how did we decide when the numbers go 2 digits?

Let me explain:the concept of going to 2 digits is weird to me: how it was decided that after 9 which is 1 digit, to 10 then 11 which are 2?

There is kind of the same thing in ancient Hebrew where the letter י marks 10,and the letter א marks 1,so 11 is יא If the answer is so obvious please be patient and explain, I'm just curious :)

1 Answers 2022-06-23

Is Pope Joan a true story?

1 Answers 2022-06-23

Did The Eastern Roman Empire Protect Ancient Greek and Roman Texts?

I've been reading Herodotus recently and it got me wondering how so many ancient texts survived through the centuries.

Of course the Eastern Roman Empire didn't collapse until 1453 but did this play a role in protecting a lot of documents that would otherwise have been lost?

If not then how did these texts survive?

I'd be interested in hearing if there were any libraries or academics in the Eastern Roman Empire that helped to preserve these texts into the Medieval period.

1 Answers 2022-06-23

"Courage" by Dorothy Cameron Disney: an obcure American WWII Story in Chinese middle school literature textbook that influenced a generation. Anyone know more about this piece?

I went to middle school and high school in China. Back in the 90s and early 2000s, the textbooks in Chinese schools were very standardized. That means almost everyone in my generation knows a World War 2 story about an American soldier who parachuted to Normandy, since most of us use the same textbook.

The original Chinese can be found here: https://baike.baidu.com/item/%E5%8B%87%E6%B0%94/5621005

The interesting thing is: no one in China or anywhere seems to know if the story is real or fictional, where did the author got her source, how did it end up in a Chinese government sanctioned middle school literature textbook, etc.

Given how much impact it has made on a whole generation of Chinese population, there is almost no information about the origin of this story, its authors background, its authencity, we can't even find the original English version on the internet.

The title of story is Courage (maybe not a literal translation of its original title), by a rather obscure American author by the name of Dorothy Cameron Disney, according to a Chinese Reddit type website.

https://zhidao.baidu.com/question/135029980047099685/answer/2833614875.html

https://zhidao.baidu.com/question/153519246/answer/458586293.html

The story is set in France during World War II. The author, DC Disney, a wartime journalist, heard the story from a unnamed solider during a lunch party in England. The unnamed solider was parachuted to a wrong location during the invasion. He found a farm house nearby and its owners, a French couple, were willing to hide him from the Germans.

Unfortunately, the Germans spotted the parachute as he landed and they searched the farm house and found the American parachuter. The French man was summarily executed on the spot as a warning to others who dare to offer assistance to the Americans. The execution left the woman a widow and an orphan child.

The Germans, however, were not sure what to do with American. So they lock him up in a small cabin. The American soldier managed to escape from the log cabin and ran deep into the forrest. The Germans got a hint of this and started to search the forrest at night.

The American solider, not knowing where to go or hide, made a stunning decision: go back to that same farm house again. With the dead body still laying on the ground, the American asked the French woman, "can you hide me?" And she replied: "of course! Be quick."

Hiding in a cellar for three days, according to the story, the American soldier was regrouped with his unit. During these three days, the German soldiers did not even bother to search the farm house again, beacuae "they cannot possibly comprehend the spiritual and moral height of the people that they are dealing with." (my cheesy paraphrase from a potentially none literal translation).

At the end of the story, the author expressed her fascination about the two characters of this "true story", that both the French woman and American soldier were truly courageous. (At the point, the teacher will ask the meaning of courage and why is the American soldier courageous etc...)

After almost twenty years, having lived in a few country by now, I am still deeply in love with this story. As a teacher myself, I feel the urge to share this story with my own students. Honestly, I don't care if it is real or fictional: this is one of the few memorable pieces of literatures we used to read that is related to America and its people. Given the vast (and widening) ideological and political differences China and the US have today, this story seemed to be taken out of the textbook for good (I need to double confirm it though). However, I adore this story so much that I hate to see it fade away. So I decided to write this long post and hopefully we keep this memory alive by finding more about this piece.

Is there anyone who knows more about this story? How about its author, Dorothy Cameron Disney, is she even the author? Was it published in the US in any form? Can we find an original English version?

Thank you.

2 Answers 2022-06-23

Are modern Irish people at all related to the Celts (Gauls) conquered by the Romans under Julius Caesar?

I was reading about Caesar’s conquest of the Celts in Gaul. At the time, I believe, Ireland was mostly uninhabited. So, I assume that these are the same Celts who immigrated there. However, I’m not sure and wanted to ask an expert.

I understand that Agricola, the Roman governor of Britain, is said to have employed a Celtic chieftain — Túathal Techtmar in Irish myth — who later conquered Ireland.

1 Answers 2022-06-23

Prior to Nazis/Hitler, what groups or individuals were mostly commonly invoked as examples of the evil that humans are capable of?

There are, of course, many examples of evil and depravity in history, but which examples would have been the most widely known? I imagine that different examples would be well known in different regions, and that the global infamy of the Nazis has a lot to do with the global information environment that arose in the 20th century. I'd love to learn about any examples from any era and any place!

2 Answers 2022-06-23

Doctrinally how did different navies view the role of the Heavy Cruiser during the interwar period & how did that compare to their actual usage during World War II?

Light cruisers seem to have a clear purpose in fleet design but I'm struggling to understand what heavy cruisers role was meant to be other than to hunt & sink light cruisers.

2 Answers 2022-06-23

We found the long lost love letters my grandfather (Pearl Harbor survivor ---> USS New Orleans) sent before and throughout the war. What do we do with them?

My mother was never allowed to read them and then they disappeared.

A stranger told us they were selling their home and found boxes of these.

Her letters were of course blown up when their ship suffered a near fatal blow in the Solomons, but what we have from him is absolutely tear-jerking.

It's just some 18-year-old kid writing about how he hates the Navy and wants to get home to his love so she can "fulfill her promise".

Then, after the attack, he is all-grown-up and says "I have seen the first battle and I hope to see the last".

5 Answers 2022-06-23

I had an econ professor that argued that the FDIC is never needed simply because it exists. People feel reassured and therefore don't make bank runs. Has the FDIC ever had to pay out a claim? What were the circumstances behind that?

1 Answers 2022-06-23

Few Chinese caravans/travelling traders made in through the Parthian Empire, so how would that be done? Did they sell everything they had at the nearest Parthian city and the Parthians would later sell it themselves? Was it a common practice to to not allow traders past a certain point elsewhere?

Also assuming this was a somewhat common practice to not allow caravans and traders passed a certain point, did that encourage some traders to “smuggle” their wares through a place to sell it themselves elsewhere?

1 Answers 2022-06-23

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | June 23, 2022

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

8 Answers 2022-06-23

Why do women from the 1920’s era all seem to have rounder faces despite being slim?

1 Answers 2022-06-23

In Edo Japan, blind men were allowed to join the blind men guild under the condition that they be employed as a musician, masseuse or acupuncturist. What are cases of a different physical disability being tied legally or traditionally to a particular profession? How were they enforced or managed?

Edit: not in Japan specifically, but anywhere in the world.

1 Answers 2022-06-23

Is there any historical instance of a an aircraft aircraft carrier getting sunk or hit in a surface action? As in hit by another ship's guns.

In combat with the enemy ofcorse. I always read about carriers getting hit by enemy planes or submarines. But I can't recall any instance of an enemy surface fleet getting an opportunity to directly engage a carrier in traditional naval warfare.

2 Answers 2022-06-23

How did settlers decide what bank of the river to start building their city on?

1 Answers 2022-06-23

During the January 6 hearings, multiple people have called the U.S. constitution 'divinely inspired'. How old is this idea and where did it originate? Did any of the men who wrote the constitution ever call it 'divinely inspired'?

2 Answers 2022-06-23

What books are great for learning more about Abraham Lincoln and his presidency?

I am looking for reliable books to study concerning Abraham Lincoln and his presidency. I'm deeply interested in him and how he handled himself and the American Civil War.

1 Answers 2022-06-23

Why did Tip O’Neill never run for the Presidency?

O’Neill had a long career in the congress and rose to rank of speaker of the house. I know that most speakers don’t become President (Polk is the only man to serve as speaker and president so far) but I assume many speakers wish they could get elected President. Is there a historical consensus on why O’Neill never made the attempt?

1 Answers 2022-06-23

Why did the nazis put “work sets you free” on the entrance to Auschwitz?

1 Answers 2022-06-23

While searching for the symbolism of daisies, I came across repeated claims that there exists a Celtic legend in which god(s) would sprinkle daisies after the death of a child, in order to bring comfort to the grieving parents. Is this true?

I tried googling various phrases in search of the supposed legend, but could find no source for these claims. All I found were countless flower store articles repeating the same thing while explaining the symbolism of daisies. So, is there actually a legit story or legend behind this? Or is it just a false statement being repeated uncritically, for the sake of marketing?

Thank you so much to whoever answers; let’s just say I have personal reasons for being invested in the truth of this.

1 Answers 2022-06-23

What impact, if any, has Fenway Park's Green Monster had on the career statistics or tactics of the Red Sox?

1 Answers 2022-06-23

How do historians find people to translate documents?

For example, let's say you find a letter from Archimedes written in 250 BCE Greece about some new math discovery he's made. If you don't understand Greek at all, you now need to find someone who is not just fluent in Greek, but fluent in Greek from 250 BCE and can contextualize whatever math stuff he's written about. That seems like such a niche person to find, I feel like that'd be like finding a needle in a hay stack. How do people actually go about finding the people they need to translate these kinds of documents?

2 Answers 2022-06-22

When I was a kid someone from my local historical society told me my hometown was almost made my states capitol or was being considered for it. I recently started doing some research though and dates aren't lining up. Was I lied to or was my hometown actually considered for the states capitol?

So i grew up in the town of tower Minnesota, a small mining town in st Louis County in Minnesota located of the mesabi iron range. When the town was founded it was a fairly major town as it was tied to another town right next door called soudan (breitung township) which was home to a successful underground iron mine called the soudan underground mine. The two towns are technically separate but due to proximity and history (tower was apperently the town where all the businesses and alot of miners lived while soudan was considered on mining company land and wasn't allowed to have any businesses but had some people live there) the towns are kindof considered to be packaged together by most of us living here if that makes sense. We have a local historical society and as a kid my school interacted with them alot. At one point one of the historians there had told me that our town of tower and soudan had been considered as an option to be the state capitol of Minnesota instead of st paul because for a time the town was really successful from the mining industry. He provided more details but it was quite a while ago and I don't remember or didn't get all the details of why we were considered or why we didn't get chosen, I was young at the time and so I don't remember all the context he gave us but the fact always stuck with me since. I recently started doing some research Into it for an alternate history project I'm working on but I don't seem to be able to find anything that confirms the story I had been told growing up. In fact everything I've found seems to indicate that I may have been given false information. I was told that the town of tower was almost chosen as the state capitol, but the problem is the town of tower wasn't founded until the 1880s whereas Minnesota became a state in the 1850s and st paul was named the capitol since then, and from what I could tell from simple Google and Wikipedia st paul had been the capitol of the territory of Minnesota even before it was a state. I'm worried I was lied to or given false information but I don't want to immediately write it off because Maybe at some point the state was considering moving the capital or something (I don't know of that can happen) but I don't seem to be able to find anything else. Even though I'm doing this research for something involving alternate history I'm not asking for what ifs or what it would be like or anything like that. I need help because I was told one thing while growing up but I now have doubts about the historical "fact" I had held with me all these years. I'm not asking what if it happened, I need to know if there was ever a point where my small mining town had actually been in the consideration as a spot for the state capitol?

1 Answers 2022-06-22

What happened to opium?

Opium used to be THE drug that everyone took in the Victorian era, at least, as far as I can tell. Yet, nowadays, it's fallen into obscurity. What caused this shift?

1 Answers 2022-06-22

What economic system did the Persian Achaemenid Empire use?

In Herodotus, the following piqued my interest:

They say that when the herald had delivered this message, Cyrus questioned the Hellenes who were with him, asking them who were these Lacedaemonians who would send such a command to him, and how many of them were there. When he heard their response, he said to the Spartan herald, "I have never yet feared any men who have a place at the center of the city set aside for meeting together, swearing false oaths, and cheating one another, and if I live long enough, the Lacedaemonians will have troubles of their own about which to converse, rather than those of the Ionians." Cyrus thus insulted the Hellenese because of their custom of setting up agoras in their cities for the purpose of buying and selling, which is unknown among the Persians, who do not use markets and, indeed, have no such place as an agora in any of their cities.

Did the Persians have a command economy? Was produce and food distributed by the state? I know they had money since I've seen it. Were individuals permitted to own any?

1 Answers 2022-06-22

212 / 7255

Back to start