Did ancient melee armies really charge into one another in massive groups like in the movies?

If so, how was anyone in the front lines able to survive multiple battles? I’d think the entire front lines of both armies would be totally ground up, speared, trampled, etc.

1 Answers 2018-11-12

When swing dancing and jazz were taking off in the 1920s, plenty of people born in the Victorian Era were still alive - did they find the new style of dance and music immoral, indecent, or overly sexualized?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

In 1899, what would the logistics be for a group of Americans to travel to Tahiti and buy land, and emigrate there?

2 Answers 2018-11-12

Why do all major SE Asian scripts (Burmese, Khmer, Thai, Old Malay etc.) descend from the Pallava script and not Sanskrit

Why is that? The Pallava script is from the South Indian Pallava dynasty in 600CEish. All major SE Asian scripts descend from it.

Yet, the North Indian Gupta empire seemed to have far greater influence, and their script is Devanagari. Yet that did not spread to SE Asia. Why?

2 Answers 2018-11-12

The kurds and gobekli tepe

I’ve been quite fascinated by the findings in gobekli tepe since it’s the hometown of my family (sanliurfa). But one thing bothers me, nowadays it’s a Kurdish city with a big Kurdish population, we are actually zaza but we are Kurds none the less.

Do the Kurdish people have any ties to gobekli tepe? What I’ve read the Kurdish history is blurry and unsure, but in my mind the people who built gobekli tepe should be ancestors of today’s Kurds. Different tribes and peoples have of course mixed during the millennia’s to make today’s Kurds but are the Kurds today related in a straight line back to the inhabitants of gobekli tepe? Sorry for bad English

1 Answers 2018-11-12

In the show Vikings, and other viking related shows, none of the houses have chimneys i noticed. Why is that?

I know these shows aren't exact science but once i noticed the houses didn't have chimneys i started looking at other images of ancient viking/norse style abodes, and none of them seem to have chimneys in them. Possibly an oversight as every image i found was a recreation or was it? Were traditional stoves/chimneys to keep the house warm not a thing?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Upon the death of Elizabeth I was there any attempt by Plantagenet descendants to put themselves forward as claimants?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Did Lancaster bombers every fly with B-17s in day missions over Germany? for example, with the Eighth Air Force? if not, did brits ever fly the B-17s with them?

Thanks for any info given!

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Was there a Canadian frontier expansion similar to that of the USA’s, i.e. a Canadian “Wild West?” If so, was it fueled by a similar belief like Manifest Destiny?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

when did worship of ancient Egyptian dieties stop?

I read through existing answers and couldn't find a very good one.

1 Answers 2018-11-12

How was switzerland never invaded in ww1 and ww2?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Before there were alarm clocks; how did people made sure to wake up on time in the mornings, specially in places where maybe not every household had roosters?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

At The End of the WW1 Would it have been possible for the Entente to dismember Germany. Also In event of that happening would Bavaria become a Communist state?

In the last week of the first world war Germany faced an uprising against the monarchy. Bavaria declared itself an independent communist state if the treaty of Versailles had Germany dismantled would Europe have a communist power in western Germany to deal with?

If You Find Any Of My Facts Wrong please feel free to correct them!

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Until the late-middle ages/early modern period, most maps were oriented with the east at the top. I've heard it said this is because Christians used to believe the Garden of Eden lay in the east. Is this true?

Does the east-based orientation of maps originate with Christianity? If so, how were maps originated before. If not, then why did pre-Christians put the east at the top?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

How was the bible, more specifically the old testament discovered and translated?

We know that the bible is very old and has had multiple translations and re-writings over the years. For the new testament, it was written in medieval greek and the documents were well preserved and copied. But the old testament, at least as close as we can get to primary sources, were written in Ancient Hebrew and Aramaic among other things. How were theologians and historians able to understand languages that nobody spoke and translate/codify them into the book we know today? Are today's writings an accurate translation or have we gotten lost playing a game of ancient biblical telephone?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Is there evidence to suggest soldiers in ancient times experienced what would today be called PTSD after fighting in battle?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Why weren't axes and maces as prominent on East Asian nations as in the rest of the world?

I often see that the "traditional" weapons of China/Korea/Japan are full of swords and Spears like the Chinese jiang or the Korean Woldo. We also see some "systems" develop like the chinese folklore weapons (the Jian, the Gun, the Qiang and the Dao)

But where do maces and axes fit in all of this? We see them being used extensively in Europe, pre-columbian American civilizations, the middle East etc. Etc.

Why aren't these weapons as prominent in East asia?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

WW1 diaries help. Germany France

i've looked everywhere and i can't seem to find a readable/easy to translate diary page during ww1 Germany against France. i needed it to be related to the schlieffen plan and it can be by German, French English or even Anzac's. Any help would be great and i would love if anyone can find anything. Thanks <3

1 Answers 2018-11-12

What were the tactics used by the early Islamic armies in their initial conquests?

More specifically, what formations and fighting styles did they utilized when facing the Byzantines and (to the great misfortune of all of humanity) defeating the Sassanids? Are there any books one could recommend on the subject?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

If a King fell in battle, was anyone 'allowed ' to kill him or did the common soldier avoid him for their higher ranks to kill him?

4 Answers 2018-11-12

What was the Bondocracy in the US after Slavery?

I was watching a youtube lecture about the book "The Half Has Never Been Told: Slavery and the Making of American Capitalism by Edward Baptist"

In the lecture and book it argued that what is commonly taught about slavery and its impact is wrong. It's argued though that slavery was a huge catalyst to American capitalism. This confronts what's taught in many schools that slavery was unprofitable and that's why it was ended.

Cited is a document by a New York Publication called The Old Guard in 1865. On page 455 there's an article named "Slavery and Bondocracy"

What is a bondocracy? What do they mean when they say 3 billions of property in slaves was converted to United States bond?

I should note this document is a northern pro-confederate publication. But it still speaks to the mindset of the north at the time. It was worth bringing up in the video and as such I'd like to understand it.

Thank you

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Does anyone know anything about the members of 3rd battalion rangers durring world war two.

Hello r/AskHistorians,

Today I was talking to my great grandmother for the first time is almost a year, and with all of the celebration of veterans going around on this great day I wanted to ask her about my great grandfather, who Ive been told served in "Darby's Rangers."

Upon doing some research and talking to her it seems that he served in the 3rd rangers battalion, does anyone know where I can find combat records of what he did, I know that he survived, however almost all but one other (according to ggmother) person in his group.

Thanks! Edit: his name was Elmer J. Montee

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Irish Cuir Bouilli armor?

So I've been trying to look up and study Irish clothing around 400-500 CE. I understand the Irish didn't generally wear armor, but that curi bouilli armor might've shown up. What might this have looked like? Or did it not exist at all?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

When did dueling fall out of style and how common was it in the US?

There are many famous duels most notably alexander hamilton vs aaron burr. My question is how often did they occur and were there written laws dictating how they went? Also why did the custom eventually die out and when?

1 Answers 2018-11-12

Unlike other democracies, the US has repeatedly reverted to a two-party system throughout virtually all of its history (even when the parties involved have changed). Is this a result of something structurally distinct about America, just force of habit, or something else?

4 Answers 2018-11-12

2291 / 7255

Back to start