I consider myself pretty ignorant regarding history in general, is there some book you would recommend that can give me general knowledge about history in different parts of the world in different timelines?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

The French had used cannons effectively in the Hundred Years War. The Spanish use of gunpowder weapons was vital for the conquest of the Americas. Why aren't they considered Gunpowder Empires like the Ottomans, Safavids and Mughals?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

Can someone recommend me some books to help me understand the situation in the Democratic Republic of the Congo?

I'm looking for reading on the history of the DRC so that I might better understand the situation today and in the past 20 years. I know that this will come close to the 20 year rule, but if anyone could point me to some reading resources then I'd be very grateful. I have nearly no background knowledge of the country or the continent, but I don't mind dense reading.

Thanks!

4 Answers 2018-02-17

Was Jesus buried?

I've been in a discussion about Jesus and I was wondering what most historians think about Jesus's burial. I know that ancient Roman crucifixion practices had the criminals either left on the crosses for days or buried in shallow mass graves and that Jesus's crucifixion was Roman and not Jewish, and I also know because of Josephus that Rome would adhere to local tradition (which would be for crucified Jews to be buried before sunset). So is it more likely that Jesus was buried by Jews or given a dishonorable burial/left on the cross?

3 Answers 2018-02-17

How did Leonhard Euler and his contemporaries actually pronounce his surname?

This question has been bothering me for a while. Here’s the thing:

So my question is: which is more historically accurate? “Eiler” or “oiler”? I found the only relevant reply here that says that because of the phonetical shift in German, the pronunciation of “eu” has changed from “ei” to “oi,” but since the reply is unsourced, I take it with a grain of salt.

1 Answers 2018-02-17

when did different levels of Germany know they were going to lose?

I know that after Stalingrad many knew that WWII was now a losing effort, but I was wondering at what points or after what set backs different groups in Germany knew/accepted that they were facing defeat (i.e. military high command vs. commons soldiers vs. German people on the home front vs. political leadership). I assumed that it wasn't a collective realization at once but maybe I'm wrong.

1 Answers 2018-02-17

Wjat are se common misconceptions people have about vikings, as in the actual raiders, and not the norse people as a whole?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

Why and when did the 's' take on its shape in printed material?

So, I've read that the curious 'f'-shaped letter 's' that is so classic to 18th century printed material (is there a word for it?) was made because the 's' shape was too weak, and so the 'f'-shaped letter was used instead as it held up better. First, is this true? Second, when did it stop being is use and why?

What brings me to ask is that I'm reading some old Louisiana legislature and in all the English-language text, they use the 'f'-like symbol, but in all the French-language text, they use our modern 's'. Crazy! Now, I'm pretty sure this is a later reprint, but why reprint the text with two different 's' keys?

Anyway, just wondering if some print historian could answer my strange query. Was it some new invention in typing? A style change?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

Did crew members on some of the most famous European voyages (Magellan, Columbus, British and French ventures to North America) leave journals of their trips?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

How do cities die?

This is probably a naieve and foolish question. But I'm genuinely curious.

I've lived in big cities my whole life. They feel so strong and lasting and permanent. But it's not uncommon for us to find the abandoned ruins of big cities.

I can easily imagine how a town or village could dry up.. But a thriving metropolis?

2 Answers 2018-02-17

German bunkers on the coast during WW2 should’ve had 48 hours of ammunition, but they only had 3 hours worth. If it was such a critical position to defend, why the shortage of ammunition?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

It is said that Nazi Germany ran on debt, but who were the biggest creditor of the regime and what happened to the loans?

One reason why Hitler was so keen to push for war with Poland and then the Soviet Union was because Nazi Germany was a card house build on debt and the Nazis needed the revenue from the plundered countries to keep the show going. That begs the question, where did the Nazis loan the money from and what happened to these loan after their defeat?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

Saturday Showcase | February 17, 2018

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

4 Answers 2018-02-17

Did Alexander Hamilton Ever do Something Scandalous or "Bad"?

I have a debate in school, and I was assigned to Jefferson's side in Hamilton vs. Jefferson. Aside from the "corrupt" ideologies that you could say Hamilton held, is there anything scandalous or really bad that he got caught for? I've been researching but I haven't found anything worthy yet.

3 Answers 2018-02-17

Since Western Europe only saw the Holy Roman Empire as the only Empire, what polity did they refer to Byzantium as?

2 Answers 2018-02-17

Are Etruscan 'Aiser' and Norse 'Aesir' related in anyway?

I came across a video today (https://youtu.be/wtzg5uEpiOI) that said the Etruscans called their gods Aiser. That sounded remarkably similar to the popular Norse word for their gods 'Aesir'. That got me to wondering if these two groups of people are related in anyway, or if their languages are related. Or is this just a case of coincidence, of words coming from completely different roots just sounding similar? I'm posting in the Linguistic sub too, but I would appreciate getting any historical insights, if any, on this.

1 Answers 2018-02-17

At which point did Catholicism become the largest branch of Christianity? At which point did it become the majority?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

Where does the 'Nero played the fiddle while Rome burned' story come from? Does he deserve the blame most ancient historians place on him, is it a bum rap, or do we just not know?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

Early Americans went through many compromises to get free and slave states to get along. Was "treating slaves better but keeping slavery" ever tried?

Ever since the uproar about "civil war" statues being torn down. I've been fascinated with early American history. (Also slightly terrified.)

The more I look into it the more it seems like most Americans didn't want to end slavery on any moral grounds but because they wanted small farms run by white men not huge plantations staffed by black slaves.

This question is probably going to bring the worst kinds of people out of the woodwork but I am pretty interested in the answer.

1 Answers 2018-02-17

What effect did Aristotle's tutoring of Alexander the Great have on him?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

I am a Soviet Army soldier fighting in 1980s Afghanistan. I have been captured by the mujahedeen. How will I be treated as a prisoner?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

I was listening to NPR recently while they were playing world music, mostly European, I was not able to tell it was not American. How much of that is due to immigrants bringing their music to the US and how much has to do with the exporting of US culture?

1 Answers 2018-02-17

How heavily did the loss of children affect families in the 1800s?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-02-17

If I were a sexually active gay man in early 19th century England that never actually broke the anti-sodomy laws how open could I be?

I was reading recently about a missionary that was sacked over allegations of homosexual activity, and was kind of surprised to learn that nothing he was alleged to have done was actually illegal at the time. My questions are, if you weren't actually breaking the law could you still get in trouble? How and from who? Could you be pretty much open about it?

Secondary question: in what situations were people actually prosecuted for sodomy? It seems like a difficult crime to get convictions for.

2 Answers 2018-02-17

Bronze Age Collapse brought on by the "Sea Peoples".... Really???

I find it bizarre and almost a historical cop-out that the Bronze age collapse has been widely chalked up to being brought on by the “Sea Peoples”... Recently, I watched a youtube video about the bronze age collapse (feeling ridiculous for never having studied it before) and I heard the video lend the wordly devastation to something called the “Sea Peoples” and immediately my mind’s record scratched loudly and sharply. Insert slack-jaw dumbfounded face. Finishing that video, I went on to watch a longer documentary about the collapse, and it was almost embarrassing watching these scholars and historians chalk things up to these Sea Peoples. Then I took to google to read as much as I could about both the collapse and the Sea Peoples but NOTHING managed to clear anything up. It all resembles some sort of historical conspiracy theory.

Anyway, go Wikipedia “Bronze Age Collapse” and scroll down a little ways to find: “Prior to and during the Bronze Age Collapse, Syria became a battle ground between the empires of the Hittites, Assyrians, Mitanni and Egyptians, and later the coastal regions came under attack from the Sea Peoples.

Follow the link for Sea Peoples and you get: “The Sea Peoples are a purported seafaring confederation that attacked ancient Egypt and other regions of the East Mediterranean prior to and during the Late Bronze Age collapse (1200–900 BC).” As well as “the Sea Peoples are conjectured to have sailed around the eastern Mediterranean and invaded Anatolia, Syria, Canaan, Phoenicia, Cyprus, and Egypt toward the end of the Bronze Age.” And to aid in the mystery “The Sea Peoples remain unidentified in the eyes of most modern scholars, and hypotheses regarding the origin of the various groups are the source of much speculation.”

In what I’ve learned between these various sources,these Sea People’s are said to have come from the Sea, the water, with origins unknown and undocumented, and the little “records” there are record these people being not so much an army of soldiers bent on destruction, but migrating families with women and children and wagons of their belongings. They didn’t appear to fight on the Sea very often, either, even though the wikipedia explanation compares them to a type of pirate. As it is currently reported, there was no decorated pottery to prove culture or ethnicity, no decorated ships or flags or clothing or jewelry or shrines, relics, gods, or anything left behind to prove a Sea Peoples... And this description of a culprit is supposed to be the very same that brought on “the cultural collapse of the Mycenaean kingdoms, the Kassite dynasty of Babylonia, the Hittite Empire in Anatolia and the Levant, the Egyptian Empire; the destruction of Ugarit and the Amorite states in the Levant, the fragmentation of the Luwian states of western Asia Minor, and a period of chaos in Canaan. The deterioration of these governments interrupted trade routes and severely reduced literacy in much of the known world. In the first phase of this period, almost every city between Pylos and Gaza was violently destroyed, and many abandoned.”

And I think the idea of the Sea Peoples was originally provoked by an Egyptian King/god, bragging about a victory over them, which I don’t find trustworthy at all with their egos and godliness on the line.

I’m trying to study as much about this as I can, I am hooked. But I’m also just a regular joe and my mind may not be wrapping things up properly. AM I MISSING SOMETHING CRUCIAL IN ALL THIS? From what I’m understanding, believing the bronze age collapse was brought on by these Sea Peoples is no different from trying to believe martians did it all. I am open minded, I really am, but this one is rich.

I’ve actually been provoked to study the old Testament and The Exodus further, because it somewhat shockingly jives with the collapse if you can open your mind to it.

Open to all info and critiques and yada yada!

1 Answers 2018-02-17

⯇ 2814 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start