The Coptic Church holds that Saint Simon the Tanner moved the Mukattam Mountain during the reign of Caliph al-Muizz, is there any historical basis for this claim?

The story holds that Caliph al-Muizz al-Muizz concerted to Christianity, was baptized at the church of Saint Mercurius in Cairo in a baptismal font that continues to exist to this day, and which known today as the "Sultan's Baptistry", abdicated the throne in favor of his son, and spent the rest of his life in a monastery.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

How did the Germanic tribes establish their kingdoms in realms that were formerly controlled by other population groups ?

This is a topic that has long been bothering me, I learned about the history of the migrations and consequent establishment of kingdoms in former Roman territories . However, I wanted to ask how they were able to take control of the population so quickly. Let's take the Ostrogoths for example, a group of people that spoke a Germanic language (I mean the only written sources of Gothic stem from the Italy region ), took over Italy,the core of the Latin world. Which leads to my second question, how was the life for the Germanic and the "indigenous groups" at the time? I just can't wrap my head around how that worked.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

How did roman legions handle the engineering side of their duties on a day to day basis?

I know that legions were as much an engineering force as they were a military force, but what did that actually look like on a day to day basis? When building a road to press into distant territory, how many men were needed, and how much time? What tools and resources were needed? How many men with actual engineering education were needed in comparison to the men doing the physical labor? What is the most important thing to understand about legion engineering?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Ok so this might be a dumb question but in WW1 why didnt the americans use Winchester lever actions instead of the bolt actions they used?

I feel like lever actioms shoot faster and carry more bullets than the Springfields. Winchester was also a pretty big company (I think)

2 Answers 2019-08-21

Why was one nuked city not enough to make Japan surrender, but two achieved this?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Was King Arthur a Chivalrous Knight? Did he maintain any sorts of codes of chivalry?

Wanted to know this.

2 Answers 2019-08-21

Did Almohad (or other Berber) leaders use christian knights as bodyguards?

In the game Medieval Total War 2 the Moors (the games amalgamation of the Almohads and other Berber muslim factions who occupy North Africa and southern Iberia) have a unit of christian knights called the Christian Guard. Their in game description is somewhat vague:

“Being overthrown by their own palace guard is a risk faced by many rulers, and one way to prevent this is to hire guards from outside of their own cultures, who cannot hope to wield power themselves. Thus the Sultans of the Moors hire Christian Knights to protect them. Their prowess in battle is an added bonus."

I've tried searching for the Christian Guard online but little information outside of the game comes up. Was it actually common for leaders of the Almohads (or other Berber muslim factions) to hire christian knights as bodyguards? Are there any historical examples of this occurring?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

In what ways has the portrayal of court room trials in film changed the way actual trials are conducted? In other words, can the history of court room trials in the United States be divided between 'before film' and 'after film'?

In a recent video from LegalEagle - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gw5H36B1tJE - an attorney was interviewed and he mentioned how he thinks cinema and television has impacted the way trials are conducted.

I was wondering if there is any documentation from legal historians confirming or disproving the belief that film has influenced the way trials are now conducted.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Art style in Colonial America

what was the prominent art style pre-1776 USA especially leading up to declaring independence?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Were horses originally domesticated for food or transportation?

I've been wondering whether people looked at horses originally as a transportation method or if that idea came about after horses were domesticated for food or some other purpose. Are there any signs indicating which was the case?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

looking for pricing in 1820ish

hi im trying to write a "book" for the first time and an important part of it is how the main character get his starting money

the character originally lives in a fishing town (in New Hampshire) and my thought was that his mother (dead) would have found a pearl and put it in a cheap necklace I want him to get at least 100 dollars (yes I know that's a lot) but some less would be fine I've been searching for like 20 minutes and I can't find any pricing on pearls around that time can someone please help me find a reasonable size/price for the pearl or should I find some other way for him to get money at first

p.s. its a historical fiction about aliens causing world war 1 (yes it does sound dumb)

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Were Iraqi generals and Saddam Hussein at all hopeful they could fend off an attack by the US and its allies during the Gulf War?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Did Douglas Haig - the commander of the BEF during WWI who earned himself the nickname of 'Butcher Haig' and no doubt contributed to the creation of the popular phrase 'Lions led by Donkeys' - ever show remorse for the exponential loses of his operations?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-08-21

How much similar was administration of Byzantine Empire to that of European feudal states after the introduction and development of theme system? How much Roman was left intact?

After reading about the theme system and its development I have a feeling, that strategoi basically resembled feudal lords, having both civil and military authority over their themes.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Why did iron weaponry appear right after the bronze age collapse?

Why did iron weaponry appear right after the bronze age collapse? Apologies if this is wrong but didn't Iron weapons appear about a century after the bronze age collapse why non during the Bronze age when warfare was reasonably prelevant and large empires had the resources to study technology why not in the classical period when empires became large again?
My understanding is technology requires large empires to put forth investment to move forward not complete anarchy.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

In what ways could a woman in Early Modern Europe express their autonomy / agency? What did it mean - and to what extent was it possible - to be an "independent woman"?

My vague sense of the period is that socio-cultural restraints were generally stronger on upper class women who were expected to be exemplars of their sex, so I'm certainly more interested in that slice, although I don't want to cut out any interesting angles that this question might cover within the lower segments of society.

My impression also is that the most easy way to have "independence" was to be a widow, probably with a young son who wasn't able to control his fortune himself. To be sure I'm also not cutting out them (although open to correction if I'm wrong there), but what I'm really interested is in those who aren't granted it by unfortunate (or fortunate?) circumstance. That is to say, a young woman raised in a good family, makes a fairly average marriage, and begins motherhood, or, of course, a woman from a good family who remains unmarried yet wants to do more than join a nunnery, or be an old maid in her father's house.

What avenues were available to women such as these to maintain a sense of self and control within the expectations of the society she lived in?

2 Answers 2019-08-21

Did Ferdinand and Isabella know immediately that Columbus didn't reach India?

I've taken two history courses so far. One professor said they knew immediately because they recognized the captives he brought weren't Indians that they've traded with. The other said it took them about 10-15 years to realize they weren't Indians.

I was just curious about which it was and I wanted some expansion on it. Were King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella able to quickly recognize Columbus discovered a new society and/or land? Did this affect their decisions on creating more expeditions West?

If it took them a while, why did it take them so long? Weren't their cultures completely different?

If they did know immediately, how come Native Americans were consistently called "Indians" still?

Resources are greatly appreciated but not necessary.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

What were the minority populations of Finland prior to the Finnish Civil War, and what were their estimated population percentages and general group opinions prior to the war’s outbreak?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Kaiser Frederick III is frequently portrayed as a liberal reformer in favor of liberal democracy and opposed to militarism. He reigned for just 99 days before he died of throat cancer. How much of his reputation is deserved and were conservatives preparing to stonewall any attempts at reform?

As the second Kaiser of the unified German Empire, Frederick is said to have been a great admirer of the British system and wanted to bring some form of constitutional monarchy to Germany. He also reportedly planned on reigning as consorts with his British wife, Victoria (eldest daughter of Queen Victoria.)

There's also plenty of anecdotes around him attending Synagogues in a show of solidarity with Germany's Jewish community as well as pledging to never engage in war should he be Emperor despite his own success during the wars with Austria and France. It is thus popularly speculated that he might have been able to avoid the First World War (and by extension the Second) had he reigned for longer.

Frederick was a heavy smoker and died of throat cancer just 99 days into his reign. His final words are alleged to have been:

"What's happening to me? I must get well again; I have so much to do!"

But how much of this reputation is deserved? His father Wilhelm I and his son Wilhelm II were very conservative. Further, the German Empire itself was a conservative coalition of Kingdoms, Principalities and Duchies corralled by arch conservative Otto Von Bismark. Was he a reformer as much as these stories suggest? Or is this merely a seductive "what-if" given what happened to Germany during the 20th Century? If he was planning on reforms, was resistance to Frederick planned? Were the conservative powers of Germany taking steps to protect the Imperial system as well as their personal rights and privileges should Frederick attempt to enact reform?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

I know that the "Buffalo Soldiers" served during the American Indian wars. But is their a record of any serving specifically in Red Cloud's War?

I noticed that the 9th and 10th Cavalry Regiments were both formed in or around 1866 which is roughly when Red Cloud's War started. However, Red Cloud's War was fought mostly in Wyoming and I can only find records of black soldiers fighting in the Texas theater of the Indian Wars. So did the buffalo soldiers not participate in Red Cloud's war and if so do we know why not? Considering that Red Cloud gave the US a run for their money you'd think the army would want as many capable soldiers fighting his coalition as possible.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Do we have any idea of how the aztecs would have told their own myths?

Aztec mythology is full of blood and sacrifices and their religion was too. However, the hindu mythology also has some very violent aspects, Kali could easily be mistaken for a demon, Shiva is a god of destruction, but when we hear the stories from hindu people we realize that Kali is more terrifying than evil, and that Shiva's role is to destroy so that there can be rebirth.

So I wonder, how would the aztecs have told their myths?, how would they have explained their rituals?, how would that change our perception?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

What was the basis of statehood in medieval Europe?

I'm reading a book and the author wrote: "And in the middle ages it was having your own laws, and not your own language, that meant international acknowledgement of a nation/people and it's statehood and for that reason it was not politically significant of what ethnicity the [rulers] were, [...]. The [old state] with it's legal heritage continued to exist."

I'm curious how accurate that is and if there are any nuances I ought to be aware of before accepting the statement at face value. I am also aware the modern concept of a nation didn't exist at the time, but I presume people still had a sense of ethnic belonging (i.e. Saxons, Normans, Franks, Germans).

​

For the record, the book isn't written in English and that was my own translation of the text. I also deliberately obscured what polity is being talked about because I'm interested more in the general principle than the specific example and I want to mitigate any potential nationalistic impulses. In so far as it matters, the relevant timeframe is Christian/Catholic Europe around the year 1000, give or take a century or two.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

As a Palestinian-American, I've realized a significant lack of Arab authorship in the Arts coming out of the Levant prior to the Islamic Golden Age. Why is this, considering Jerusalem's global importance?

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Did Britain have any interest in continuing its presence in Egypt/Suez Canal after India achieved independance?

Seeing as how India was the main reason for controling Egypt, British intervention in Egyptian politics seems unnecessary.

1 Answers 2019-08-21

Short Answers to Simple Questions | August 21, 2019

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.

  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.

  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.

  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.

  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.

  • Academic secondary sources are prefered. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).

  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

36 Answers 2019-08-21

⯇ 1807 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start