What did the Europeans get out of the Meiji Restoration?

I’m curious because to my knowledge Japan did not levy any kind of territory to the Europeans. I’m not certain what resources Meiji period Japan had to offer to the ever industrializing colonial powers of the west. As I understand Japan had more exotic goods rather than raw materials which would be used in the age of industrialization.

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Do people in sub-Saharan Africa tend to identify more with their nationality or ethnicity?

Because many of the African borders were created arbitrarily and ethnic groups were split between various nations, is there more pride in one's ethnic background, national background or both? For example, the Hausa people are split between Nigeria and Niger.

1 Answers 2018-04-19

NWAAF North West African Air Force Rest Camps

Hi, does anybody have any information about Air Crew Rest camps in Tunisia in 1943? My father was based there for 8 months until Dec 1943 and according to his service records he was based at No 2 and No 4 Aircrew Rest Camps. From 1944 until 1945 he was based in Sorrento doing the same. I only have one postcard that he sent to my grandmother from Hammam Liv in Tunisia but can't find any information about the camps. Thanks, any help greatly appreciated!

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Are there any good works dealing with structural difference in patriarchy in settled vs. nomadic/semi-nomadic societies?

Alternatively, any insight on the topic you have would be very interesting. The reason I'm asking is because a lot of the patriarchal structures in settled societies seem to be based on the idea that "the father is the master of the house", which sometimes or often extends all the way to the structure of the government as a whole (filial piety, and so on).

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Was the year 1000 celebrated in a specific way ? New millenia and all ?

Y2K was a big deal. What about Y1k ?

2 Answers 2018-04-19

What did prostitutes in the middle ages do when they fell pregnant? How if at all, did they continue their careers?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Where and when did the concept of the “family wage” originate?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Do today's historians play any role in ensuring historians in later times have appropriate material to do their job?

2 Answers 2018-04-19

Pursuing history?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Why did Japan abolish slavery in 1590?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Why does nearly every form of art depict Jesus as having long hair despite there being no mention of this in the Bible?

2 Answers 2018-04-19

Why did no one invade the U.S. during or immediately after the civil war?

Title says it all. Doing the way there was chaos and after the militaries were worn out, depleted, and spread thin so why wouldn't a foreign government take the opportunity to conquer?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

What stopped the Soviet Union from launching a manned mission to the moon in the early weeks of December 1968 and thus beating the US to the moon?

I recently finished Robert Kurson's book Rocket Men describing the successful Apollo 8 mission, and in it he mentions how the Soviet Union had a good window for launching their own manned mission to the moon a couple of weeks prior to the launch of Apollo 8. The Soviet launch was ultimately scrapped, but the author does not elaborate as to why. Given how contested the space race was up to that point, and how the USSR had appeared to be winning, I'm curious as to why they wavered.

Was an early December 1968 launch planned by the Soviet Union? What stopped them from launching?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

How do I, as a layman, evaluate historical claims?

I see all sorts of historical claims on reddit and in books and just in the world in general. On reddit I have been told that there was no historical Jesus, wikipedia says that William the conquerer invaded britain in 1066, the hadith claim that Aisha married the Prophet Muhammad at age 6, Hitler claimed that Jews stabbed Germany in the back during WW1, and I recently read a biography of Mao Tse-tung that claimed he did not walk but was carried on a sedan chair for the long march.

Leaving aside which of these examples are in fact true, how do I personally go about judging the truth of an historical claim? Particularly as a layman who speaks none of the relevant languages, would be kicked out of an archeological dig, and hasn't even had access to a university library since graduating many years ago.

Not that it is right or fair to contrast history with physics, but with a physics claim I could concievably reproduce the observations and check the math. Even if I won't actually put in the work, the path for checking any claim seems reasonably clear. But, and this sounds inappropriately dismissive, with history it seems like at the root of everything we are trusting some unverifiable claim someone has told us somewhere along the way, and we just have to trust that the person making the claim as well as the original chronicler and everyone in between to correct in whatever they are asserting. That is to say, you tell me about the battle of thermopylae, but how do I evaluate your claims? Then you point to Heroditus as a source, but how do I evaluate his claims?

I really like history, and I don't like the idea of belittling it, but I can't shake the question of how is history not just a chain of mostly dead guys saying shit? And how can I personally distinguish legitimate from illegitimate claims?

4 Answers 2018-04-19

First hand accounts of Viking warfare?

I'm writing a research paper on Viking warfare, and while I have plenty of secondary resources to pull from, I'm struggling to find any primary sources to reference. Unfortunately all sources used have to be ones that could be found through my university's library, so it may be a long shot, but if there's the chance that any of them would work it would help me immensely.

1 Answers 2018-04-19

South African Nuclear Program?

How far along did the South African nuclear program go to reaching a bomb or a bomb able to deliver to a target? Any links or books on the matter?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Why is Europe considered its own continent and not just an extension of Asia?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

Books on Germanic / Celtic tribes?

Very interested in Germanic, Norse and Celtic tribes. Looking for any books regarding these subjects about the so called “barbarians”.

1 Answers 2018-04-19

I think I may have found a Native American rock mound, what should I do and who should I tell?

First off sorry if this is the wrong sub, but I thought maybe historians would know how to handle something that might have some historic significance... I found an obviously man made pile of geodes roughly the size of a grave in the woods in Kentucky (I don't want to be too specific of location because it's close to our house). The pile has some small trees growing through them, is on a hillside facing a creek. I'm worried it's a grave? Should I call the police or who? It's too dark tonight but I can take pictures of it tomorrow.

3 Answers 2018-04-19

During the era where Zeus was the dominant God, is there any documentation of someone being struck by lightning and surviving? How would that person be treated?

I can imagine a world where this person could be either ostracized in fear of associating with someone who was punished by the gods, or potentially thought of as immortal or magical and even revered, as someone who withstood the wrath of Zeus.

Thanks for any insight.

1 Answers 2018-04-19

When did the US start taking away the right to vote from convicted felons who already served their prison terms?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

How did China move past fax machine usage while Japan didn't, when the supposed reason is that Kanji (i.e. Chinese characters) were too complex for early word processing software?

This article claims that one reason that fax machines are still prevalent in Japan is

that computers, at the outset, never worked well for the Japanese. The country’s language — a mix of three syllabaries, with thousands of complex “kanji” ideograms — bedeviled early-age word-processing software. Until the early 1990s, Japanese was nearly impossible to type. Even today, particularly for older Japanese people, it’s easier to write a letter by hand than with a standard keyboard. Japan also relies on seals, called “hanko,” that are required for most official documents.

While the typing difficulties also apply to China, the country never got stuck in the fax stage, tech experts say.

Why did China overcome this and not Japan?

1 Answers 2018-04-19

How was diplomacy between the Ottoman Empire and the United States?

1 Answers 2018-04-18

After the Russian Revolution, and the treaty of Brest-Litovsk, many small nations formed, such as Armenia, Ukraine and Finland. How exactly did these short lived countries operate and did any of them have any real authority?

2 Answers 2018-04-18

Historiography of the Spanish Civil War - “If you wish to provoke a violent argument... it is enough to introduce the theme of the Spanish Civil War."

I was inspired to ask about the historiography of the Spanish Civil War by a recent post and discussion in /r/badhistory, as well as the news of a David Simon series focusing on the Lincoln Brigade. Several users in /r/badhistory made claims of bias by recent historians, and without breaking the 20yr rule I was hoping some users could comment on the study of this conflict.

Franco's Nationalists won the war (1936-1939) and held power in Spain until the transition to democracy (1975-19??). I would appreciate it if someone could do their best to explain how the study of the Civil War evolved in the post-Franco period and where it stood on the cutoff date (April 19th 1998).

Bonus question: I've read and enjoyed Hugh Thomas's The Spanish Civil War, but it always seemed strange to me that the most recommended work (that I could find) on this conflict was written in the 1960s. Are there other works that I am missing? Is the language barrier to blame?


  • I heartily recommend Hugh Thomas's book on the Spanish Civil War. It features information gleaned from interviews undertaken by the author with many witnesses of the war, and it is heavily, heavily footnoted. I believe there was an updated edition published in 2001. I am unfamiliar with Tomas's other work.

  • Quote: “If you wish to provoke a violent argument in a group of University students who are having a peaceful meeting, it is enough to introduce the theme of the Spanish Civil War." - Rafael Calvo Serer, La literatura universal sobre la guerra de España (1962)

-edited for formatting

1 Answers 2018-04-18

⯇ 2686 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start