A person's origin or nationality in historiography

Hey,

I was reading some bios in wikipedia, and I was wondering about the style and fact of the person's origin/nationality. So if the person was born in the land Prussia, is it correct today to present him as German?

Examples:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johann_Sebastian_Bach "was a German composer and musician". But there was no Germany at that time (as I understand)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludwig_van_Beethoven "was a German composer". But he was born in the "Duchy of Brabant" part of the Holy Roman Empire.

The one I found to be the most neutral was:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolfgang_Amadeus_Mozart "Born in Salzburg" Which is part of the Holy Roman Empire

Does not say "Austrian".

later it details "This was the capital of the Archbishopric of Salzburg, an ecclesiastic principality in what is now Austria"

But NO nationality.

Edit: grammer

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Ramesses II had a very distinct physical appearance, (red hair, exceptionally tall for his time, aquiline nose) is this something other Egyptians exhibited? Where did it come from?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Islamic History Book Suggestions?

Hey all, I'm looking to brush up on MENA history. Any suggestions on literature regarding Pre-Ottoman Islamic histories. Thanks a ton!

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Is there a possibility that John G. Trump has used Nikola Tesla’s work after Tesla’s death?

Hi!

I have been reading about Nikola Tesla and something caught my eye. After Nikola Tesla died in his hotel room on January 7, 1943, John George Trump, an electrical engineer, was asked by the Alien Property Custodian agency to analyse the works of Tesla that were seized by the FBI.

Dr. Trump found nothing of note and wrote: source 1 & 2 (January 9,1943)

[Tesla's] thoughts and efforts during at least the past 15 years were primarily of a speculative, philosophical, and somewhat promotional character often concerned with the production and wireless transmission of power; but did not include new, sound, workable principles or methods for realizing such results.

Not to belittle Dr. Trump’s work and career before analysing Tesla’s work, but it appears that his career appears to change gear after this date, to the point where, after his death in 1985 his work of the past 3 decades is especially referenced as being impressive.

As his lab director James Melcher said:

"John, over a period of three decades, would be approached by people of all sorts because he could make megavolt beams of ions and electrons – death rays. ... What did he do with it? Cancer research, sterilizing sludge out in Deer Island [a waste disposal facility], all sorts of wondrous things. He didn't touch the weapons stuff."

So at this point, i find it peculiar that Dr. Trump is especially credited for his work from the 1940s onwards, and i can’t help but think it is fair to ask if Dr. John George Trump has perhaps used Nikola Tesla’s work, which he investigated, and presented it as his own, while stating that the work he investigated did not feature anything worth of note.

I would also like to draw attention to the fact that Tesla was thought to have a “death ray”. And James Melcher mentions that Dr. Trump had a death ray.

Another source used nap.edu

2 Answers 2018-04-08

I’m watching Troy:Fall of a City on Netflix. They have cast black actors to play Achilles and his Myrmidon Warriors. It’s a cool way to differentiate them from the other Greeks, but is there any historical reference for this?

2 Answers 2018-04-08

The U.S. Constitution, the 2nd amendment, and the "comma debate"

I remember being told multiple times, by both teachers and a few lawyer family members, that when the U.S. Constitution was sent out to each state for ratification there were "typos" in some of the copies. Most notably, the comma after Militia in the first sentence of the 2nd amendment was missing on some State copies.

From a legal perspective this could change/shape the debate over gun control currently taking place drastically. However, I am unable to find any real reference to this "discrepancy".

Is this just some "wive's tale" I've been sold my entire life?

2 Answers 2018-04-08

Did the Pythagoreans believe that everything can be brought down/explained in numbers?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | April 02, 2018–April 08, 2018

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

4 Answers 2018-04-08

When US states were seceding right before the Civil War, did the Union have a plan to evacuate D.C. if Maryland, a slave state, decided to join the Confederacy?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

In Greek mythology, Atlas was sentenced to hold up the sky. Why then do so many depictions of him show him holding the entire Earth?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Etymology of the term nappy used in a derogatory fashion (US History might be able to help)

DISCLAMER I do not condone the use of derogatory terms. I am purely interested in this from an academic sense.

For those of you that don't know nappy is a term used to describe the hair of people of African origin and is commonly seen as derogatory. I'm looking into the etymology of the term because I'm interested to see if it connects to the use of nappy to mean diaper. This diaper meaning usage is common in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa and Ireland from what I can tell. I've found a wikipedia entry saying

"These words (nappy and bushy) were originally used by slaveowners, as far back as the 1800s, to grotesquely describe the hair of their slaves." citing

West, Willis (1922). History of the American People. Boston, MA.: Allyn and Bacon. p. 1-819.

but I can't find that book or other sources beyond wikipedia or a few nerd mom blogs about the use of nappy vs diaper and dont cite any sources. Basically I'm wondering if the term originated as calling someone shit head cause babies shit in diapers and the hair is on their head or something to that extent. I know that the US wasn't on the list of countries that use nappy to mean diaper but it may have been in the 1800's and then diaper replaced it as the derogatory term took primary definition locally.

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Protection of churches in WW1

Now, during World War One there was massive amounts of damage done to towns, buildings, and almost everything. My question is, was there an attempt to avoid destroying religious symbols like a church or a cathedral?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

During the rise of the Nazi Party and Hitler's aggression in Europe, what reasons did many Americans have, other than antisemitism, for being Nazi sympathizers?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Why didn't Japan's 1931 invasion of Manchuria result in a war between the Japanese and Chinese?

Manchuria (if I've understood what I've read) was Chinese territory at the time of the invasion. Why didn't it lead to a Sino-Japanese war immediately, starting in 1931, separate from everything else in WW2? Why did the Chinese just let them have it, and no war ensued until the Marco Polo Bridge Incident in 1937?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

[Meta] Is there a way to report the number of comments in a thread more truthfully?

This is a very common problem in this subreddit. For example, this thread says there's 18 comments as of this writing, but in reality it only contains 4 notices that a comment has been deleted and a mod's comment explaining why a comment has been deleted. There's no actual content whatsoever.

I understand this is probably a technical issue over which the mods have little control but maybe they could report it higher?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Bicycles seem simple to design, require no power (engine) so it might have been a good alternative to chariots and horses back then. Why did it took so long for bicycles to be invented?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Did Egyptian Pharaoh’s live a “rockstar” life? How much were they worth in currency and what was their lives like?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

I have read that "After 1933, all further research in sexual sciences was discontinued, and Czechoslovakia became the last remaining country, where sexology was to be studied/researched freely." How much truth there is to this statement? What can you tell me about Czechoslovak Sexual Sciences?

edit: I meant to say "discontinued in Germany" in the title, of course. Sorry for that mistake!

I'm not sure whether I have phrased my question correctly, it is not a direct citation, rather just a rough outline from my memory.

This is a topic that interests me a lot, as a Czech and a gay guy.

I tried looking it up on google (in Czech and English), but I didn't find much concerning sexual sciences in the pre-WW2 period. Most of the works I found were about sexology during Socialism. A lot of them mentioned the prewar period, but very briefly, mostly they just compared the prewar sexology, which according to them was mainly researching "sexual aberrations", to the sexology of socialism, which focused on gender theory, scientifical emancipation, etc.

Thank you a lot for your potential answers!

2 Answers 2018-04-08

Was the historic Jesus likely to have been literate?

2 Answers 2018-04-08

Did medieval soldiers have PTSD?

Disclaimer: I saw this question in another subreddit but nobody did a good job answering the question.

I would’ve figured they’d have it much worse since fighting was closer and some battles and sieges could last days/months/years.

1 Answers 2018-04-08

It is estimated that about 50000 Filipino and Japanese war brides immigrated to the US immediately after WW2. How were these interracial marriages perceived back then, especially with the ban on mixed marriages in many states?

2 Answers 2018-04-08

Why did the Roman Infantry of the late Empire switch to the Spartha?

My understanding is the late empire had alot more cavalry and the Spartha and oval shield is better for cavalry. Why didnt the heavy infantry stick with the scutum and gladius?

How did Roman tactics change when the infantry switched to the Spartha and oval shield? Do the lines have more space between, etc.. ?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

When did Egyptians start to call themselves Masreyyin?

I haven't been able to find any information on this either on AskHistorians or elsewhere, probably because of the difficulty involved in understanding contemporary ethnicity around the world, let alone in understanding ethnicity as it applied to people in the past.

With that said, my understanding is that Egyptian identity in the modern era is pretty complicated and involves different ideas about their status as Arabs, as Muslims (and as Christians), and as heirs to a 5000 year old civilization, but that they refer to themselves as Masreyyin (or something along those lines).

This looks like more of a national, i.e., 21st century style nation-state-citizenship based identity than anything else. I also understand that ethnicity and other types of group identity take many different forms across the world!

But assuming Masreyyin serves as the primary identity of the people of Egypt apart from their religious identities, when did this take effect? I've read that Ancient Egyptians referred to themselves as "People of Kemet" and I believe modern Copts refer to themselves as Niremenkimi.

TL;DR: Did the Islamic conquest of Egypt transform local identity from Niremenkimi / Rmt-n-kmt to Masreyyin? How long did the process take? What did this transformation look like?

Thank you for reading and answering my long and probably difficult question!

1 Answers 2018-04-08

In the Roman Empire, were their notable high-status people who had ethnic backgrounds that today we would generally categorize as black African, Indian or East Asian?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

Was “fragging” (or more generally insubordination) as common during WWI and 2 as it was during the Vietnam War?

A recent thread brought the question to mind using a particular episode of Band of Brothers as the reference. I know that troops can and will get frustrated with their COs but I am curious if there are nearly as many documented instances.

As an aside, did government censorship and propaganda play a role in the public perception of such conduct did occur?

1 Answers 2018-04-08

⯇ 2709 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start