The Western Roman Empire is glorified for many things especially for its military structure while the Byzantine Empire managed to prevail for at least 1000 years more after the fall of Rome and it does not get that much recognition. Why is this the case and how effective was the Byznatine military?

So one of the things that the Western Roman Empire gets a lot of fame for (among the many other things because many other powers throughout history wanted to replicate the effectiveness of the Roman Empire like Germany, Russia and so on) was its effective and highly disciplined military (which obviously had its own flaws becuase it was mostly focused on infantry but the Romans had the tendency to learn to advance their military throughout time and learned from their own enemies) and most of their military structure and tactics are still studied and replicated today.

Compared to the Western Roman Empire, we also have the Eastern Roman Empire, also known as the Byzantine Empire, which managed to survive during the Medieval period and to managed to maintain its power, economy and wealth through its trading system as Constantinople was literally like a bridge between Europe and Asia, and also through its own resources as the East was full of them.

Apart from that, Byzantine Empire once managed to conquer most of the Western area of the Europe again until it was conquered by the Christian powers, it managed to defend itself from countless enemies like the Turks and the Slavs and even the Crusaders (becuase apparently, in the Fourth Crusades, the Crusaders wanted to vent off their frustration and anger because they were in debt, to the Byzantine Empire which resulted in a large loss of land)

(And the Byzmatine empire managed to have its own technological advancements like better structured legal systems that were designed by the Roman Empire, the Greek fire and so on)

And very slowly, the Byzantine Empire started to lost most of its land (although it managed to stay in power and managed to keep its influence in the Medieval period for a while longer) until it feel in the year 1453.

While it may appear that the Byzantine Empire did not have an effective military like the Western Roman Empire did becuase it lost most of its land as time went on while the Western side managed to retain its lands and its borders for a while longer than the Eastern side, it still managed to defend itself from countless enemies as it was literally surrounded by them and yet, the Byzantine Empire managed to prevail for at least a 1000 more years after the Western Roman Empire fell.

So how effective was the Byzantine empire's military and how come the Byzatine empire does not get that much attention, whether in the historical/archeological community or in the general population?

2 Answers 2018-06-21

Did women fight in WW2?

Me and my friend had an argument about if women actually fought in WW2, or if the just helped make tanks and ammunition. Thank you!

1 Answers 2018-06-21

To what extent did ancient civilizations realize cultural appropriation was responsible for similarities in mythical gods and heroes vs the assumption that there was one pantheon recognized by different names in various places?

  • Ra/Apollo/Sol
  • Horus/Mars/Ares
  • Minerva/Athena/
  • Zeus/Jupiter/Varja
  • Hercules/Krishna
  • Aphrodite/Hathor/Venus

Did the greeks assume these similar or identical gods and heroes were the result of cultural appropriation, or was the assumption that the one-true set of gods just traveled the world and so all cultures had seen them? Any other scenarios the ancients discussed regarding these obvious similarities?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

What do you believe to be the main cause of the Salem Witch Trials?

Im studying this for some coursework and just want to see others opinions. I personally believe that hysteria related to religious beliefs and supression is to blame where as some people believe it was lust for power that caused people to accuse each other.

1 Answers 2018-06-21

Inspired by the turn the Western world seems to have taken in the past two years: how important was The Battle of Cable Street in suppressing the rise of British fascism? Why didn't it take hold in Britain as it did in other European countries?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

I had heard about an infamous serial killer from Colombia, and Wikipedia browsing eventually brought me to "serial killers by number of victims". Weirdly, the top four are all from South America. I don't mean to disparage, but is there a particular reason for this, or is it purely a coincidence?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

How did Volkswagen, a company founded by Hitler, get adopted by Allied culture so quickly and successfully less than a decade after WWII?

Volkswagen was formed in 1937 by, almost exclusively, the Nazi Party. In fact, the development of the VW ‘Beetle’ was considered Hitler’s pet project and was heavily involved – even Wikipedia lists Adolf Hitler as the founder. However, VW was introduced to the US in 1949, and by the early 1950s it “established itself as America’s budget car” the Beetle itself was selling “hundreds of thousands in the 1960s”. Concurrently, VW was also establishing a large market in the UK along with other allied countries.

Really what I am asking is how did a company “founded by Adolf Hitler” become popular in the western world just 5 years after WWII ended? I researched other companies “founded by Hitler” and saw that all notable ones were completely dismantled following the conclusion of WWII in all countries. Why was VWs case so different?

I'll add that I know companies like Hugo Boss and Fanta are very common despite their Nazi ties, but unlike VW, neither were actually created by the Nazi party

1 Answers 2018-06-21

Thursday Reading & Research | June 21, 2018

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Research is intended as an academic free-for-all, for the discussion of all issues historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • New developments or discoveries in the field

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • Your current research interests or projects

  • The goings on within the academy

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters historical discussion, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

5 Answers 2018-06-21

What did President Roosevelt mean when he referred to the USS Iowa as a happy ship?

Was reading up on the USS Iowa and came across this quote:

Iowa completed her presidential escort mission on 16 December by returning the President to the United States.[7] Roosevelt addressed the crew of Iowa prior to leaving by stating, "... from all I have seen and all I have heard, the Iowa is a 'happy ship,' and having served with the Navy for many years, I know—and you know—what that means."

What is he inferring?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

How big of a discovery is the new ancient city in Albania?

Just read today about a city in Albania that can be about 2000 years old but after seeing pictures it seemed to look like mostly rocks lined up. I am wondering if this discovery is big or are there many places like this already discovered around the world.

http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/discovery-of-lost-city-in-albania-thrills-archaeologists-06-18-2018

Some information. It may date back to 100-200 BC, it doesn’t seem like it is dug out completely yet. Maybe a follow up question is what could we expect to find?

2 Answers 2018-06-21

Why did the U.S. Senate hold hearings to investigate the Titanic disaster, given that it was a British ship operated by a British company

A subcommittee of the United States Senate held hearings in 1912 to investigate the RMS Titanic disaster. (https://www.senate.gov/reference/reference_item/titanic.htm Why did the Senate do so, given that it was a British ship, crewed mostly by British citizens, operated by the White Star Lines (a British company), and (on account of the disaster) the ship never visited the United States at all? Granted, many American citizens died on the ship, but the fact that hearings into this incident seem out of character for the limited government philosophy that I understand to have prevailed at the time.

2 Answers 2018-06-21

In James Clavell's novel Tai-Pan set in Hong Kong, many prominent characters including the protagonist are Scottish traders. How prevalent were Scots in East Asian trade? Were Scots renowned as traders in the British Empire?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

What do historians think of the documentary series "The World at War"?

I really like this documentary, esp the episodes about Stalingrad and Leningrad but I was wondering what historians think about it. Knowing that the documentary was made in the early 70s maybe a lot of viewpoints have changed or became more nuanced.

2 Answers 2018-06-21

When did beaches become a place to relax, have fun?

I'm in sunny Spain on holiday and whilst at the beach I realised I didn't put enough sun cream on; its bloody hot and I can feel my skin burning like bacon in a pan. Then I realised, no matter where you go in the world, if the sun has got his hat on, people will flock to the beach for a swim and a tan. Or in my case, a nice spot of sunburn.

This is purely a modern invention? Or have some cultures been doing it for centuries?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

In the Ordinance of Dunstaete the treaty text states that one can clear themselves by ordeal (ordal). Do we know what such an ordeal would have been?

The specific sentence in Old English is: "Ne stent nan oðer lad æt tihtlan bute ordal betweox Wealan [and] Ænglan, bute man ðafian wille."

Any secondary literature relevant to this would be very much appreciated!

edit: I realize I've misspelled Dunsaete and cannot edit the title - whoops!

1 Answers 2018-06-21

Is there a consensus among historians whether the 13th century 'children's crusade' actually happened? If it was a myth, do we have any idea where it sprung from, by whom, or why?

2 Answers 2018-06-21

During the era of classical music, was there any disdain for the rise of lyrical composers?

Assuming classical music as music from the classical period composed between about 1750 to 1820, what was the reaction to lyrical composers during the later impressionist period who combined poetry and lyrics with music of that time?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

Every time my Pa microwaved one of his hearing aids or dropped one in his gin, it was covered by the Australian Dept. of Veterans' Affairs. What access to government medical support could German veterans of WWII claim in East Germany?

I can't help but wonder whether veterans of the Wehrmacht faced social stigma from the GDR administration, both on the principle of having fought for Nazism and for the enormous prevalence of atrocities among German forces in the East (after all, thinking about a veteran's claim is surely different if there's about an 80% chance they're a war criminal, right?). Did these questions shape their access to services?

I know embarrassingly little about the day to day administrative functions of the GDR and its economy, so I may be thinking about this in entirely the wrong framework.

1 Answers 2018-06-21

Many theories and jokes exist, as well as tons of misinformation - How DID the Egyptians build the pyramids?

I have heard dozens of explanations from as many sources, and even a decent google search gave me mixed information. How did they do it?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

Why was the Union so important?

Forgive my ignorance. I’ve just become interested in the run up to the US Civil War. I just wondered, why did Lincoln and others have such fervour for preserving the Union at any cost? Was it not intended to be a union of freely associated states which meant that states could choose to withdraw if they wished?

Edit: I should say, of course abolition of slavery was something to fight for, but Lincoln seemed motivated by other factors as well, in fighting for the integrity of the Union? He was not originally wanting to force the abolition of slavery in the South, as wasn’t a Radical Republican - and considered the risk to the Union too great to attempt that? (I’m not sure why my question was downvoted, either?)

1 Answers 2018-06-21

Why is Romanian a Romance Language?

Can anybody hear explain to me how Romanian became to be considered a Romance language? I totally understand that the area was at one point a part of the Empire, but wasn’t Greek later the Preferred language of the east?

Not to mention the heavy Slavic and Ottoman influences of later eras, what caused the isolation of that area allowing Romanian as a derivative of Latin?

3 Answers 2018-06-21

Books about Soviet Union during 1920'to 1930'?

I am interested in understanding Soviet Union during the time after its creation and consolidation to somewhere around the great terror. I have read couple of books about Soviet history but they all go over this period in couple of pages. It would be very helpful if somebody has any recommendation to what should I read

1 Answers 2018-06-21

In the middle ages there was a period of witch hunt in Europe, why did it start? Who where the people that hunted them and what motivated them to do so? Wich where the methods to show proof that someone was a witch?

English is not my native language so i am not sure if my questions are clear.
I would like to know more about witch hunts on this period of Europe, specifically the origins and the people that partook on them.

1 Answers 2018-06-21

At the time of Shakespeare was he as influential as he is now?

Everyone has studied shakespeare at some point in their life, whether it be school or own interest, but did Shakespeare have as profound of an effect on society at the time as he does today? Did students study his literature at their schools?

1 Answers 2018-06-21

Where can I get a detailed historical account of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict that isn’t polluted by ideology or bias?

Title says it all.

1 Answers 2018-06-21

⯇ 2560 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start