common until the early modern period. I'm specifically interested in Hindu temples in Indonesia before the 11th century, but any evidence of ancient Hindu statues being painted would be of interest (preferrably archaelogical or historical evidence, not just conjecture based on current practice).

1 Answers 2019-12-02

How did the Medici family actually make their money?

I’ve tried looking this up, but all I can find is that they were bankers. And banking simply isn’t profitable if you’re just holding onto money and then giving it back to people. And loans seem like an even worse idea at a time when they couldn’t charge interest.

So I’m confused as to how they actually made the vast sums of money that they did. Has anyone figured this out?

2 Answers 2019-12-02

Were White Churches/Religions in America Complicit in Historical Injustices Towards Blacks?

I've been reading Righting Historical Injustice in Higher Education by Lionel K McPherson. McPherson is a philosopher, and not exactly a historian, but he basically states that institutions of high education weren't only complicit in historical injustice towards blacks, but exacerbated the problem (ie. discriminatory admissions practices). Both the GI Bill and affirmative action were policies to equalize socioeconomic/racial differences, with the catalyst being higher education; however, even as bastions for liberal ideals, McPherson says that these colleges/universities didn't do enough and even committed injustices.

I'm wondering if Religion/Churches were also places of 'moral' ideals, how they promoted justice or injustice, specifically in regards to race (especially, blacks).

I'm more concerned within the scope of the United States.

Thanks, so much!

1 Answers 2019-12-02

Unlike many other 19th century European nation states, Austria-Hungary was comprised of many different minority ethnic groups. To what extent did they think of themselves as united?

While many European countries were dominated by a single ethnic group (either because that ethnic group was the only one present, or because it forced minority groups to assimilate), the Austro-Hungarian Empire was comprised of many different groups which (in the 19th century) were granted some degree of autonomy and many managed to avoid forced assimilation. While Austrians were the largest minority group (at ~25% of the population in 1911), they didn't seem to be in a position to assimilate other minorities.

So my question is: Did the peoples of Austria-Hungary share any sense of national identity? If so, what was it based on? Did most people see themselves as part of their ethnic group first and Austro-Hungarian second? To what extent did this vary among particular ethnic groups?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

How did people preserve butter before refrigeration?

So, I know butter was an important product of at least scandinavian peasants, it was exported, used to pay taxes, and at least allegedly in one case paid as a stipend for someone to go to university. But I've never quite understood how these large amounts of butter (sometimes measured in barrels) was made to last. Was it simply salted sufficiently? Was it simply expected that butter would go rancid? Or is there something I'm missing?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

How important was Nazi-technology for the military development of the US after WWII?

So after considering, that the Messerschmitt ME-262 was the first jet-powered aircraft and also that Nazi scientist, most prominently Wernher von Braun, were a (maybe the?) major factor in the development of rocket and space technology amongst other technologies (eg firearms-technology, like the Sturmgewehr 44), I asked myself how important these "appropiated" technologies were for the further development of the US? Weren't the Nazi-made developments milestones of engineering and science, which still are seeking for comparable achievements since then?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

Why isn't Turkish a lingua franca?

With other empires like British, French, Russian, Spanish and Portuguese all of which have lingua francas in the countries and land they had.

But why didn't this happen with the ottoman empire and the turkish language?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

How did ships pay for supplies at foreign ports in the Age of Sail?

Did the host nation just send an annual bill to the other nation?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

A plot of many action movies is terrorists getting control over a nuclear weapons. Was there any actual examples of such an event in the real world?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

Are there any good examples of medieval building styles that aren't found in popular culture?

Medieval buildings found in popular culture tend to have the same look.

Was this, or similar styles popular across most of Europe at the time?

Are their any other examples of well known architectural styles that were used at the time, that are less well known to us today?

Was this style of building actually popular at the time, or has pop culture made it seem like this was the prevailing style?

I must confess that I have ulterior motives with this question, in that I'm into building models of castles and fantasy, and this is the style that pretty much everyone builds in to symbolize the period.

I'm hoping someone can point me in the right direction, so I can brings a new style the next time I build.

2 Answers 2019-12-02

When did last names become a thing?

I know the Romans had last names, and a bureaucracy to take those into account. But did other (later) cultures start using last names? When did John the Blacksmith become John Smith? How did that come about?

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2019-12-02

Has Hanukkah Observance Changed Due To The Commercialization of Christmas in the 20th Century?

Today Xmas stuff is everywhere in the US, from Coca Cola advertisements to television specials, and it is often secularized (Peanuts notwithstanding) with little mention of the birth of Jesus but quite a lot of Santa Clausi and reindeer. Has this widespread commercialization of Christmas had a real impact on Hanukkah observance?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

What was the difference between Cisalpine and Transalpine Gaul in the first century BCE?

I'm reading Adrian Goldsworthy's biography of Caeser and Transalpine & Cisalpine Gaul keep coming up.

What was the difference between the two regions? He mentions one was quite Roman-ised but were there any other differences? How would a typical Cisalpine Gaul view themselves compared to a Roman citizen?

Also, as a side note, why are the regions prefixed with Trans- and Cis-?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

(1) Is history a science? (2) What makes a good historian?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

In the Medieval Europe, there were the "Seven Liberal Arts" as major areas of study in universities. How much were instructors of different arts paid? Were there particular arts that were significantly better paid than other?

1 Answers 2019-12-02

Need help with ancient Graeco-Bactrian geography!

Hi everyone,

While indexing some ancient coins dating from the Graeco-Bactrian and Indo-Greek Kingdom, I came across these geographical names. I tried to google them but came no where close to understanding where they are situated, or whether or not they are names of places or of regions. Can someone help me out please?

I have trouble with the following geographical units:

  • Gandhara
  • Punjab
  • Paropamisadai
  • Sogdiana

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2019-12-02

1635 / 7255

Back to start