Do we actually lack evidence that William Shakespeare existed or is that just a myth perpetuated by high school English teachers?

3 Answers 2019-04-01

Where did the steriotype of the typical redneck come from?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Carthaginian Use of "Tall Horses"

Why is so much made of the elephants used in the Punic wars while there is almost nothing written on the usage of giraffes? I know that the walls in North Africa were specifically made tall enough that an army couldn't just use giraffes to scale them - but surely mainland Italy didn't do that?

Did they all freeze in the Alps, or was their use simply too embarrassing to be discussed much amongst Roman Historians?

Is there any further reading available on the military use of giraffes?

2 Answers 2019-04-01

What did feminists in 1979 think of the election of Margaret Thatcher - first female PM of the UK but a conservative?

What did 1970s feminists, particularly left-wing ones, think of the first woman to be elected to be PM of one of the major Western Powers being elected via the Conservatives rather than Labour?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Is there any surviving art from Ancient Greece/Rome that is bad? Why did only good art seem to survive?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

What is considered poorly equipped in World War Two?

I've been thinking about this because, in my research, the Japanese infantry man in World War Two is considered to be poorly equipped, while them having great small arms such as the Nambu light machine guns and reliable and accurate Arisakas, along with the effective "knee mortars" in combat. So what is really "poorly equipped" in world war two, and is it a myth that the Japanese were "poorly equipped".

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Considering that Athena was a goddess of war, how did the warlike ancient Spartans feel about their main rivals the Athenians having Athena as their patron deity?

Given that Athena was (like Ares) a goddess of war in addition to a goddess of wisdom, was the Athenian patronage to Athena ever a sticking point for Spartans, either as a point of jealousy or creating a feeling of kinship(however begrudging)?

For example, I've noticed that in the real world, many Muslims feel a kinship with Christians despite the stark differences in their faiths (belief in the trinity being the root of the disparity of doctrine), referring to them as 'people of the book', and considering them to be likeminded but misguided. This is as opposed to how many Christians and Jews consider Muslims to be hijacking their deity and religious traditions. Naturally, these two sentiments are not native to either end of that religious disparity. This being a modern precedent, it makes me curious as to whether this type of thing occurs in polytheistic religions as well, namely the Spartans and Athenians.

What's the scoop?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

What would it have been like to be a spectator at the games in a Roman coliseum?

Asking again without the title error.

We have pretty good ideas of what the games would have been like in Roman coliseums, but what would it have been like to be a fan in the stands? How different would it have been from modern arena sports? I imagine there would have been plenty of food and drink, but were there streakers running across the sand pit behind the gladiators? Were there ever fights in the crowds? Did they do the wave? What would life in the stands have been like for the average game-goer in the Roman era?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Why was there a spike in popularity of the name Jacob in the late 1600s?

I was looking at the name Jacob in the Google Ngram Viewer, and it shows a large spike in the late 1600’s. What is the reason for this?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Did Great Britain deteriorate as a military power between WW1 and WW2

In WW1 Great Britain had the flagship military for the Entente, and had tremendous success against the Central Powers.

WW2, they seem to have taken a back seat, with their contributions being grossly limited merely to airforce, information, and navy, unable to establish a meaningful ground presence in Europe, or effectively wage war against the Nazis man-to-man (so to speak). Only after the Soviets and USA managed to break the German lines did the British manage to contribute directly in conventional ways to the war effort.

1 Answers 2019-04-01

What's the culture impact of various Germanic people in Western Europe/Southern Europe/Northern Africa who no longer exist?

By this is mean groups like Vandals, Goths, Burgundians, etc, which are no longer extant ethnic groups, but before and after the collapse the Western Roman empire, existed and often ruled places outside of what we would consider 'Germanic'. Were they just a kind of a ruling elite, or did they leave a lasting impact on the culture?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Was banditry ever the exception rather than the rule in premodern Europe?

Were there periods of time when a traveler could have made it from England to Portugal, Austria, or Greece with little need to fear banditry?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Band of Brothers has an episode about replacement members of E Company following the Normandy Invasion. How often were soldiers assigned to be replacements vs going fresh units? How was that decision made?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Why do we associate the following melodic pattern with the Far East? (4/4) ||DDDDC-C-|A-A-C---||

You can find this in everything from Looney Tunes to Family Guy -- where did it come from?

1 Answers 2019-04-01

Why are Ancient Egyptian gods sometimes depicted differently across different artworks?

In various artworks I have seen, there have been changes in the attire of the same gods. This is seen with Hathor as sometimes she is depicted with a white dress and multi-coloured headdress, yet in others she is wearing different dresses. Is this simply a change of attire? Or is there a deeper meaning? With some other gods the differences are a lot greater, how can you easily identify which god is which?

Thanks.

1 Answers 2019-03-31

I heard that Jim Jones, of Jonestown fame, sold monkeys to raise money for his church, what other fundraising methods did he use?

1 Answers 2019-03-31

Did all dinosaurs go extinct from the meteor?

Dumb question, but obviously the meteor was a world catastrophic event that wiped out a very large population and made the dinosaurs go extinct. But did they ALL go extinct?

The modern bird is said to have evolved from the dinosaur, so some of them had to have survived, or at least evolved enough to survive the meteor. Which one was it?

2 Answers 2019-03-31

On two-seat fighter aircraft (such as the F-4 Phantom/F-14 Tomcat), what does the RIO/WSO do in terms of weapons?

(Sorry if this is the wrong subreddit to post this question; if it is, please let me know.)

1 Answers 2019-03-31

How did tribal European lands like the Vikings and Slavic tribes "civilise" and become kingdoms and more complex societies?

1 Answers 2019-03-31

The military rank "(field) marshal" has existed since the Middle Ages, and been used by dozens of militaries, but not the U.S. Army. Instead the equivalent "Five Star General" is used: why is the American military unique in not using "marshal"?

2 Answers 2019-03-31

How did sailors relax at desolate ports during WWII?

Things must have gotten pretty boring if your stuck on a ship or in a burned out port. What could a sailor do?

1 Answers 2019-03-31

When did the practice of putting coins on graves start becoming a common practice?

1 Answers 2019-03-31

There is no need to panic. You aren't crazy. /r/AskHistorians is having a very, very normal last day of March!

Hello everyone!

For those who have been here at least a year, you probably have caught onto what is going on by now. For our newer users, while here in /r/AskHistorians we take things seriously 364 days a year, we take April Fools just as seriously too, and use it as an opportunity to let our hair down and get rid of all those jokes that we've been holding back the rest of the year!

This year, once the clock hit 0000, 1 April at /r/AskHistorians HQ in Kiribati, we returned to our 'Greatest Hits', and /r/AskFakeHistorians 2.0 has been in full swing for several hours now! The flairs have the privilege of a heads up to get in on the fun too, but everyone is welcome to partake, of course, and for the next day or so, Answers may be written as long, elaborate jokes that are not real history. We invite you to partake (or not) in the fun, but ensure that you follow the rules and guidelines laid out below, as the moderators aren't going to be taking the day off.

The number one rule of /r/AskFakeHistorians is your answer must be obviously fake. The rules for the event are designed to help keep that from happening, but in general, keep that spirit of things in mind. We want this to be a fun and entertaining experience for everyone, which includes the readers, not just you laughing at people believing your BS. So as you write and post, keep these in mind:

  • Please show judgement and good taste: The point is to get crazy, but that doesn't mean everything is fair game. We aren't going to be making an exhaustive list of what is out of bounds, but we hope that it is for the most case obvious. That doesn't mean that the villains of history are out of bounds - Hitler clones, anyone? - but it does mean you shouldn't be writing the secret history of how they were actually the good guys.
  • Participation is Voluntary: If you just want your question answered normally, including [SERIOUS] in your title will keep it off-limits, and our flairs pinky promise that even if they don't have time today, they will do their best to find time to return to it once the event is over.
  • Don't Jump Into the Archives: Threads posted earlier than 0000 EDT, or 0400 UTC, are off limits. Please don't post joke responses in anything older than that.
  • Poll and Example Seeking Rules are Relaxed: These rules exist for technical reasons, related to their impact on efficient moderation. Not being concerned that answers are correct, we will not be enforcing them today, with, of course, the usual base rules about Soapboxing, Civility, and such remaining in place.
  • Real Questions Only: This isn't /r/AskFantasyHistorians. Making up fake history in the question ruins the fun! IF you need inspiration for a question to ask, try visiting the archives and reposting a classic. We can see how the two answers compare!
  • Answers must be obviously fake: If you are writing something that is basically real, just with subtle tweaks a non-expert would never notice, that is not going to fly. To be sure, the first round of this proved that there are some really gullible people out there, and riffing off of real history is not only allowable, but encouraged, but make sure that things get obviously ridiculous by the end of the post! And of course, keep in mind that what is obvious to you might not be to a layperson. Make sure you write with that in mind.
  • Sources are required: They might be highly suggested usually, but here they are required. They also must not be real, or must be obviously inappropriate for the topic at hand - for instance citing novels or films as if they are non-fiction academic sources.
  • Listen to the Mods: We will be giving a warning when the day is at an end with a post sometime in the middle of April 1st UTC-4 to 'turn things off'. All threads posted before then will remain fair game, but thread posted after that point will be back to normal and joke responses removed. We may also make periodic updates to this thread during the day, so please check back from time to time.
  • Edit Your Answers: ALL answers, after the day ends, must be edited with an April Fools disclaimer. Those that aren't will be removed if we see them.
  • Keep META Discussion to This Thread: Feel free to talk about the event, or offer META commentary on answers in this thread. Feel free to share how much of a killjoy you are here, as well if you would like to complain about what is going on today.

If you are still a bit unsure of things, and want a few examples, I linked a few of my own as examples above, but we also have a complete archive on the Wiki which you can peruse for inspiration. Not all are going to reflect the revised guidelines as there are changes from 1.0 however, so these ones in particular we would highlight as what we are really looking for:

  • /r/AskHistorians/comments/21vjle/were_there_any_notable_independence_or_insurgency/cggxjwc/
  • /r/AskHistorians/comments/21y0ka/from_the_mid_1800s_to_the_late_1800_the_noth/cghj8q0/
  • /r/AskHistorians/comments/21w9oa/suppose_i_am_a_17th_or_18th_century_caribbean/cgh4pks/
  • /r/AskHistorians/comments/21vnwq/did_any_works_of_literature_from_persia_transmit/cggxpwf/
  • /r/AskHistorians/comments/21uybe/what_us_veteran_has_fought_in_the_most_wars/cghacqx/

14 Answers 2019-03-31

Why did US troops commit more crimes in Vietnam than they did in both world wars?

Young American men were drafted in WWI, WWII, and the Vietnam conflict, yet their presence in Vietnam was far more brutal. In both world wars, Americans weren't using flamethrowers on German villages or going into rural areas mass-slaughtering civilians like they did in Vietnam. If it was both mainly made up of young drafted men, why was their attitude different in Vietnam?

1 Answers 2019-03-31

From Folklore: "Fee fy foh fum, I smell the blood of an English man." What was the theory of blood-smells at the time? Were other regions/gender combinations considered to have unique smelling blood?

1 Answers 2019-03-31

⯇ 2039 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start