Announcing the Best of March Award Winners

A little delayed due to other matters, but without further ado, here we go!

The votes are in!

This month /u/yodatsracist took top honors from both the Flairs and Users for answering "I saw an article today claiming that the "missionary" position derives its name from Native Americans/Africans who saw missionaries having sex. How true is this?"

In a very close second came /u/FlavivsAetivs, who tackled "I'm a Roman foot soldier at the battle of the Catalaunian fields (AD 451), what would I have been my arms and armour? How would this compare to my compatriots in the Eastern Empire?".

Taking the "The Dark Horse Award", recognizing the top voted non-flaired answer, is /u/erissays who answered "I've heard the Disneyified versions of Grimm's Tales Americans are familiar with are highly sanitized (RRHood and Grandma are eaten by the wolf,Snow White is about necrophilia,it's Cinderella's family, not steps- tormenting her, that kind of thing).Is this true? Were children the target audience?", no to mention some enlightening back-and-forth below.

And finally, this month's Excellence in Flairdom award goes to /u/Bentresh! You might recognize this username from answers on the Hittites...or Egyptians...or Israelites...or Babylonians...or all of the above in a single answer! Bentresh is one of the flairs who absolutely pounces on threads, and to stretch the jungle cat metaphor way too far, you've never seen paws like their command of primary sources and ability to pull out exciting quotes. Thanks, Bentresh!

The winners each receive a month of reddit gold in recognition of their accomplishment!

So as always, a big congratulations to the winners, and a big thanks to everyone who contributed to the subreddit in the past month! Also a reminder, if you want to nominate answers for the monthly awards, the best way to do so is to submit your favorite posts every week to the Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check them out here!

5 Answers 2018-04-10

Baltic Crusades

What are some good sources to look into to learn more about the Baltic Crusades?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

Why did Hitler invade Britain/France if his target lied mainly in the Soviet Union?

Clearly, Britain and France did not believe war would actually break out, so why did Hitler try to poke the hornet's nest?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

I’m watching this show called “hunting Hitler” on the History channel. Although I don’t have a great deal on knowledge on the subject, I’m still skeptical. Is there any actual compelling evidence that Hitler escaped Germany before the Soviets reaches Berlin?

2 Answers 2018-04-10

What's known about the compromise of 1877? The election of 1876 had the highest rate of participation in American history; did voters know going into the election that the fate of Reconstruction was at stake?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

Was the Meiji Restoration the revenge because the Tokugawa faction won during the Sengoku period?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

Were the Japanese medical experiments similar to the Nazianz medical experiments?

There was a question posed earlier about the Nazi medical experiments and was wondering about the Japanese expiriments.

1 Answers 2018-04-10

Did JFK serve in WW2?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-04-10

Why are historians sceptical about calling the medieval reconquest of Spain a 'reconquista'?

2 Answers 2018-04-10

Why does Homer's Odyssey and Iliad counts as historical source?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

I am hoping to write an honours dissertation on early 19th Century French culture and politics however my supervisor advises I avoid Napoleonic history as it is 'over-written'. Any ideas on topics that are both relevant to my interests but also relatively under-researched?

3 Answers 2018-04-10

Why was was the Soviet (and later that of Russian Republic) economy so badly affected by market reforms in late 1980's/1990's but not during the period of NEP when it transitioned from War Communism into the market economy?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

In retrospect, how certain was an Allied victory over the Axis? Was it clear cut, or were there real turning points that the Axis Powers could have used to win the war?

It seems there's always a lot of conflicting information surrounding the forces of the Allied and Axis nations in WWII, with it either being a neck and neck conflict or a completely one-sided campaign once the US entered the fray. Obviously neither are going to be representative of the entirety of World War II, which brings me to reiterate my question:

How certain was an Allied victory over the Axis Powers? Logistically speaking, could the Axis have pulled off a win if certain pivotal moments went the other way? Or would it have led to a more drawn out and bloodier Allied win regardless?

4 Answers 2018-04-10

How effective were Ming Dynasty Rattan Shields? This source claims they are almost musket proof but I feel like that can't be right?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2018-04-10

When and how did the Ottoman Navy switch from oared galleys to sailing ships?

My limited understanding is that they preferred to use galleys long into 16th and 17th century, and where slowly switched to sail ships. Do we have an idea why (if it's true)?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

What are some extract wedding gifts Vikings gave to each other?

Extravagant*

1 Answers 2018-04-10

In Leonardo Da Vinci's 1503 Map of Valdichiana there is a large body of water that no longer appears on satellite imagery. What happened to the large lake at the center of the map?

Here is the map for reference. It appears that the large lake and riverbed is now covered in farmland. What caused this change in landscape?

4 Answers 2018-04-10

Did Friedrich Nietzsche unintentionally help creates German Facism?

And if not what did?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

The Roots of Yodeling in American Country Music?

Generally speaking when I hear about the roots of country music most people point to the Scots-Irish in Appalachia which does explain a lot of country-western’s sound. However, the Irish don’t yodel and that leads to my question: how did yodeling become popular in early country music, specifically in the country-western “cowboy” music?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

How seriously taken is the claim that Operation Barbarossa was a preemptive strike?

In most Western education I've been taught that Hitler's invasion of the Soviet Union was a purely aggressive action and that Stalin was unprepared for war, and he was even caught off guard. However, I have begun to read more on the historiography and it appears that many Russian historians give credence to the idea that Stalin was planning to attack Hitler in 1941, and Hitler's invasion was mirrored by similar plans in the Stalin camp. I understand that the historical consensus leans more on the mainstream view, but how fringe is the other theory? Is it merely unorthodox, or outright wacky?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

How do Historians Assess the New Deal?

I've recently heard a growing number of Conservatives argue that Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal prolonged the Great Depression, or otherwise made it worse. Politics and counter-factual history aside, is there any truth to these claims? What is the typical historiography opinion of the New Deal?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

Japanese perspective of Pearl Harbor attack

Around 2003, I read a small blurb in the recent news section in Time Magazine about some wreckage that was discovered that Japan views as evidence of America being the aggressor before they attacked Pearl Harbor. That was the first time in my life that I had ever heard of anything contrary to the "surprise attack" narrative we are taught in America (I'm American).

I'm very skeptical of the claim that America was the first to attack Japan, but I'm having trouble finding any information about it. So far my best guess is that Japan views the sinking of a small submarine by the USS Ward hours before the attack as being the first strike that justifies the attack on Pearl Harbor.

And beyond the details of the wreckage that may be evidence of who attacked first, does anyone know how the attack on Pearl Harbor is viewed in Japan?

Thank you.

2 Answers 2018-04-10

Are there any good book (for layman) about climate changes and their impact on the course of human history/prehistory? Hopefully with maps.

Climate changes are often mentioned in history books as impacting human societies around the world. E.g., Little Ice Age, some desert not being a desert during this period, some region dried up during this period prompting immigration, etc.

So I thought having a comprehensive book on the topic should be nice. I am particularly interested in Europe, North Africa, Middle East, Central Asia and China. Hopefully with maps showing the climate change region-by-region. Online sources too would be great.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2018-04-10

In World War 2, American and British Sherman crews would camouflage their upgraded 76mm guns using fake muzzle brakes to make themselves less of a target for German tanks. How effective was this?

1 Answers 2018-04-10

France used to be by far the most populous country in Europe but isn't any longer. What happened?

The area encompassing modern France is thought to have had ~three-four times the population of England and between 1.5-2 times the population of Germany in the middle ages (see https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/source/pop-in-eur.asp). By World War I, this had changed drastically, with the population of Germany being larger and that of England being around equal in size. This had dramatic effects on the ability of France to go toe to toe with Germany in the Franco-Prussian war and in World War I. Presuming that the early industrialization of England gave it a heads up in population growth, why was there then such a big change in the relative populations of what is now Germany and what is now France? I realize that this is a complex question, but I think it is very interesting and wanted to offer it up for discussion.

2 Answers 2018-04-10

⯇ 2705 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start