This Week's Theme: China

2 Answers 2018-09-16

What made somebody a "shishi" in Late Edo Japan?

I understand that the shishi were anti-foreign and anti-Tokugawa militants that arose in the wake of the assassination of Ii Naosuke, but I am unclear on how exactly the term was applied. Did people and groups apply it to themselves, if so, how did the term become current? Was it a term that Tokugawa or provincial authorities applied to heterogeneous groups? Or is it a term created by historians?

To put this in another words, what exactly made somebody a shishi specifically, as opposed to simply somebody who didn't care for the Tokugawa?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

I'm an African-American man living in the Jim Crow South, and I'm looking to purchase a firearm for self defense. What sorts of restrictions or prohibitions on me doing this are there due to my race?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Why in WW1 or other trench wars did they not dig tunnels under no mans land?

Dig a tunnel or 2 or 3, have men pour out directly into the enemies trench or tunnel under the enemy and fill with explosive?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Why did Yemen support the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | September 10, 2018–September 16, 2018

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

6 Answers 2018-09-16

Do we have any insights as to what drove Genghis Khan? It seems like a desperate desire for a war filled life he chose to live. Why? Was he likely to have had a mental illness?

2 Answers 2018-09-16

When did we start calling the Ottomans, "The Ottoman Empire"?

After seeing this same question in a r/MapPorn thread, I became curious. When did people start calling this country an empire? Did the Ottomans self proclaim themselves as such?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

How did the regular Ottoman Navy get along with the various irregular corsairs?

First, I'd like to apologize for asking so many questions in one thread, but I assume it's okay because they're all based around a central topic, and thus presumably the answers are related.

Anyway, I've been reading about the Ottoman Empire back when the Barbary states could still get away with corsaring, and I get the distinct impression that a large portion of the Ottoman Navy was made up of pirates who happened to have a vague disposition in favor of the Ottoman Empire. They clearly were an important part of the Ottoman Navy, as you have pirates like Redbeard (I refuse to call him Barbarossa because Redbeard is an amazing pirate name and is what he deserves to be remembered as) who become an admiral in the Ottoman Navy. But how did the central government and its regular navy actually coordinate things with the corsairs? It's not like they could just mail every pirate in the empire and tell them "hey, group up with the Sultan's fleet so we can sink the Spanish navy," as pirates tend to move around a lot and don't really have fixed mailing addresses. Hell, what even made the pirates follow the Sultan's orders in the first place?

On top of that, was the differences in discipline between regular navy sailors and the pirates an issue? While I'm not sure how disciplined the sailors in the regular ottoman navy were, I assume they were more disciplined than actual, honest to god pirates. Were there any incidents of fights breaking out, either between sailors themselves or larger scale fights between warships because of this?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Were the Anatolian Turks the same Turks as in the Turkic Peoples in Central Asia?

I'm a little confused by the amount of different Turks that pop up throughout history, I've heard about central-asian Turks in reference to raiding steppe tribes that harassed everyone from ancient Sumer right the way up to Persia, the Turks who encountered the Mongolians and of course the modern day state of Turkey.
I was wondering if those Turkic people were related to, or responsible for the modern state of Turkey, or is this a situation similar to the European definitions of Barbarians, Vandals and Goths? (as in a somewhat loose definition of those who threaten "civilised society").
Who are the Turks?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Wouldn't a visit to a brothel in pre-antibiotic days almost guarantee transmission of an STD? Maybe not with a single visit, but say after several? How is that sustainable?

Also, did any of the pre-antibiotic treatments work? Or did people recover on their own from some STDs? Anyway, I can understand the market forces behind brothels and prostitution, but I can't understand how STDs didn't throw a huge wrench into the smooth running of business.

3 Answers 2018-09-16

I've seen pictures of Australian soldiers bringing kangaroos and even a koala to Egypt during World War I. Why was this done and how did they keep the animals fed and healthy in that environment?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Real dueling and "staged" dueling

In his memoirs - written in the 1860s - Italian politician and writer Massimo D'Azeglio briefly discussed an episode of his youth (him being sixteen or seventeen at the time, son of a Marquis in cavalry school) when he had almost met for an "unauthroized" duel with another cadet of the same class. The seniors present had declined to assist the two in a matter that D'Azeglio himself described as trivial; and conveniently someone had decided to place his potential opponent under arrest before he could meet the future Prime Minister to the chosen location.

Almost fifty years later D'Azeglio explained:

You should also look at a duel as at the most serious matter. You could kill, or disable a man for life and condemn them to misery, or stab so many hearts together with their one. It might come a day such memory would weight like a mill-stone on your heart.

And I mean a real duel. A duel for show is a laughable, pitiful thing. So that both circumstances are something to regret. Avoid it as much as you can.

On to my question: would this attitude towards a duel "for show" be common in the mid XIX Century? Were duels for silly reasons, or duels where the two parts "staged" the confrontation common enough to warrant the distinction?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Why did the Ottoman Empire not fight to keep Egypt, Tunis, and Algeria the way they did for Lybia?

Okay, so during the Italo-Turkish war the Ottoman Empire put a lot of effort into using guerrilla warfare against the Italians, creating an entrenched resistance movement in Lybia that lasted so long that it fought against the Italians during World War 2, long after the Ottoman Empire had ceased to exist. However, when the Dey of Algeria beat up the French Ambassador to Algeria, the Ottoman Empire declared Algeria to be independent and let the French take it over. Likewise, when the French marched into Tunis, the Ottoman Empire just pretended that Tunis was an "autonomous region" of the Empire, and when the British invaded Egypt, the Ottoman Empire allowed looked the other way.

​

Why were these responses so different? The Ottoman Empire fought tooth and nail for Lybia, but completely ignored the loss of all of their other African territory. What made Lybia so special?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

There's a wikipedia page detailing roman expeditions to sub-saharan africa. Do we know what romans thought about these lands and their inhabitants?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romans_in_Sub-Saharan_Africa

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Did Spartans or any ancient Army "Work Out" like we do today?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Whenever two opposing teams face off, they're often given the colours of red and blue per default. Is this practice associated with the various wars between England and France?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-09-16

how did the British public react to the Kinderstransport rescue attempt in World War 2?

Recently I heard that before the outbreak of the first world war, many German children - Jews in particular - left their homes on Kindertransport to go to Britain until it was safe to return, similarly to the evacuation of British children from cities. Although this action was supported by the government, there would have still been a prevailing anti-German sentiment during that time. Given this, what was the reaction of the British public towards these German refugee children and how would they have been treated? would Brits have been angry that support was being given to foreign refugees despite British children needing safe housing too? Or would the people be generally content knowing that the children were fleeing persecution and would most likely die without their help?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Have there been daoist rulers in China? Did they rule in a very hands-off way?

The Dao de jing has lots of passages suggesting that rulers should be very hands-off. E.g.

When the government is too intrusive, people lose their spirit.

Act for the people’s benefit. Trust them; leave them alone.

Or

When the master governs, the people Are hardly aware that he exists

I'd be interested to hear whether there have been Chinese rulers that seriously tried to adhere to daoist principles, how they did this, and what consequences this had for the Chinese people.

(Dao de jing quotes from Mitchell translation quoted in https://fee.org/articles/liberty-and-small-government-in-tao-te-ching/)

2 Answers 2018-09-16

Were the Egyptians, Greeks and Romans smoking (anything)?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Why did the Nazi regime support Subash Chandra Bose ?

As and Indian myself, I have always wondered why the Nazi regime gave (what appears to me given their views on Gypsies and other coloured race) unexpected support to Subash Chandra Bose and his attempt to free India through armed struggle ? Was it purely tactical (enemy's enemy is a friend) or was there more to it ?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Exactly where was FDR when he found out about Pearl Harbor?

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Are there any other accounts about boudica other than the Romans?

The only source I’ve heard about boudica say they come from 2 Romans

Mainly her war crimes

1 Answers 2018-09-16

A book on history of education?

Could somebody recommend me a book on history of education? I thought that this is a major topic in history of ideas and was surprised how hard is to find a good treatment.

1 Answers 2018-09-16

Are Romans really aesthetically muscular? And is having a sculpted body an aesthetic goal back then?

Most if not all roman statues portrays a person in great shape so I am wondering if being muscular was a desirable norm for everyone or is it a natural consequence for people who’s not in the upper class. Also, what is the standard of beauty for men in the Roman times, is it their statutes? Because in some paintings, wealthy men is portrayed fat, do wealthy men back then care about how they look specifically? Thank you

1 Answers 2018-09-16

⯇ 2396 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start