Saturday Showcase | February 16, 2019

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2019-02-16

Is Strasserism far-left or far-right?

Strasserism is a strand of Nazism but it seems to have more in common with communism and socialism, even its racial policy is based on ideas of rejecting capitalism rather than eugenics. So would it be consider a far-left ideology?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

Who decided who was the solider at the forefront of formations/line infantry in ancient times and in the colonial period? Was there a logic for any typical individual to be in the front/back of a formation at any given time?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

Did Plato invent Atlantis whole-cloth, or are there possible sources of inspiration?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

In the bombing raids of WWII, when the bombers were defending themselves from the fighters, were they just raining down millions of bullets on the populace below? Or would air currents disperse them with little impact?

3 Answers 2019-02-16

What repurcussions did the Chola invasions of Sriwijaya have on the Malayan archiepelgo?

Was it serious at all? Many argue that the invasion was merely just a small series of raids on coastal towns.

1 Answers 2019-02-16

World War Two is known in popularly portrayed in Western Cinema as being primarily fought by white men, yet it had huge populations of Colonial soldiers fighting on the side of Great Britain and France. How were those veterans treated upon return to their homeland?

Follow up question: how did the veteran treatment compare to those returning after World War One?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

Was PTSD common for ancient warriors/soldiers?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

How did seemingly well connected and educated figures in the early beginnings of the Third Reich buy into conspiracies founded in racism?

I’ve been watching a few docu-series on the political nature of the National Socialist party and it seems that most of their brain washing of the German people relied on propaganda and false information. My question really has to do with the earlier figureheads of the party and their Aryan belief system. Did they have any factual grounds to believe that “lesser races” had corrupted and infiltrated their government and way of life? Or was it a sense of social misinformation of that day and age? Was anti-semitism a popular notion among German people of the time? Why?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

When “the people of Riga” wrote to Pope Boniface VIII to complain about the Teutonic Knights, as Victoria Finlay says in Jewels, who were “the people of Riga”? Presumably most of “the people of Riga” were illiterate, so what did she mean by this?

“They” wrote the letter in 1299 and Finlay’s source is Friedrich Bunge’s Liv-, esth- und curländisches Urkundenbuch nebst Regesten, p. 180.

1 Answers 2019-02-16

A history professor of mine made the claim that President FDR's father made his fortune in the opium trade in China, and that the United States was the second largest opium supplier to China, how accurate are these claims?

2 Answers 2019-02-16

Chess is famous for its incredible spread across the world. How did it become standardized internationally?

2 Answers 2019-02-16

What would happen to a tank if was damaged in battle during WWII?

Let’s say that your tank’s tracks were snapped, your gun was broken and you could not fire, your turret was jammed and could not move, your engine had holes in it, or something else.

Would the crew attempt to repair the tank after it was safe, would it be abandoned, would it be taken back to base to be repaired? What type of damages could be repaired by just the crew of any on the battlefield?

How would different things be repaired? Could the crew repair more complex things like engines?

What about holes? Could the crew weld a piece of metal to cover them up or something?

Is the repair process similar between countries? Has is remained the same from World War II to today?

Also, what would the crew do if they did have to leave their tank? Would they be able to go back to base and get a new one eventually?

3 Answers 2019-02-16

Trying to locate historians specializing in a specific ethnic group, culture, area, period for genealogical research? (Louisiana)

Hello historians, thanks for reading and I hope this is ok here. I'm doing research for my partner's family and his great grandfather has a mysterious background based in the Redbone settlement that developed in the Sabine area of the Louisiana Neutral Zone.

The neutral zone was a strip of Louisiana owned by neither the US nor Spain, and as a result became a No Man's Land. President John Quincy Adams called it "America's back door" because after the abolition of slave importation, slave ships came there. Outlaws, runaway slaves and anyone running from something came there. It was truly a Wild West sort of environment and feuds, murders, duels and shoot outs were common place even after the land became part of Louisiana officially.

One of the peoples to settle there were called Redbones - ethnically mixed people that are considered to likely be white European, African and native American, though at the time they claimed none of those. They were an insulated community that were considered warrior like. They frequently fought among themselves but would band together to protect each other from outside influence. There were famous feuds involving them, including one day long shoot out that was instigated by a white man approaching a Redbone girl.

My spouse's great grandfather lived in this area and from everything we are finding, his mother was a Redbone and his father was a white man. The family story is that the mother was murdered by the Klan, but that may have mutated over the years.

I've been working on this for awhile and feel like I've reached an impasse for official records. There's no record of this murder, or where his great grandfather was raised. I know this is a long shot but I feel like my best bet is someone maybe local, or who has studied this area and /or the Redbones. Thanks for reading.

1 Answers 2019-02-16

During the Sixties Scoop, were social workers required to provide any reason for taking a child away, or was their race the only reason required?

Just to be clear, even if a reason was required, I don’t think that justifies what happened. I would assume that the reasons given were not legitimate. I’m just curious about the process, and whether a “reason” was even required.

1 Answers 2019-02-16

Is there a link between the Teutons and the Teutonic order?

In the game age of empires 2, there is a civilisation called the Teutons. Their unit is the Teutonic knight which is from the Teutonic order. After some research, apparently the Teutons were a Germanic tribe documented by the Romans. Is there any link beside the name?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

Is there a pattern to previously harmless tribes conquering vast lands, or am I seeing one where there isn't any?

I am seeing a pattern where a group of previously seen as harmless and undeveloped tribes very suddenly become more or less united and such a force that they conquer a large part of the world in a very short time.

The three examples that came to my mind are Germans conquering Europe, the Arabs conquering the Middle East and North Africa, and the Mongols conquering the Eurasian steppe. I also thought about the Indo-Europeans and Slavs, but am not knowledgeable enough about the subject to draw any parallels.

So is there an actual pattern or mechanism that causes this or am I just overthinking it?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

How comparable were the living conditions of Irish immigrants in the United States during their forced immigration due to the potato famine, to the African American slaves imported to the US?

My friend and I recently had a dispute. He says that the lives of the Irish immigrants in America during the potato famine were worse than the lives of African American slaves. Is he right or wrong?

1 Answers 2019-02-16

Did the English really excelled in archery or is contemporary historiography too much Anglocentric?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-02-16

WW2 Gunstock Rations?

In an episode of “Band of Brothers”, a character is trapped in German-controlled territory and hides out in a farm. There is a scene where he opens what seems to be a compartment on the stock of his rifle and take out something to eat (it always looked like a sausage to me). Were rations like that hidden in gunstocks? And what were they?

1 Answers 2019-02-15

How could have the Ottoman Empire block trade routes to Asia despite there being no Suez Canal, a better question is HOW they blocked trade (leading to the European discovery of America)

1 Answers 2019-02-15

After the fall of Tenochtitlan, how was the rest of Mexico conquered?

From what I understand the forces that fought the Aztec and besieged Tenochtitlan were mostly composed of rebellious vassals of the Aztec, with only a small amount of Spanish soldiers. Once the Aztec were defeated, how did the Spanish go about defeating the rest of the Mexican tribes?

1 Answers 2019-02-15

Why didn’t the South/Central American city state and civilization spread into Northern America prior to the Europeans?

1 Answers 2019-02-15

How much damage did one bullet from a world war 2 aircraft do to another aircraft?

1 Answers 2019-02-15

The Wikipedia article on the Father of the House says that the UK House of Commons' one inherited the responsibility of conducting the election of the Speaker from the Clerk, who isn't entitled to speak and had to do it silently, after some kind of incident in the 1971 election. What was it?

1 Answers 2019-02-15

⯇ 2115 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start