If forts were deemed useless after ww1, why did the french build the Maginot Line and why didn't the Germans wanna go through it?

Yes, there's obviously something crucial I've missed.

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Book(s) on the lives of everyday, normal people.

Hi there. I'm interested in finding books about the quality of life for everyday, normal people throughout history, perhaps in comparison to modern life. Does anybody have any recommendations?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

What was Hitler's opinion of the Baltic states specifically Lithuania?

I'm curious because I've heard he was fine with them, but hated the slavs but halts and slavs are very closely related so this doesnt make much sense to me.

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Is is true that Heinrich Himmler decided to implement gas chambers after he witnessed for the first time mass execution of 120 men in Minsk August 15th 1941?

Richard Rhodes in his book "Masters of Death" cites Karl Wolff, personal adjutant of Himmler, who states that organised especially for Himmler execution of 120 men near Minsk August 15th 1941 was the first time when Himmler witnessed killing a man. According to Rhodes he was so disturbed that he decided after to came up with other, more clean and less mentally burdensome method of killing. Is it possible that it was first time when Chief of SS witnessed act of killing? Also is it true that it was the reason of implementing gas chambers?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Did Japan really think bombing Pearl Harbor was a good move?

The US wasn’t directly in ww2 yet it just seems like the biggest blunder imaginable.

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Did Ernst Roehm, Hitler and the Nazi leadership engage in homosexual activities? Or is it political slander?

Hitler publicly railed against Magnus Hirschfeld as a symbol of decadence, Jewishness, cosmopolitanism and modernity. But some say the Nazis used the repulsion of the lower classes to homosexuality in order to gain power and as a political weapon. Basically they used the accusation of homosexuality to get rid of anyone they didn’t like, not because they were really against it. Some research https://www.theguardian.com/world/2001/oct/07/books.booksnews

What do you think? Truth or slander?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

In one of Rembrandt's paintings "Christ Before Pilate," he includes a clock. Did he have any idea of what the place looked like historically, or was he trying to modernize the scene for his time?

Here is the painting in question: Christ Before Pilate - a copy of the link to copy/paste: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b6/Rembrandt%2C_Christ_before_Pilate_%28Ecce_Homo%29%2C_1634%2C_National_Gallery%2C_London.jpg

​

In his final print, the clock is gone. Did somebody tip him off about the history of clocks?

​

I'd also love to know more about his choices in design for the final piece if anyone has information.

2 Answers 2019-01-10

I’ve been told by a friend that the majority of the early Russian/Soviet Communist government was Jewish. Is this true and can someone go into further detail on the Jewish effect in communist politics?

I’ve heard the term “Jewish Bolshevism” and wanted to know if this was just used as anti-communist propaganda or actually true...or both. Thanks!

2 Answers 2019-01-10

How Succesful was the Roman Idea of Consuls?

I was wondering, isthe idea of two people in charge who switch off their control every month was generally seen as a good move or more likely to cause political strife?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

My grandfather served in Europe in WWII. He’s passed and I’d like to find where he served and in which battles he was engaged.

Looking for tips on where to start. Thanks!

1 Answers 2019-01-10

How were the Crusaders able to capture Constantinople in 1204 while the Ottomans had difficulty doing so with a far less populated city in 1453?

I can think of a few reasons, like Ottoman forces not being designed to conduct a siege, inept leadership during 1204, and just-repaired walls. But apparently the Venetians managed to scale the sea walls during 1204. How did they do so?

​

*Alexios Strategepoulos* *Sneaks Into the City*

1 Answers 2019-01-10

Do any Native American tribes have histories or legends surrounding the adoption of the horse?

Growing up, I assumed that the various Sioux nations were always a horse riding people. It was only later I learned that the horse was introduced to North America, and slowly adopted by some tribes for the many benefits they brought. Do native people have any stories surrounding that adoption? Any clear example of it transforming a tribal culture or art?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

What was the ethnic make up of the Mongol army that invaded Hungary and Poland?

I know that the Golden Horde eventually became more predominately Turk as time went on, but what was the army made up of when it invaded Hungary and Poland?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

How did Switzerland emerge from the HRE without being absorbed by Austria or Prussia?

1 Answers 2019-01-10

What are the best sources on human history of the world across the last several centuries?

Edit 1: The question's practically already answered in the stickied comment, but if anyone else feels they have something to recommend please don't hesitate. There's no bad recommendation, so long as it's a good source. This sub is a diamond in the rough.


Disclaimer: I'm exclusively a lurker and occasionally make one-off accounts to ask questions. This is one of those accounts. I've read the rules and hopefully my question won't violate any of them.


Question:

I want a decent understanding of how our modern world came to be. What books, shows, or other media would be the best sources to get a relatively cohesive grasp?


Context:

I admire and respect the strict adherence to evidence-based truth that this sub-reddit strives for and can't honestly think of a better place to start my search. But, if anyone does know of better sources, let me know. It's definitely within the scope of my question.

So, I'm in the Northeastern USA and was raised in a rural area. I took history classes in High School. World, U.S., Government, the "works". About a decade later, I've since moved to a city with some diversity and learned/corrected more by osmosis and exposure than I ever learned in those classes-- even though I wasn't able to fit history courses into an engineering degree during my time at university. The experience has shown me that while my view of the world has expanded, it's still pretty narrow and it's also rooted in very little historical wisdom. It makes me naive, easy to manipulate for whatever causes.

So, all of this is basically just for my own edification. I want a world view that's based in fact. I want my political views filtered through what has and has not been successful in the social movements of the past. I want to know where we've been so that my idea of where we should go won't be riddled with dogma. I want our world, as chaotic and tumultuous as it is, to be less mysterious. And I'd like to do the work myself, but I need a roadmap. From just lurking, y'all seem to be really serious about your domain.

I recognize that the question is broad in its scope, but I hope that it is also clear enough in its intent that it doesn't violate rule 1.

Any and all recommendations appreciated.

Thanks much, u/AlertMarsupial, apparently. idk. The name generator chose it.

1 Answers 2019-01-10

In Oliver Stone's "Untold History", he mentions a blurb about Indian defection to the Japanese side during WWII, any resources for further research?

I can't seem to find much through standard googling, or perhaps don't know particular keywords to start from

1 Answers 2019-01-09

How do historians even retain that much information?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2019-01-09

In WW2, how feasible was a Japanese assault on Siberia? Could it have accomplished anything of note?

I hear the argument come up relatively often that the Japanese should have attacked Siberia in WW2, as it would have split Soviet forces and allowed Germany to defeat them in the west.

Non-aggression pact notwithstanding, this never really sounded quite right to me. Outside of Vladivostok, I don't know of any notable cities that far east, the infrastructure would have made advances beyond the coast leave an even heavier burden on the Japanese logistic system already straining to supply their men in China, and if I'm not mistaken, Soviet resources in Siberia weren't being exploited too heavily at the time.

All in all, it seems to me like for such an offensive, Japan would have had to use a lot of men and material to not really accomplish much of note. Is there more to it that I'm missing, or would it have been as ineffective and cost-prohibitive as it seems?

1 Answers 2019-01-09

Why did the crafters of the various U.S. State Constitutions (except Nebraska) choose to create bicameral legislatures? Was this simply a matter of mirroring the federal Congress, or was there a prevailing political theory that suggested bicameralism was better than unicameralism?

As I understand the Founding documents as taught to me in high school, the Fathers created Congress as a bicameral legislature as part of the Connecticut Compromise to balance:

  • The need to balance the interests of smaller, less populous states with their larger brethren, and;
  • The need to balance the interests of the people with the interests of the states themselves, as directed by the state legislatures (as Senators were not directly elected by the voters until the early 1900's)

As neither justification would have applied at the state level, why was it that 49 States nonetheless adopted bicameralism?

2 Answers 2019-01-09

When did it become customary for the bride to wear white at weddings?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-01-09

Prior to the Perry Expedition, Japan was an isolationist country with limited trade and few resources. Why did the West want to open trade with Japan so aggressively? Were there any Japanese goods in high demand?

1 Answers 2019-01-09

How do I track this French report down?

Hi, I'm looking for a report on a weapon by a Swiss man called John Steuble that was commissioned in 1837 by a General Bernard of the French artillery. The only problem is, I have absolutely no idea where to even begin. I know historians use records but how do they find those that aren't easily accessible on the internet? I'm only asking because I'm fairly sure the report isn't on the internet but as the report was commissioned over 100 years ago I figure it must be available to the public in some form. Also, I feel like I should mention that I don't speak any French, which doesn't help matters much.

2 Answers 2019-01-09

Why did Benin change their flag to a green flag with a red star at the top and then changed back after 15 years to the flag they use now?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2019-01-09

How were smithing tools made in ancient times?

I understand that smiths used some sort of cups to hold melted iron in ancient Egypt. But how did they make the tools that can handle melted iron?

1 Answers 2019-01-09

Did Silesia leave the Holy Roman Empire?

I was reading a Wikipedia article and stumbled upon this section:

"Am Ende des Ersten Schlesischen Krieges stand der Breslauer Vorfrieden und Berliner Friedensvertrag von 1742. Dem Vertrag gemäß gingen das Herzogtum Niederschlesien und die Grafschaft Glatz 'in voller Souveränität und Unabhängigkeit ... von der Krone Böhmens' an Friedrich über. Er erhielt Schlesien unter Aufhebung der reichslehensrechtlichen Bindung" - Wikipedia (https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titulatur_und_Wappen_der_Deutschen_Kaiser_nach_1873#Souver%C3%A4ner_und_oberster_Herzog_von_Schlesien_wie_auch_der_Grafschaft_Glatz)

Translation:

"The First Silesian War ended with the Preliminary Peace of Wrocław and the Peace of Berlin in 1742. According to the treaty, the Duchy of Lower Silesia and the County of Kladsko were given 'in full souvereignty and independence ... from the crown of Bohemia' to Frederick. He gained Silesia with the bindings of Imperial feudal laws being repealed."

Is this accurate? Does that mean Prussian Silesia was not part of the Holy Roman Empire anymore as of 1742? I have never read anything about this being the case before, and the maps I know that show the late HRE don't exclude Silesia. Plus, it was definitely part of the German Confederation, where at least usually only the former parts of the Empire were included.

1 Answers 2019-01-09

⯇ 2184 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start