Alexander and the ancient Macedonians Greek?

So I was reading about Alexander and I’ve seen large fights in the comment section over whether or not the Macedonians were are very much separate group or were culturally Greek. So what’s the historical view in this

2 Answers 2019-01-19

I have read the claim that "Sanskrit has 100 times the number of manuscripts of Latin and Ancient Greek combined". How much validity is there to this? If it is true, what precisely might be meant by "number of manuscripts"?

After searching around for the source, it seems that I read this claim in the back cover blurb of my copy of Peter Scharf's Ramopakhyana - The Story of Rama in the Mahabharata: A Sanskrit Independent-Study Reader. This is a generally well respected text for students of Sanskrit, but whether that means there's any validity to what's written on the back cover, I couldn't say. Are there any other sources which back up this claim?

In addition, if it is true, I was wondering what exactly might be meant be "number of manuscripts". Number of surviving manuscripts? Estimated number ever composed? Etc.

2 Answers 2019-01-19

Racism in the ancient world

Was there racism in the ancient world or is it phenomena of newer times? If yes, was there a difference between different cultures?

1 Answers 2019-01-19

(WW2) What actual proof do we have that Hitler certainly killed himself if no one ever saw his body?

It seems extremely plausible that Hitler moved to Hungary to live out his days there... Plus there have been claims of people seeing a withered old Hitler when he would be aged around his 90s...

1 Answers 2019-01-19

Why have so many countries installed large statues of Buddha?

I was looking at the list of tallest statues in the world, and so surprised to see that China, Myanmar, Japan, Thailand dominate the Top 10 with enormous Buddha statues. Is there a reason why large statues would have been erected in so many different countries?

1 Answers 2019-01-19

I read/heard somewhere that the main reason why the Catholic church forbid its priests to marry was to stop any descendants from claiming inheritance. Is there any truth to it?

1 Answers 2019-01-19

If Christian kingdoms sent missionaries to the New World to spread Christianity there in the post-Columbus era, why didn't Muslim nations like the Ottoman Empire do the same to spread Islam?

To build upon that question, why did only a handful of European kingdoms attempt colonization of the New World? Why didn't other nations do so, especially ones outside of Europe like those in Asia and the Middle East? What factors motivated that handful of nations (Spain, Great Britain, France, Portugal, the Netherlands, Sweden, Russia) to colonize that wasn't present for other nations?

2 Answers 2019-01-19

Did the Khmer Rouge really kill everyone with glasses?

I was listening to Dan Carlin’s Hardcore History and at the beginning of the latest episode he said

something about the Khmer Rouge killing everyone with glasses in Cambodia. I am vaguely aware

of the events that took place there but unsure if this glasses cliché was actually what happened.

Could someone explain maybe where this came from, or if it is true? Thanks

1 Answers 2019-01-19

I saw a post on reddit that said "human beings have advanced more in the past 130 years than anytime before that." Does this statement hold any weight among historians? Is there an objective way to measure this?

1 Answers 2019-01-19

Authenticity of a letter Hulagu Khan purportedly sent to the Mamluks?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2019-01-19

Why did the Duchy of Warsaw not reform the Winged Hussars?

The Winged Hussars were a defining factor of Poland and Lithuania so why did the Duchy of Warsaw not form them? They were effective in warfare and could increase nationalism so it makes sense to reform them.

1 Answers 2019-01-19

Every other Cold War proxy war seems to have involved Cuban expeditionary forces: Nicaragua, Syria, Ethiopia, Angola, and many more. How did a small nation have the resources and manpower to participate in these campaigns while being under constant threat from the US in their own backyard?

While some of the interventions were limited in scope, others were long campaigns involving tens of thousands of Cuban soldiers.

Even with Soviet help, this must have taken a toll on Cuban capabilities to protect their own country. Was this just not a problem for Castro, since he trusted the Soviets to protect the island? Or was the US judged a paper tiger after the Bay of Pigs?

And why do they seem to have contributed more than the Soviet Union when it comes to manpower? For example, per the wiki page on the Angolan Civil War there were 60,000 Cubans in the country in 1988, compared to 11,000 Soviets between 1975 and 1991.

Searching around in the sub I found some answers touching on the interventions, but I could not find one that touched on my specific doubts.

1 Answers 2019-01-19

In the early 1900s, how did Japan become so powerful despite closing the country for 200+ years and having no natural resources?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-01-19

From the beginning of Chinese nationalism Western religion and philosophy played an outsized role, with Christians supporting the Kuomintang and atheists supporting the Communist Party of China. At that time most of China was Buddhist, Taoist, or Confucian. How did these groups cleave?

1 Answers 2019-01-19

Help Needed! I hope this type of question is allowed here. I am currently working on a 40 page research paper on the First Battle of Bull Run and I’m in desperate need of primary sources.

[deleted]

3 Answers 2019-01-19

Was the 90% marginal tax rate under Eisenhower controversial?

I read somewhere that it actually motivated Reagan to switch parties to become a Republican. Was he in the minority of people who didn't like it?

 

edit: apparently 2 commenters have posted but the comments aren't appearing on desktop nor app. If you dont mind reposting your comments that would be great

edit2: nevermind, they were removed

1 Answers 2019-01-19

British WW2 clasp / jack knife, Is this geniune ww2? & what are these symbols?

Hey guys, just picked up 2 British clasp knives, 1 with the marlin spike and 1 without.

Now the one without seems genuine, dated 1944 Sheffield where pretty much all these knives seem to have came from to my knowledge.

However the one with the marlin spike, shown in the image does not have any info listed on it's blade, no date, no city of origin, manufacturer etc. Which seems strange, even stranger it has some numbers/symbols that I do not recognise on the tin opener.

​

https://i.redd.it/eabwo77k8ab21.jpg

​

Symbols from what I can tell are

Top bar - "L D UP ARROW 5"

bottom bar - a backwards 'h'. backwards 'L', 4, 1?

​

I know an upwards arrow (crow feet) normally means WW2 military, however never seen it like that.

Something else to add is that the knife has a brass ring loop, which I believe means pre-1940.

Anyone know if this is genuine and what these symbols mean?

Thanks

1 Answers 2019-01-19

Advice needed: old oil painting of what seems to be World War One era British navy painted on map of the river Mersey

I'm looking for some information or help to find out more about an oil painting that has been in my family for generations. The painting depicts a naval battle, the warships are bearing the British flag. It is painted on the back of a detailed map of the river Mersey. We are not sure who painted it , or how they managed to get a section of such a map.

Oil painting and map on back: http://imgur.com/gallery/15RQPoE

Unfortunately over time it has become slightly damaged but it still has a lot of value to us. We have wanted to find out more for years and we decided to ask here.

Thanks in advance for any replies or info.

1 Answers 2019-01-19

What was the political structure of the Middle East immediately before the Muslim conquests?

I was thinking about this and realized I couldn't really place any major civilizations to this area at the time immediately preceding the Muslim conquests... It's far too late for the Assyrians or Babylonians, but well before any Turkic people come down from Central Asia, so no Ottomans or Safavids. The only major one I can think of is maybe the Persians, but I guess I don't know enough about their time periods to be sure.

Basically I'm wondering what the general political structures were in that time period throughout the Middle East, not just Persia or the Levant, but Arabia and Anatolia and North Africa. What would the average person's social/religious/political fealty be?

1 Answers 2019-01-19

Did the Japanese Use Curved Knives?

So the genesis for my question is this door handle at my most convenient watering hole. It's a sushi bar and they have other things that I recognize as authentically Japanese: calligraphy brushes, koi fish, samurai helmets. I am by no means a historian, let alone a Japanese historian, but I've been interested in Japanese culture since I learned Nintendo was a Japanese company but I've never seen a knife quite like the one pictured. It bothers the hell out of me every time I use the door and I figured I could get an answer here. Most of the Japanese blades I've come across in the pop culture I've consumed have been straight so I'm curious about this one there.

Thanks a bunch.

1 Answers 2019-01-18

How intertwined were the Opium Wars and the Taiping Rebellion?

I'm reading "The Opium War" by Julia Lowell and I'm struck by how halfheartedly the Qing fought the British. The Second Opium War happened concurrently as the Taiping Rebellion.

Was the rise of the anti opium Taiping Heavenly Kingdom tied to the rise of opium importation? Why did the Qing expend millions more lives fighting the THK than the British? How related are these two (three really) conflicts?

1 Answers 2019-01-18

What did darwins notes look like?

When darwin first was in the galapagos, how would he have gone about organizing categorizing and recording everything he found? Obviously taxonomy was still young and he hadnt come close to starting on the origin of species yet, so did he make it up as he went along or was it a very measured thing

(I tried asking this in r/askscience and i was directed here)

1 Answers 2019-01-18

What did Che Guevara do? Why do a lot of people love him and why do a lot of people hate him?

This might be a loaded question, but the fact is that I never learned who Che Guevara was but still I see him being mentioned everywhere, from people who idolize him and from people who demonize him. What exactly did he do in a historical sense? What was he known for? What did he contribute to? Why some people love him so much and yet a lot of people hate him?

1 Answers 2019-01-18

Why are noble women usually depicted in medieval and post-renaissance paintings with grey or white hair?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2019-01-18

Weaponized Water

Has water ever been used in really cold climate regions to drench the enemy and make things worse for them?

1 Answers 2019-01-18

⯇ 2167 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start