Why did so many Italians leave Italy from the late 1800s to the late 1900s?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

Is there any evidence that Lincoln was bribed to preserve the Union rather than having done it for a love of his country?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

What was the relationship between imperialism and the caste system in India?

3 Answers 2018-10-11

The stock market crash and the Great Depression are often blamed solely on Hoover. Obviously he is not the sole reason for the crash. What did previous administrations like Harding and Coolidge do that had an impact on the economy?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

It sure seems to me that everybody in Scandinavia is in a metal band. How did it get so prevalent ? Did grandfathers just growl the Kalevala into their little vikings' face ?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

This week, 100 years ago, the Hindenburg line on the western front was breached. What had changed in October 1918? Why was that offensive successful when so many before it were naught but catastrophic failures?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

I’m an upper-class Englishman in Victorian England during the height of Egyptomania who has been invited to a mummy unwrapping party. What can I hope to expect?

3 Answers 2018-10-11

In the Iliad, it depicts armies putting forth a champion to fight and determine the battle without mass fighting. Did this ever really happen, and how often were the results honoured?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

I'm a high school student with some questions about possibilities in history jobs.

Hi! I'm a high school student in my last year (Canada) with some questions about potential career pathways in history, and what I can do to get there.

I have always found myself incredibly frustrated with the way history is approached in high school and in the popular mind, and I am thoroughly unsatisfied with the chain-of-events way that we popularly engage with history. I worry that we are not engaging with our past in a way which allows us to understand how our cultural narratives both then and now influence our perception and use of history, and I want to do something about it. I want us, as a population, to develop the tools to think critically and analyse the past through a variety of approaches, from gender to geography, rather than seeing history as a laundry list of dead people, stereotypes, and military battles.

In short, I am interested in delving deeper into history and hopefully using my future expertise to engage with regular people (I also kind of have a nerdy hard-on for society in Ancient Rome). Unfortunately, I'm not quite sure how to go about it.

​

One of the more obvious pathways people talk about is moving into research and Professordom. While I am GREATLY interested in this pathway, I have heard again and again that the academic job market is pitiful and fiercely competitive. What is the experience, from graduation to landing the job, actually like? What can I do to get a leg up in this competitive atmosphere? How can I best access research/publishing opportunities as early as possible?

And how proficient do most grad programs want you to be in the languages relevant to your study? I know I'll likely have to squeeze in a ton of language classes during undergrad.

​

Another possibility I am thinking about is simply becoming a high school teacher. Teachers in my province are paid well (although the market is also quite competitive), and I was hoping that teaching history to adolescents could help provide these kids a solid, critical foundation for their future pursuits, whether in academia or something as simple as voting or buying the groceries. I guess I could also use my spare summers to go the popular publishing route and write some books or something.

​

Unfortunately, beyond those two options, I'm not sure what else is out there for me. What am I missing?

​

Thank you so, so much.

5 Answers 2018-10-11

Why did the publication of the Dead Sea Scrolls create such a controversy in the early 1990s?

The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered in the 1950s by Israelis but finally published and released to the world in 1991. This release apparently caused a huge amount of controversy in the 1990s. See this article from 1992:

https://www.nytimes.com/1992/04/19/us/open-dead-sea-scrolls-stir-up-new-disputes.html

The article says the scrolls are "potentially upsetting," "raising a furor," "rattling shutters," and quotes academics saying "we're in a new era," and "it's reinventing the wheel," etc.

For a layman in 2018, the Scrolls just seem like an academic footnote that didn't change anything about modern-day religious beliefs. Were these documents really so controversial back then? Why? Or is this a case of the media sensationalizing something that wasn't really a big deal?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

Why aren't the Tulsa race riots of the '20's ever mentioned in American history books?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

Why did the Interhamwe and FDLR flee Rwanda after butchering 800,000 Tutsis?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

Is the origin of the Roman salute found in ancient Greece?

I was listening to a lecture by greek academic Leonidas Mbillis, who stated that the Nazi Salute, as well as the swastika were ancient greek in origin. I tried to substantiate this claim but the only site I could find during my coffee break was a golden dawn website that claimed it was used first in ancient greece and therefore not originally tied to fascism or nazism. Obviously that website is very biased. Help me historians! Is this misinformation from the professor or does he have a point?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

Why did Arabic displace the native language(s) in Egypt but not in Iran?

A number of languages are spoken in Iran today with the main one being Farsi, descended from the ancient language of pre-Islamic Iran. By contrast in Egypt, the pre-conquest language is now only used in liturgy, with Egyptian Arabic being the first language of almost all Egyptians whether Christian or Muslim. What is the cause for the divergent fortunes of the ancient Egyptian language and Farsi?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

How do historians decide if someone was really LGBT (if they didn't openly declare themselves as such)?

When I was in high school, I occasionally heard about "women who dressed as men" or two men who "lived together as best friends". Since then, I've heard a lot of arguments that various historical figures were actually LGBT, that the "women who dressed as men" were lesbians or transgender men, or the two men who devoted their lives to each other were gay partners. Those arguments certainly make sense to me. On the other side, the cultural meaning of behaviors that I would regard as obviously gendered or romantic must change across places and over time. (For example, I know that in many places in the world right now, male friends hold hands while walking together; in the US, that's a pretty unambiguously romantic gesture.) For example, I've seen photographs of women dressed in suits (trans men? lesbians") with feminine female partners. To me they're obviously queer couples, but other people said it was just a costume party or something. To make things more complicated, a lot of historical figures would have hidden the fact they were LGBT, right?

So how do historians puzzle it out? Do they just assume everyone is cisgender and straight unless proven otherwise? Is there a standard for deciding? How do they know what evidence means?

2 Answers 2018-10-11

How has corruption in public officials been overcome, where it largely has been in the modern West?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

Were pirates religious?

3 Answers 2018-10-11

When did we start domesticating pets? And why did we choose cats and dogs?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | October 11, 2018

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

9 Answers 2018-10-11

Fairytales are thousands of years old?

Can someone ELI5 what this study is saying? What do they mean when they say a story is old? I'm kind of skeptical. Is this theory taken seriously?

​

r/https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smithsonianmag/fairy-tales-could-be-older-ever-imagined-180957882

​

r/http://rsos.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/3/1/150645

2 Answers 2018-10-11

In popular imagination Ivan "the Terrible" is an archetypical mad, cruel and tyrannical ruler. How warranted this reputation? How much his actions were outside of norms compared to contemporary monarchs of Europe?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

How did the Spartan Special Forces operate?

Was curious how the 'Special Forces' of the Spartans operated during their time. What was their main use? How did they train? How were the soldiers chosen?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

Why Do People in Old Middle Eastern Paintings Look More East Asian?

I've always wondered why people in old Middle Eastern paintings look so East Asian.

https://www.wikiart.org/en/ahmad-musa/archangel-gabriel-carries-the-prophet-muhammad-over-the-mountains

https://www.wikiart.org/en/ahmad-musa/afrasyab-kills-navdar-1336

1 Answers 2018-10-11

What did the League of Nations do during WW2? Was the staff sent back home? What was going on in its buildings in Geneva?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

After the American Revolution, was there any movement to rename states and cities named after royals?

I know in the French Revolution, there was a huge movement away from symbols of monarchy. Did any of the staunch opponents of monarchy in America oppose the number of states (Georgia, the Carolinas, Virginia) associated with monarchs?

1 Answers 2018-10-11

⯇ 2349 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start