How common was the practice of 'salting the earth' in ancient times ?

The phrase 'salting the earth' used to refer to an action which is needlessly vengeful... I believe that it dates back to ancient times when armies would salt the earth of conquered cities to prevent crops from growing there again (along with other things such as burning, pillaging, raping, sewing seeds of thorny plants (Thanks Dan!)).

However, it seems unlikely to me as salt is somewhat valuable and I'm not sure where they would have obtained such large quantities of the stuff to actually poison the soil.

I would like to know how common the practice was in ancient times and why it was practiced?

1 Answers 2018-07-25

What was being a soldier in the Kuomintang (KMT) like during the Chinese Civil War and the retreat to Taiwan?

My grandfather escaped to Taiwan with the KMT in 1949 and I'm curious about historical details around his journey, before, during, and after. I have stories that my mom has told me, but I don't know how much have been embellished. Some details I'm curious about:

  1. My mom said that my grandfather was "snatched up" to join the KMT (she said 他被抓到). Was this part of a practice of recruitment? My grandpa was the only one in his entire family to go to Taiwan, so I'm assuming he was the only one who was in the KMT army (and he had at least one brother who joined the CPC). I don't know if he was an officer or anything like that, and I don't know when he joined.
  2. He was from Qufu, Shandong. Since that's more northern, does that mean he joined the KMT earlier on and was with them as they were pushed south? Was there a difference between provinces (or geographic regions) in who joined the KMT vs CPC?
  3. What might've the journey from mainland China to Taiwan been like? From this previous question about 1949, /u/AsiaExpert mentioned that the retreat wasn't chaotic. What kind of boats did people take? Did people have to ask to go to Taiwan, or were soldiers and other KMT folks taken along no matter what they wanted?
  4. Are mainlanders who retreated to Taiwan considered refugees? I can see parallels on an individual level regarding fearing for their lives if they stayed in China, but an entire army and government system went over. Can it be considered some type of colonization? Both? Especially when over a million people fled to Taiwan.
  5. My grandmother (who my grandfather married) was a poor Hokkien Taiwanese girl – were "mixed" marriages like this less common back then?

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2018-07-25

[META] Wikipedia's downsides are well documented; what is a good alternative for a layperson trying to casually get an overview of a historical topic?

After reading the rules roundtables on Wikipedia, I don't want to use it for casual reading anymore. At the same time I don't know of good alternatives. I'm looking for something very casual. Britannica online can be good, but it is often just a brief sketch of a topic.

Edit: I wont reply to everyone individually, but I really appreciate the responses and suggestions for other sources.

4 Answers 2018-07-25

Ptolemy measuring the width of Eurasia

In an old post by /u/Itsalrightwithme, he mentions that Ptolemy had measured the landmass of Eurasia and Columbus thought it was actually shorter. How did Ptolemy measure the width of Eurasia? Or I am misunderstanding the post.

The post is at: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3vo2xj/did_christopher_columbus_really_think_he_landed/cxpakst/

EDIT: also what units was the circumference of the Earth measured in, as meters had not been invented yet.

1 Answers 2018-07-25

Why was King Edward VIII's marriage to Wallis Simpson opposed by the Church of England while previous kings were seemingly allowed to keep mistresses?

At the time, Edward VIII marrying a twice-divorced commoner was seen as morally unacceptable by the English church and public, as the King served as the head of the Church of England. If that is the case, then why were several of Edward's predecessors, such as his grandfather Edward VII, who had numerous affairs with mistresses, or William IV, who had ten children out of wedlock, allowed to become/remain King? Why was remarriage after divorce such an issue while adultery and having illegitimate children was not?

1 Answers 2018-07-25

The Sexual Offences Act 1967 partially decriminalised homosexuality in England and Wales. Why was Scotland not included given that it did not have a devolved parliament at the time? And why then did it take thirteen more years for The Crime Justice (Scotland Act) 1980 to do this?

1 Answers 2018-07-25

I want to write a screenplay or at least a treatment about the Business Plot of 1933, can anyone give me a detailed account or link me to one?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-07-25

Were the Voyages of Zheng He really just a big propaganda campaign?

Most of the time when people talk about the voyages of Zheng He they tend to interpret the voyages as either a direct analog to contemporary European exploration, or as some sort of morality tale of an outward looking China falling into isolation and stagnation. This always irritates me a little. First, of course, because it seems to be interpreting history mainly as a morality tale for more modern issues (e.g. eurocentrism, globalization, etc.). But more importantly, it seems like these interpretations overlook a far more parsimonious explanation for the whole project: Zheng He's voyages weren't about exploration or opening trade routes or even projecting China's power outwards. Rather, they were more about conferring legitimacy on the Yongle Emperor.

This would fit the context very nicely. The Yongle emperor had come to power in a coup, and that fact alone meant that he always had to deal with a serious challenge to his legitimacy. This was all the more the case because the emperor he overthrew, the Jianwen emperor, seemed to have been groomed more or less specifically for the purpose of establishing a legitimate line of succession for the Ming dynasty (right down to the name). And while, by and large, the Yongle emperor's position was secure, we know there were real consequences to this crisis of legitimacy. We know, for example, that many of the prominent Neo-Confucian scholars of the day either rejected the Yongle emperor or had to tie themselves into pretzels to accept his legitimacy. And we know that the Yongle emperor's rule was typified by a pretty strict regime of censorship aimed at stamping out such criticisms. There's even a rumor that Zheng He's voyages themselves were just a giant manhunt to find the (still alive) Jianwen emperor, and while these rumors are almost certainly false they do speak to the general theme of a ruler who needed to take extraordinary steps to secure his position.

In that context, a big symbolic gesture like sending a massive fleet to the ends of the earth to get tribute from as many people as possible would make a lot of sense. Not because establishing such tributary relations or establishing control over the Indian Sea trade were ever practical ends in and of themselves, but rather because doing so would prove to everyone that yes, indeed the Yongle emperor really was the rightful ruler after all.

But I haven't seen much in terms of historical analyses that look at the voyages from that angle. Does anyone have any insights into this issue?

1 Answers 2018-07-25

Were people in the medieval times (excessive torture methods days) less sensitive to pain?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-07-25

History communicator? Is this a thing?

I was recently watching a YouTube video from Because Science where the host, Kyle Hill, discussed the differences between scientists and science communicators. Science communicators like Kyle Hill and Bill Nye aren’t scientists like theoretical physicists or chemists,but their job is to take scientific concepts, theories, and principle that scientists have researched or discovered, and present them in understandable, relatable, and comprehensible ways for people who are not scientists.

My question being; is there a similar position/concept in the field of historical academia!

Follow up; if there is not, would such a position be beneficial or of value to the historical community in the sense that it can get more people interested in history?

(I.e I like watching the YouTube channel Extra History and it has often made me want to go out and do more research on the historical subjects they bring up. Would more stuff like this be beneficial?)

1 Answers 2018-07-25

The secession of the CSA was an action that must have taken an awful lot of planning and forethought. when did the concept of an independent south first arise, and when did it enter popular discourse? How well-known was it at the time of and leading up to secession?

1 Answers 2018-07-25

The release of Life of Brian in 1979 caused serious outrage on both sides of the Atlantic from conservative religious groups. But what about Jesus Christ Superstar, both the album (1970) and film (1973)? Was there a buzz? Tell me what was happening!

1 Answers 2018-07-25

What were the reasons and consequences of the Khmer Rouge anti-intellectual killings?

I understand the Khmer Rouge under Pol Pot applied one of the most massive anti-intellectual killings (supposedly even killing people who wore glasses because that suggested literacy) in modern history. Was the only reason for these killings to silence dissent and potential major rebel groups, or were there other less spoken reasons as well?

Akin to that question, what were the major consequences of these killings, beside the obvious? Did the higher ups in Pol Pot's regime have their own professional doctors or did they run into the Stalin-esque issue of not having anyone to treat them because they killed off the real/good doctors? Did the country during the Khmer Rouge reign suffer consequences other than less/no education and poorer health due to the lack of intellectuals?

2 Answers 2018-07-25

How Was Asperger's Syndrome/Autism Treated In The 1980s and 1990s?

How was Asperger's/Autism treated in those decades? Was it stigmatized? There wasn't an understanding of it in those decades, at least not like today. Can you tell me in great detail?

1 Answers 2018-07-25

Pre-Marian Roman soldiers bought their own gear, meaning certain divisions were made of wealthier men. How much of a difference in wealth and social status was there between the soldiers?

In particular, would a triarius or cavalry trooper come from an aristocratic background, or did they just have the kind of wealth that comes from saving income over a long military career?

At the end of a day would a Triarius and Hastatus, for example, fraternize, roll dice, get drunk together, etc? Or was the social division great enough that they kept to different groups within military camp life?

1 Answers 2018-07-25

Neutral countries in WW2

I know Switzerland was neutral in WW2 and it was seen as a “safe” zone for some minority’s persecuted in Germany, but my schools never went into detail on why the Nazi’s never invaded. Details?

1 Answers 2018-07-25

Why were all Chinese Wars to deadly?

5 of the 10 deadliest wars were in a China. Most of them were before the booms. Why was it that such high levels of their populations used to die on the wars? Most wars in Europe had average death tolls of at most 3 million. But why did China have death tolls like 30 million, 20 million and so on?

2 Answers 2018-07-24

Just how widespread and active were the Highland Clans in support of the Jacobite cause, did it differ in 1719 and 1745, and were there any notable clans who opposed the cause?

What rough % of the Highlands supported the wars with each attempt, did some who were active in 19 stay out for memory of losses suffered, or some who had been on the sideline decide to join up in 45?

If any were supportive still of George I and then II during the risings did they suffer attacks during and after or in turn take revenge on their rebellious neighbors or was the divide mostly between the Highlands and Lowlands instead?

1 Answers 2018-07-24

Were witches actually independent women who tried to do abortions, live by themselves, etc?

In Caliban and the Witch by Silvia Fredici we can read about how women who were accused of being witches were targeted because of their reproductive freedom. How true is it that witches were independent women with that promoted reproductive freedom?

1 Answers 2018-07-24

What processes made Damascus steel unique in the 12th-13th centuries CE? What price would a Damascus steel knife or sword command, compared to a typical European knife or sword? How would it compare to Toledo steel, or Scandinavian pattern-forged blades?

3 Answers 2018-07-24

Were there nazi soldiers that hid out and continue to fight after Germanys surrender in 1945?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-07-24

Did the Maya really worship Ixtab, goddess of suicide by hanging, or was she made up by Spaniards?

I read that Spanish missionaries and modern media could have fabricated the goddess Ixtab, and that her cult never existed among ancient Maya. To me it seems a very specific dominion for a goddess (suicide by hanging). In case her following existed, did the Maya have other gods for different forms of suicide?

2 Answers 2018-07-24

Did the Soviet Union have normal town and city police in addition to the NKVD?

How did the two interact?

1 Answers 2018-07-24

Is it true that 'America supported Pol Pot's rise to power' and if so what does that mean?

I've heard this accusation a lot but I'm not really sure what it means/if it's true/how true it is.

1 Answers 2018-07-24

Could a present-day Arabic speaker understand an Arabic speaker from the time of Muhammad?

3 Answers 2018-07-24

⯇ 2498 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start