What exactly is the relationship between the Assassin cult and hashish?

I've heard basically three histories, and I'll attempt to give my lay-person summary of them all:

  1. The Assassin cult used drugs and mysticism to motivate agents before suicidal(or nigh so) tasks, and got known for using hashish to this end. Thus, they were known as 'users of hashish' which eventually became the word for Assassin.

  2. There is no actual connection between hashish and the assassins, the result being bad translation of arabic by westerners presuming the words had anything in common when they in fact did not. The connection is purely some form of western backronym.

  3. The assassin cult was the object of plenty of ridicule (for numerous reasons, political, religious, etc) and were effectively tied to the drug as a form of slander, an attempt to discredit them. Their contemporaries claimed they were drug users or addicts to minimize their influence. This may or may not be a parallel name to another name they had.

Reading the wikipedia article I think all three of these are espoused in different places which just makes me more confused. Is there something I'm missing that makes these make sense together, is one of these predominant? Are they all independently true, in a sense?

2 Answers 2019-01-10

Wikipedia says the vikings had to leave Britain in AD 1005 because a famine struck their army. Did that famine just effect them, or were the native English badly hit as well?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1005

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Here They Are! Announcing the AskHistorians Best of 2018 Winners!!!

Hello everyone! The polls are closed, the votes have been tallied, and the most important awards ceremony of the season is going to kick off!

Every year, thousands of users contribute amazing content to /r/AskHistorians, and each and every one of them deserves recognition for the part that they play in making this such an incredible community, as do those of you asking questions, upvoting great content, or simply reading and enjoying what gets produced here every day. But even then, there are some who go above and beyond to stand out even here, and although there are still far more examples of that than we can reasonably recognize, these awards at least can give some well deserved laurels to a few of the people who have helped to make 2018 another great year of AskHistorians.

I'm going to start out with the one that, out of all other awards handed out, is perhaps the most justly due. We have run our "Excellence in Flairdom" award for over a year, intending to recognize flaired users who helped make the sub a better place through more than just answering questions, but through giving to the community, but this year we have decided to award a deluxe edition Excellence in Flairdom award for the year as a whole. We’re not just giving; we invented this award for /u/itsallfolklore. For years now, IAF has been one of the warmest, most steadfast, smartest, and most quietly fun presences on AskHistorians. If you only read their posts for “facts,” you miss their real lesson—history is a story, history is infinite stories, and we are storytellers. Well, IAF is the master storyteller, whether it’s the folk, the diaries, or their own oral histories. For many of us in the flair community, itsallfolklore has also been an amazing and understanding mentor (consciously or not). It’s not an accident that one of the most-repeated lines in mod discussions is, “I want to be IAF when I grow up.” Now that we have sufficiently embarrassed them, we will close by saying thank you, and here it is: Excellence in Flairdom Award 2018: Historian, Storyteller, Mentor, Friend.


Next up is the 'Users' Choice Awards', the Vox Populi.

And I must say, it is nice to know that you all are just as crazy about IAF as we are. The first place Users' Choice Award I'm pleased to announce goes to /u/itsallfolklore for their answer to the question "Is there a way to study history in an unbiased manner? If so, how?", asked by /u/bidric, which was as enlightening and entertaining as we could hope for, but easily par for the course when it comes to him.

The second Users' Choice Award goes to /u/Bentresh! They were able to really sink their teeth into the question "I'm playing Assassins Creed, and frankly, the crocodiles are really irritating me. How did actual ancient Egyptians deal with it?", asked by [deleted], and give a little depth to the history behind the game!

Taking that third User's Choice Award was /u/dhmontgomery. Their wonderful answer to "How true is this claim: "...in 1789, 50 percent of the French people did not speak [French] at all, and only 12 to 13 percent spoke it fairly well"?", asked by /u/Nessie, might have passed under the radar back in January, but its getting well deserved recognition now!

Finally, for the Dark Horse Award in the user vote, recognizing a non-flaired contributor, /u/sickhobbit scored the honors for their answer to "Between 1945 and 1949, the Netherlands and Indonesia went to war over Indonesian independence. US and British forces were involved, and there were approx 200,000 casualties, before Indonesia finally prevailed. Why is this conflict so obscure? What were the consequences in East Asia?", asked by /u/ajbrown141.


Now for the 'Flairs' Choice Awards', voted on specifically by the members of our panel.

First up here is /u/drylaw, who is being recognized for their work on "The greatest treasure of the Aztec empire was taken by Cortez, but then captured by the pirate Jean Fleury, who presented the riches to the king of France. What happened to those treasures afterward?", asked by peace-monger.

Taking the second Flairs' Choice, and no stranger to this podium, is /u/mikedash, who earned his prize this year with "What was the nature of the government of Barawa? Was it unique in the Swahili coast? Was it a republic, and if so, how did it compare to contemperary governments in Europe?", asked by Ana_Gramm.

And finally to round out this podium is /u/400-rabbits who gave us some excellent insight into the question "What would it have been like to grow up as a girl in the Aztec Empire pre-colonialism?", asked by /u/AnnalsPornographie.

For the 'Dark Horse' Award in the Flair vote, it isn't surprising to see perennial winner /u/Erusian once again taking a bow, nor it is surprising that it would be their answer to "Was John Cleese correct, in 1972, when his character famously exclaimed that cheddar cheese was the most popular cheese in the world?", asked by /u/ZeMoose, that is most fondly remembered.


Closing out our ceremony, finally, is the 'Greatest Question Award', which goes to /u/IphisofCrete for their question "The Stonewall Riots are generally considered the beginning of the modern LGBT rights movement, but gay rights groups had existed long before 1969. What made the post-Stonewall revolution so impactful and what changed to make gay rights movements more cohesive and vocal?", which might have gone unanswered the first time, but did get that helpful boost to get a fantastic response from /u/sunagainstgold on the second try.


So there we have it! Your 2018 honorees. Let me be the first to congratulate them all, and thank them for their part in a wonderful year.

As always, winners will be getting some well deserved "reddit Premium", and - fingers crosses - some fancy /r/AskHistorians swag in the mail once the Admins finish updating their licensing agreement.

22 Answers 2019-01-10

Were there any cultures where intimate relationships between adults of the same sex were tolerated, rather than just pederasty?

For example, Ancient Greece and Shogunate Japan are often described as being tolerant of homosexuality, when in reality these cultures only tolerated relationships between grown men and teenage boys, prostitutes or slaves. A man had to be the active partner in the relationship, and if he allowed himself to be the passive, penetrated partner he would face great shame.

So, were there any cultures that tolerated or accepted what might be described as "egalitarian" homosexual relationships between free adults, with no particular stigma reserved for the "passive" partner?

I've also noticed that a lot of ancient writers seemed to be totally unable to understand how lesbian sex might work. Were there any cultures where same-sex relationships between women were tolerated, or at least understood?

4 Answers 2019-01-10

Origin of "Traditional" Breakfast Foods

From what I've read, it seems people ate just about anything for breakfast. Be 18th century Canadians eating breakfasts featuring things like pickles or hot chocolate. Medieval English commoners eating bread and ale. Or Vikings eating leftover stew. They just ate random food, apparently. When did people - in the West anyway - start categorizing things like bacon and eggs or toast as "breakfast foods".

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Why Japan didn't join with Germany during first days of operation Barbarossa by attacking the Far East?

2 Answers 2019-01-10

The Battle of Stalingrad Soldier Kit

Did some Soviet soldiers wear the SSH 36 helmet during the Battle of Stalingrad, or was that helmet completely phased out at that time?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

What made the American pursuit of the atom bomb so much more successful than the German's endeavor?

While watching a movie, someone suggested that Heisenberg didn't want to succeed in developing a nuclear weapon for the Germans. Was American success due to the will of the people involved? The resources allocated? Sheer luck?

3 Answers 2019-01-10

How Fascist was Britain?

I was recently watching The ABC Murders which is set in Britain during the 1930s. Throughout the show we see fascist posters, people handing out fascist flyers and people wearing fascist pins on their coats, how common was it for people to openly express this kind of support?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

I’m reading ”King Solomon’s Mines” in English right now, and want some advice on the historical meaning and historical connotations of racial slurs in the book.

In the book, the narrator Allen Quatermain has conflicting views on the Zulu, Khoisan, and other indigenous people around him. He is very familiar with their culture, being fluent in their language, yet also on occasion insults their primitivity. He is uncomfortable with and distasteful towards saying n*****, yet also refers to people as Kafirs and Hottentots, both of which are currently considered racial slurs. I’m not asking about the narrator’s views however, but the historical connotations of these words. Did Victorian British consider Kafir and Hottentot as disparaging as the n-word, or was it a “culturally aware” title for the time?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Japan Clothes

Hello, I'm doing a project about Japan's history. Can you guys tell me something about Japanese royal costume? Like the change throught the years and the rules when the tailors make the clothes. Thank you very much!

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Was depression as common in any times before 1800 as it is today?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

What book best explains battlefield tactics and weapons of WWII?

I've read so many histories of battles in the Second World War and they always refer to the names of guns and weapons. The authors write as though the intricacies of these weapons would make sense to a reader with no military knowledge. I am looking for a book that talks specifically about battlefield tactics in WW2. For example, when do you use a sub machine gun, how you use a heavy machine gun, how to support a tank, what a howitzer does, what is a mobile gun carrier and how is it better than a tank, how to deploy a unit, how many men in a unit and what are their roles. This kind of stuff. Any help gladly appreciated

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | January 10, 2019

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

5 Answers 2019-01-10

Lombard's, Ruling class or population replacement of northern Italy?

My question is simply. When the Lombards invaded and occupied Italy but especially northern Italy did the Lombards simple take the position of the elite/ruling class of the italy/northern Italian population or did they drastically or completely mix/replace with the population that was there be forth them.

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Best website to find out what my grandfather did in the war?

Hi,What are the best websites to find out what my grandfather did during the war? He never spoke about it when alive so we have very little to go on other than he was in the RAF, he was stationed in India for around five years, and loads of photos of him with random women, alongside his telegram explaining his departure in 1944 due to medical reasoning. We have no idea about his squad or what he actually did, other than be an apparent war-time model. I have tried to look on some websites, but I couldn't find his name.

Thank-you in advance.

Bonus Question: Does anyone know about the possible car make "OTTOPHOCUS"?
I have tried to look online but have found nothing. I realise it could just be what the car is named and not the actual make but, I would just like to double check.

2 Answers 2019-01-10

How did Britain aquire Gibraltar as an overseas territory?

It is almost never mentioned before the Napoleonic and World Wars. Then it is never explained how Britain took this extremely strategic rock for themselves.

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Why is Norse mythology so similar to Greek?

3 Answers 2019-01-10

Was the story in the 300 movie real? If so, how well did it depict the events that occurred?

Note* I know that the spartans wore armor instead of being almost naked

1 Answers 2019-01-10

There is a common theme in wartime propaganda posters to warn citizens against talking too much lest the enemy hear secrets. But was it common for belligerents to actually find useful information in this way?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-01-10

How on earth did the Unabomber evade capture for nearly 20 years, despite the costliest FBI investigation in history?

2 Answers 2019-01-10

Romans: bow and arrow?

Hi!

I was wondering if the Roman army at the time of the Roman empire (or republic) used archers in its army. Since the only things I know of are velites (thst threw javelins) and slingers.

This information may mainly come from total war games.

On a more serious note: I never heard of the use of archers in my history classes concerning the Roman Empire. So that got me wondering.

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Why Didn't France Fortify their Border with Belgium After WW1?

I don't know much about WW2 since my interest primarily lies further in the past. I am aware that France had heavily fortified their border with Germany after the Franco-Prussian war and that Germany accounted for this and invaded through Belgium to avoid that fortified line in WW1, after which France created the Maginot line.

I did a cursory reading of the Battle of France and it seems like their intent was to have their best available at the Belgium border while the Maginot line held the rest but it seems odd that they wouldn't have made an attempt to continue the Maginot line north since that was Germany's last invasion avenue.

Was it because the terrain wasn't as rough and thus an invasion force could avoid the more heavily fortified regions of the area or was it an economic issue?

Please correct me if my assumptions about anything are incorrect. I intend to delve deeper into WW2 but I just have a lot on my plate concerning history books at the moment so I have a very cursory knowledge of it.

2 Answers 2019-01-10

The poetry English soldiers wrote during the Great War is some of the most renowned in the English speaking world. Did WWI similarly inspire poetry in German, French, and/or Russia? And if so, how does it thematically compare to poems like “The Soldier” or “Dulce et Decorum Est”?

2 Answers 2019-01-10

[Negotiation and Accomodation] How would contracts have been handled in a society like the Celts, where people where illiterate and there was a heavy focus on ORAL tradition?

Pretty much the title.

I'm reading about the Celts and I keep reading so often about contracts, but the people were almost all (if not all) illiterate and their cultures focused on oral tradition, so how would they have formed contracts? One form of contract was for joint-ploughing but WAS it written down? Did they memorize the wording of the contract? Did they use a standardized contract (probably likely), which if so, did they have witnesses to such? How were contracts 'drawn up' in an illiterate society that focused heavily on oral traditions?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

⯇ 2183 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start